3 ms·
I'm struggling to see the relationship between my comment and your response. For example, you emphasize pH heavily, but I don't see that I mentioned it anywhere
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
I'm struggling to see the relationship between my comment and your response. For example, you emphasize pH heavily, but I don't see that I mentioned it anywhere. Hydrofluoric acid will have all kinds of horrible effects on you, sure, but it can only have those effects if it's there. Whether it's there, and to what degree, is exactly what concentration measures. Aqua regia's ability to dissolve gold is unrelated to its pH. Does that mean it can't dissolve gold? Why bring up pH?
What point are you trying to make in response to the observation "99.9% of acids found outside a lab may be no more dangerous or destructive than human vomit, but that isn't particularly meaningful since the acid in human vomit is highly dangerous and destructive"?
- bell-cot 4y agoLegit criticism. (And no, down in my harshly-worded disclaimer, you are not the "you".) For a specified acid, both concentration and pH are fairly good, one-dimensional, metrics of how relatively dangerous/destructive various solutions are. (Or at least "to within household common sense". Anyone competent to cook spaghetti should understand that "10 gallons" or "boiling hot" would make the solution far worse than "3 drops" or "ice cold".) What set me off was that your comment seemed far too close to "concentration is a good, one-dimensional, measure of how dangerous/destructive acids are." (Without the "specified acid" and "relatively" qualifiers.) That (or a similar statement with "pH" instead of "concentration") is the sort of "logical" simplification that kiddies and idiots can far too easily latch on to, when they're thinking about doing cool & dangerous things. (So - NO, kiddies. The fact that 5% acetic acid is vinegar, which is safe to splash on your salad, does NOT make (say) 5% hydrofluoric acid safe in any way at all. Stay the hell away from the latter, unless you want to look like a cheap horror movie extra for the rest of your might-be-kinda-short life.) > What point are you trying to make [...] 99.9% of acids found outside a lab [...] than human vomit [...] Technically, vomit is (horribly impure) hydrochloric acid. But for household safety purposes? Any good 11-year-old babysitter can safely clean up baby barf, using only routine baby-care supplies. But handling high-molar HCl, let alone dealing with spills of the stuff? That's a completely different world.