3 ms·
> if the throttle is mechanical If the throttle is mechanical. So yeah, I guess there's a window of time there where EFI became the norm but before throttles w
by vel0city 4y ago
> if the throttle is mechanical
If the throttle is mechanical. So yeah, I guess there's a window of time there where EFI became the norm but before throttles were also electronic, so late 80s to early 2000s. I imagine the majority of cars on the road today in the US are fully electronic.
> The normal failure mode of a carburetor leads to an engine that doesn't run, and not the opposite.
I've personally experienced carburetors getting stuck open, usually on abused/unmaintained lawn equipment. I do agree the usual failure is that it gets gummed up and inefficient in its atomization, but a stuck open carb isn't impossible. Either way, a carb that fails and you suddenly lose power can also cause problems when unexpected.
> You can get a lot better efficiency from a carbureted engine than most people think.
Yeah, a well-tuned and well-maintained carburetor isn't absolutely horrific in efficiency. But it'll still pale in comparison to the combustion efficiency that can be had in a GDI engine.
> As for safety, I'd rather have freedom.
Cool, and feel free to drive that freedom car in your freedom yard. Please keep your freedom emissions in your freedom air though instead of polluting your neighbors. When you're driving on the public streets there's more than just you out there.
- userbinator 4y agoCool, and feel free to drive that freedom car in your freedom yard. Please keep your freedom emissions in your freedom air though instead of polluting your neighbors. When you're driving on the public streets there's more than just you out there. Freedom includes doing things that others don't like --- and tolerating the opposite too. Otherwise you're just encouraging an authoritarian socialist dystopia.
- vel0city 4y ago> Freedom includes doing things that others don't like --- and tolerating the opposite too. So I should tolerate people driving on public streets without insurance and without a license? I should tolerate people driving the wrong way on the highway? I should tolerate whatever emissions come from the tailpipe of someone's car? I should tolerate sompeone driving a car that nobody has touched the brakes on for a decade and they're about ready to fail at any moment? I should tolerate people driving at night without headlights on? I should tolerate people driving at any blood alcohol level? All of these are laws which limit freedom in the name of safety. You're arguing you'd prefer freedom over safety. Personally, I prefer all of these tradeoffs of freedom over safety, at least when driving on public streets. If you don't like these regulations, don't drive on public streets. Requiring a driver's license, having emissions controls, creating traffic standards for driving on public streets are examples authoritarian socialist dystopia I guess.
- eimrine 4y agoAs far as I have understood, the previous commenter used to talk about FLOSS only (which is rather wise then not if you do value RMS' philosophy) and you have turned the discussion into absurd (kind of driving without license which has nothing to do with wiseness).
- vel0city 4y agoTo me they brought it to that extreme when referencing authoritarian socialist dystopia when originally talking about carburetors. Hard to not see it going that direction about rights/freedoms when not having the ability to tune your carb means you're encouraging an authoritarian socialist dystopia.
- eimrine 4y agoIt has been meant that there is no any car with FLOSS injector software. Every injector hardware devise has proprietary software. How on Earth can I drive an injector car if any proprietary software is not an option for me?
- vel0city 4y agoThey weren't talking about FLOSS here. They weren't talking about free or proprietary software, they wanted no software > Personally, I prefer no computer control. They're not arguing for free software controlling their car, they're arguing for no software controlling the car. No software controlling the car means generally less safe cars with higher emissions on the road. Higher emissions hurt the people around them. Not having common safety systems like ABS and traction control make the cars harder to operate on normal roadways, leading to a higher likelihood of collisions. They're arguing they should be free to operate less-safe cars which emit higher emissions on public roadways, and that everyone around should just accept it. Arguing otherwise is arguing for an authoritarian socialist dystopia.
- eimrine 4y ago