5 ms·
Your link of Sudden unintended acceleration contains a lot of entries related to this issue which don't involve computers at all. It lists pedal misapplication,
by vel0city 4y ago
Your link of Sudden unintended acceleration contains a lot of entries related to this issue which don't involve computers at all. It lists pedal misapplication, entrapped pedals, stuck throttles, electrical shorts, and diesel engine runaway as other things which can cause such an issue. A lot of the reported incidents had nothing to do with software.
Either way, if you've had a fuel injected car you were still exposed to these issues. You would have to go buy a carbureted engine from the 80s or before to get away from these "unintended acceleration" issues, as in the end a car with EFI probably has a computer actually controlling the injection. I'd be way more wary of daily driving an 80s or older car from a general safety standpoint than a software issue. You're way more likely to be t-boned at an intersection than a software glitch causing an accident; having a much more modern car will help from a crash safety standpoint than having a carburetor.
There's a ton of things that can go wrong in a car which can cause an accident. The software stack is surely one of those things, but even a 100% mechanical car can have a lot of failures as well. Ever have vacuum hoses fail on an old car? Carburetors get stuck or clogged? Personally, I'd prefer a computer controlling components directly instead of tons of vacuum lines and springs trying to keep things tuned right. On top of that I'll also get much better efficiency and reduce harmful emissions which hurt my family and my neighbors.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>There's a ton of things that can go wrong in a car which can cause an accident. And pretty much none of them ever do if the driver doesn't react exceptionally poorly. Even the spectacular stuff that the internet absolutely loves to hand wring about, like a wheel falling off for whatever reason, almost always results in the car coming to a controlled stop on the side of the road. The conversion rate between "failures" and "meaningful harm to anyone or anything is abysmal."
- vel0city 4y agoAgreed. The biggest component failure leading to injuries is by far the one in the driver's seat.
- kube-system 4y agoThat’s true now, because most of the critical systems have redundancy. I wouldn’t want to drive a vehicle with one brake circuit and no throttle return spring, though. It has been a very long time since that was the case, but those days are probably where the mechanical failure horror stories come from.
- kube-system 4y ago> It lists pedal misapplication, entrapped pedals, stuck throttles, electrical shorts, and diesel engine runaway as other things which can cause such an issue. And modern cars are much better at handling these types of scenarios. For example, in my late model car, if you apply the accelerator and brake at the same time, the vehicle will ignore the accelerator input. This solves two potential problems from the past: someone accidentally stomping on both pedals when they meant to hit the brake, and a foreign object wedging the accelerator pedal down.
- Tangurena2 4y ago> someone accidentally stomping on both pedals when they meant to hit the brake This happens to me (sometimes) in parking lots where pedestrians walk between cars. Mine (2019 Mazda Miata) does not do this, instead I get an engine rev while standing half on brakes, half on accelerator, full on clutch. I end up feeling embarrassed as I tend to get glared at by the pedestrian (no, I did not intentionally rev it to scare you).
- kube-system 4y agoI'm glad that's not the behavior on a manual Miata, that would totally kill the prospects of heel-toe downshifting. ;)
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoWait what? You drive a manual and use the left foot to hit the brakes? Recipe for disaster.
- vel0city 4y agoNah, their left is full on clutch, their right foot is between the accelerator and brake pressing both at the same time.
- Tangurena2 4y agoCorrect. Left foot on the clutch as I was (in every one of these situations) backing out slowly. Then I see the pedestrian, lift foot off the gas and jam it on the brake. I guess, in my panic, I don't move the right foot far enough to the left (to get it fully off the gas pedal). This is part of why I hate nose-in parking.
- _yb2s 4y agoMost EFI still has a mechanical throttle, so if there is a glitch in the EFI it can’t possibly cause unintended acceleration. Only fairly new cars now have electronic throttle that could potentially accelerate the engine due to a software glitch.
- kube-system 4y ago"Most" may vary by locale at this point. At least here in the US, automakers started migrating to throttle-by-wire in the 00s.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agoMy early-2000s Japanese car was throttle-by-wire.
- userbinator 4y agoEither way, if you've had a fuel injected car you were still exposed to these issues. You would have to go buy a carbureted engine from the 80s or before to get away from these "unintended acceleration" issues, as in the end a car with EFI probably has a computer actually controlling the injection. Even with EFI, if the throttle is mechanical and the EFI continues to ask for more fuel for whatever reason (or a fuel injector gets stuck open), all that will happen is the engine will stall due to the excessively rich mixture. Ever have vacuum hoses fail on an old car? Carburetors get stuck or clogged? The normal failure mode of a carburetor leads to an engine that doesn't run, and not the opposite. Before complete failure, you will notice a performance decline. Personally, I prefer no computer control. On top of that I'll also get much better efficiency and reduce harmful emissions which hurt my family and my neighbors You can get a lot better efficiency from a carbureted engine than most people think. As for safety, I'd rather have freedom.
- gzer0 4y agoCarbureted engines are significantly less fuel efficient than modern engines that use fuel injection systems. They're less precise; often times not able to fully burn all the fuel supplied.
- vel0city 4y ago> if the throttle is mechanical If the throttle is mechanical. So yeah, I guess there's a window of time there where EFI became the norm but before throttles were also electronic, so late 80s to early 2000s. I imagine the majority of cars on the road today in the US are fully electronic. > The normal failure mode of a carburetor leads to an engine that doesn't run, and not the opposite. I've personally experienced carburetors getting stuck open, usually on abused/unmaintained lawn equipment. I do agree the usual failure is that it gets gummed up and inefficient in its atomization, but a stuck open carb isn't impossible. Either way, a carb that fails and you suddenly lose power can also cause problems when unexpected. > You can get a lot better efficiency from a carbureted engine than most people think. Yeah, a well-tuned and well-maintained carburetor isn't absolutely horrific in efficiency. But it'll still pale in comparison to the combustion efficiency that can be had in a GDI engine. > As for safety, I'd rather have freedom. Cool, and feel free to drive that freedom car in your freedom yard. Please keep your freedom emissions in your freedom air though instead of polluting your neighbors. When you're driving on the public streets there's more than just you out there.
- smolder 4y ago> Either way, if you've had a fuel injected car you were still exposed to these issues. I don't think unintended acceleration with cable operated throttles was ever much of an issue. The simpler EFI systems of the 80s and 90s were very robust with predictable failure modes. We've certainly bought a lot in terms of safety and efficiency with the newer designs, but their complexity also means problems can be more obscure and more likely to sneak their way to market. Anecdote: My 01 Volvo had weird/dangerous intermittent acceleration, but had a fully computerized throttle. The software got confused by a failing throttle position sensor. The best fix is to replace it with a hall effect sensor that doesn't wear out.
- uconnectlol 4y agoYeah yeah, we had to get ECUs because of "problems". It's like how the terrible half working google captcha I get here for signing up with Tor is because "AI breaks text now". In reality it's just a bunch of lazy people going with the flow. > reduce harmful emissions which hurt my family and my neighbors. If there was a true problem it could be solved by having less kids. Why do you end your sentence with this dipshit way of arguing? Nobody falls for that. Of course we all know the game here is for someone to call you out being a passive aggressive dipshit and play the victim once that happens.