4 ms·
This article is a good answer to "how can CEOs be worth all that money they get paid?"
by WalterBright 4y ago
This article is a good answer to "how can CEOs be worth all that money they get paid?"
- dsr_ 4y agoIt seems to provide the answer of "Clearly, not all of them are."
- WalterBright 4y agoNobody said "all".
- pwinnski 4y agoYou did technically use the word in your statement ("...all that money,") but you also implied that the example of James Daunt said more than "James Daunt is a good hire if you run a bookstore company," which might or might not be true.
- WalterBright 4y ago> You did technically use the word in your statement ("...all that money,") You know better. "money" is not "them", if you need more elucidation.
- pwinnski 4y agoOkay, that's twice you've taken the easy response and ignored the actual meat of critique. I think that's indicator enough that you're unserious.
- WalterBright 4y agoYour addition of "all" was the meat of your critique. It's a rhetorical device, meant to be argumentative, not substantive. "which might or might not be true" is yet another variation of the same rhetorical argumentative trick.
- dsr_ 4y agoIf some of them are, then maybe all of them are. But whoever was in that role prior was not, or else Daunt would not have been an improvement. So... not all CEOs are worth paying outrageous amounts for, and the world track record on making that decision is not very encouraging.
- WalterBright 4y agoAgain, nobody said "all".
- mempko 4y agoWhat did the CEO do? He gave control to the workers. They got to choose what books go where and on what shelves. Most businesses can learn from this. Give control to the people who care. This is how most co-ops work and why they are special. Gaming world has Valve following a similar model. The reason why CEOs have so much impact is because they are at the top of a tree and make all the important decisions. this isn't a consequence of the amazing (or terrible) nature of CEOs, it's just the outcome of the corporate structure. With a little imagination, we can imagine other corporate structures...
- WalterBright 4y agoIt's easy to imagine other structures. Whether they'll work better or worse is something else entirely. Business has evolved into the current structure, and since in a free market it's survival of the fittest, it appears to be optimal. After all, businesses exist to make money for their owners, not CEOs.
- mempko 4y agoBut what if we don't have a free market, never have, and never will have. Also most misunderstand 'survival of the fittest' which Darwin never said. Evolution is about creatures fitting to their environment. If you have a complex environment, you have complex animals. If you have a simple environment, you have simple animals. It has nothing to do with 'robustness' or 'strength' or any notion of 'good'. Similarly, if free markets are an optimizing system, they are a deeply flawed one. The constraint of spot trades and singular prices. And of course externalities, make them poor at optimization where it matters. So if we had free markets (we don't), what 'optimal' is very constrained and simple relative to what people need.