3 ms·
Copper has long been the choice for piping because it's soft enough to bend without cracking. The obvious #2 choice, stainless steel, is often even more expensi
by pjc50 4y ago
Copper has long been the choice for piping because it's soft enough to bend without cracking. The obvious #2 choice, stainless steel, is often even more expensive.
(I don't like the standard HN analysis technique of assuming that another field has made a really basic error that can be spotted by an autodidact from outside)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- etrautmann 4y agoWhile I generally agree with your response to the perceived arrogance - shouldn’t we all ask if we can do better than assuming someone else is an expert and has fully optimized a solution? As long as we approach new domains with a sense of humility and respect I think it’s desirable to always be looking for better solutions.
- mindslight 4y ago> assuming someone else is an expert and has fully optimized a solution? I wasn't offering my own singular expert [0] opinion, but rather pointing out what I've observed the entire industry has seemingly converged on. Despite being subject to the hyper-cost-optimization of the consumer market, every refrigeration appliance I've seen still uses copper heat exchanger tubes and copper piping. I would welcome someone chiming in saying something like "actually I work in HVAC and things are moving towards aluminum heat exchanger tubes and stainless piping" or "that's already the case for most new building-scale systems", because I'd learn something new. But "just asking questions" based on one single material property isn't particularly helpful. And yeah, copper has gotten expensive. That has helped some new technologies displace it (eg PEX), but copper is also still used where it's needed (eg PEX and PEX fittings over 1" nominal (which is equivalent to 3/4 copper) are prohibitively expensive for some reason). [0] In fact, I'm not a refrigeration professional, and have yet to pretend to be one. I just tend to look at how things are built.
- eloff 4y agoFirst off, I was upfront about my ignorance. Secondly, copper is way more expensive than stainless steel, unless I’m missing something. More than 8x according to random websites on Google. I’m sure there is a reason copper is used, but if the industry has to find an alternative, it would likely be cheaper.
- mindslight 4y agoStainless sucks at heat transfer, and has to be welded. Copper can be soldered (low temperature), or I believe refrigeration lines are commonly brazed (higher temperature). Raw material cost doesn't tell the whole story. Stainless is harder to work with, therefore costs more to manufacture. And even if it ended up being less expensive in the long run, there would a lot of capital investment to recover.
- Kirby64 4y agoStainless steel not conducting heat would be an advantage for linesets - you don't really want the heat/cold to be released in the lineset... it's released in the condenser/evap coils. Those coils are already often made out of aluminum, so dissimilar metals aren't really an issue as far as I can tell...
- lazide 4y agoFlexible stainless tubing is more expensive than copper flexible tubing. Also, copper flexible tubing is super easy to source.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoFWIW there does seem to be a certain blind spot about PEX as an alternative in the US. A friend redid his whole house with it himself to great success. He mentioned one of the contractors he got a bid from while deciding his plan, when asked about PEX, said "Well that just saves you time and money" in tone of dismissal. I think there's something similar going on with ductless heat pumps in the US. They're a fantastic option in my area but still uncommon. Part of that seems to be the installers make more from other options. I very much agree with you about the tendency of HN's community to assume other industries are simply obvious idiots, rather than realizing they're just ignorant of that industry's reality.
- lazide 4y agoPersonally, having lived in places with ductless heat pumps they suck. Lots more maintenance (they need regular cleaning or they build up mold), they don’t circulate air through the house so rooms get their own weird microclimates and get stuffier, and it’s a constant hassle tracking down remotes. Central is way more comfortable and lower maintenance, IMO.
- Marsymars 4y agoMy house with central forced air already has rooms with weird microclimates due to differing amounts of exterior walls and/or windows. I’ve had the thought that I could use ductless heat pumps to reduce the temperature differences between different rooms in my house.