6 ms·
1491: New revelations of the Americas before Columbus (2005)
- Khelavaster 4y agoOne of my favorite history books, as well as it's sequel 1493.
- EdwardCoffin 4y agoThe book was an expansion of the essay Mann wrote for The Atlantic, and you can read that essay online [1] [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/03/1491/302445/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/03/1491/30...
- kerblang 4y agoAlso recommending this essay: https://www.laphamsquarterly.org/democracy/hiding-plain-sight https://www.laphamsquarterly.org/democracy/hiding-plain-sigh... - in reference to > the present worldwide movement toward democracy owes not to Locke or Newtonian physics, but to Indians, “living, breathing role models of human liberty.” Of special interest is the man Kandiaronk, a native american. Edit: Just noticed Graeber is bickering with Mann in that essay!
- Mistletoe 4y agoI was walking in the New Mexican desert this Christmas and finding painted pottery shards that date to a little before Columbus arrived. It felt so powerful to touch something that existed before then and think what their lives must have been like before the arrival of Columbus and everything changing.
- themantra514 4y agoPottery, painted pottery, and mycelium derived materials are all the craze nowadays because it's "green & organic" etc. It would be interesting to consider other aspects from pre-Columbus times that we should consider integrating in our daily life.
- hirundo 4y agoIt has surprised me that the majority of pottery shards I find in the New Mexico desert are painted. The unpainted ones are the exceptions. So these must not have been special ceremonial pots, but for every day use. The fact that the pueblo people put such a high value on decoration for everyday objects is fascinating. I think of aboriginals as utilitarians struggling to survive. But if you're taking the time to decorate normal pots, survival must be relatively assured. I'd like to exchange lives with someone who made those pots for a for a few weeks, and compare notes. I wonder if I have more or less free time than they do.
- comte7092 4y ago>I think of aboriginals as utilitarians struggling to survive. Grouping all pre Colombian Native Americans into one bucket is akin to talking about “Africa” as one indistinguishable place today. There was a massive diversity of societies and cultures that spanned the continent with trading networks that crisscrossed the continent as well. Most European account of initial contact tend to describe a life of relative abundance, people certainly weren’t struggling to survive any more than your average 15th century European.
- Mistletoe 4y agoI feel the same. Nearly every shard we found had painting on it. These people were decorating their daily lives and tools, celebrating them with art. My brother is a potter and it was fascinating to listen to him talk about how they did the polychrome pots. For anyone reading this far, here is the kind of pots we are discussing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Lazaro_archaeological_site https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Lazaro_archaeological_site
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI keep wondering how these civilizations might have developed if we'd discovered them in, say, 1900 instead of 1500s. Or what if Columbus did land on the American shores, but never made it back to Europe, and the native Americans got their hands on European technology and figured out how to recreate it.
- mathattack 4y agoThe outcome is the same. They lacked our weapons and immunizations- it would have been hard to catch up in parallel with the Western world. Look at Japan in the 1850s. The isolation of the prior few centuries hurt them.
- throw_pm23 4y agoWere there any positive effects of the long isolation in the case of Japan?
- credit_guy 4y agoIn an indirect way. (warning: following is highly speculative) - being isolated made Japan backward. Also, Japan does not have natural resources, and is not an agricultural powerhouse. This meant Japan was not a juicy target for the colonial powers. - Still, given enough time, one of them would surely have snatched it - Japan figured out the point above, and decided to not become a colony. It industrialized at a furious pace until it became a half-decent military power - huge stroke of luck, or something else, but Japan destroys a Russian fleet at Tsushima in 1905, and leapfrogs into the ranks of Great Powers - they further gain a lot in WW1 by sitting on the sidelines, and eventually joining the winning side - this goes to their head, and they proceed to do the most foolish thing at Perl Harbor, and pick a fight with the 800 pound gorilla - this fight does not go well, predictably, so Japan ends up under US occupation for 7 years - another huge stroke of luck: US, instead of sending Japan back to the stone age in retribution, decides to help Japan rebuild, and pumps massive amounts of aid - Japan goes through a second incredibly fast bout of industrialization This story ends around 1990.
- StevePerkins 4y agoThe sequel "1493", about the local and global impacts following Columbus' landing, is even more fascinating.
- botswana99 4y agoThis really shook up my worldview when I read it. American history as told in my schooling was about a vast empty with an occasional violent native. This is not what happened I read this book twice. I recommend 1493 and his latest book ‘wizard and prophet’ as well. His twitter is also interesting
- theironhammer 4y ago[dead]
- Tagbert 4y agoIn my American schools we did learn more about North American natives though it was often through the point of view of European explorers and colonists. We got the usual stories about interactions with Jamestown/Pocahontas and Mayflower colonists /Squanto. There was more about Ponce de Leon and Coronado and the peoples they encountered. We got more details about the Aztec, Maya, and Olmec. I also remember sections about the mound builders and the Iroquois Confederacy. There were lessons on the American westward expansion and the conflicts that caused though I suspect that was downplayed a bit. The only South American people we studied were the Inca. Obviously that misses whole sections of the continents.
- russdill 4y agoGiven that European epidemics literally decimated the native population and the military marched many of the remaining natives to reservations that is the reality that most settlers encountered.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway6734 4y agoThe spread of disease was guaranteed to happen sooner or later. Europe and the middle east went through the same thing, just earlier in time
- 4y ago
- doitLP 4y agoThe book is great but pretty old now. Can anyone comment on how it holds up to new discoveries/advances in knowledge we’ve made in the last 20 years?
- jussaying2 4y agoAlong the same, er, vein, check out The Open Veins Of Latin America - it's a painstakingly well-researched and fiery book on the colonization and exploitation of Latin America for its resources, under the guise of "taming the primitives". It also documents the attempts of the US in sabotaging popular, labour-led/socialist movements, nearly always successful and often involving the use of violence, all in the name of "fostering democracy".
- andrewstuart 4y agoThe Vikings arrived in North America in 1021AD…. long, long before Columbus. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-58996186.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-58996186.amp https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/4-the-greenland-vikings-land-of-the-midnight-sun/id1449884495?i=1000433253893 https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/4-the-greenland-viking... Or: https://youtu.be/lmbY-GrM8pI https://youtu.be/lmbY-GrM8pI
- itsoktocry 4y agoUh..yeah? What does that have to do with anything? This is about the European arrival, which had a significant historical impact, not about who was first.
- Haga 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thinking4real 4y ago“Native Americans were as active in shaping their environments as anyone else. They built great and wealthy cities; they lived, for the most part, on farms” “He closes with a provocative thesis: namely, that the present worldwide movement toward democracy owes not to Locke or Newtonian physics, but to Indians, “living, breathing role models of human liberty.”” Oh lord. Revisionists begetting revisionists. I had a buddy in college who insisted that Natives were ‘almost as technologically advanced as europeans’ and if not for a few miscalculations in battle, would have effectively flung them off and advanced to a society beyond our wildest dreams. Of course, he failed to respond when I mentioned that there were no modern weapons and the mystical technology he assumed to exist amounted to little more than what Europeans had had for tens of thousands of years. It’s really sad how much hyperbole gets thrown into the revisionism of prehistoric civilizations. It’s not doing the descendants of these people any favors to make up fictitious reinventions of their technological advancements.
- krapp 4y agoYou may be right about technology, but the political system in the US and its Constitution was based on, among other things, that of the Iroquois Confederacy. The premise that Native Americans influenced the global spread of democracy by way of US political hegemony isn't entirely revisionist.
- michpoch 4y agoHow exactly did you tie the US constitution to democracy and then that to US hegemony influencing spread of democracy? Democracy as a concept has nothing to do with US. US had one of the first constitutions, but the concept did exist before.
- justinator 4y agoThe US was an early example of the idea of a democratically elected government, and just so happened to come about by fighting, then winning a war against not only a monarchy, but arguably the most powerful monarchy that has ever existed. Before that, democracy seemed perhaps a good idea, but you're going to have naysayers who want to see a proven example. Proven track records are why anyone listens to anybody when it comes to influence.
- billiam 4y agoA good introduction but there has been much work since this came out. See these more recent books by an historian that looks at things through the lens of two prominent North American nations: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/44310208-lakota-america?from_search=true&from_srp=true&qid=xJ7eATWzIe&rank=1 https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/44310208-lakota-america?... https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3304956-the-comanche-empire https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3304956-the-comanche-emp...
- throwaway6734 4y agoI'm learning about the byzantine empire right now, and I find it so fascinating that the roman empire finally fell less than 40 years before the Americas were "discovered".
- ngoilapites 4y agoA Russian author quoted by Kissinger in Diplomacy claims that Russia is the continuation of The Roman Empire, not sure this is just nationalism or a grounded thesis.
- v7n 4y agoGoing with The Meme[0], Constantine XI[1] was the last Byzantine emperor until his death and the Fall of Constantinople in 1453. The line of succession, ignoring dead empires and bought titles, is supposedly brother (Thomas) > nephew (Andreas, son of Thomas) > niece (Zoe, sister of Andreas) > Grand Prince of Moscow (Ivan III, through marriage with Zoe) > Tsar of the Russian Empire (grandson of Ivan III) [0] https://i.imgur.com/tolQ9ih.png https://i.imgur.com/tolQ9ih.png [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constantine_XI_Palaiologos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constantine_XI_Palaiologos
- ngoilapites 4y agoSo the tsar is derived from caesar. Interesting!