3 ms·
The “crash detection” and “fall detection” features on the Apple iPhone 14 and watches automatically call 911 when the devices detect a sudden stop that, in con
by userbinator 4y ago
The “crash detection” and “fall detection” features on the Apple iPhone 14 and watches automatically call 911 when the devices detect a sudden stop that, in concept, means the user has been involved in a car crash.
I wonder how many times it's been activated not by skiers, but by angry people throwing their phones for whatever reason.
“We are communicating with Apple to get them to pay more attention to this but it feels like we are trying to turn a battleship in a bathtub.”
An easy way to get them to pay attention might be to just loudly announce the intention to, and then start ignoring, automated calls from them, or at least deprioritise them in favour of human calls. The equivalent of nullrouting DDoS traffic.
- lostlogin 4y ago> I wonder how many times it's been activated not by skiers, but by angry people throwing their phones for whatever reason. Even just dropping it. I’m bemused at how many cracked screen devices I see given how often I drop mine and yet it never seems to break.
- shusaku 4y agoIt’s all about the angle I think. The only time I cracked mine was a very short drop (two feet at most) but it hit flush with a tile floor
- watwut 4y agoit depends on where exactly it falls. Mine cracked after it hit a rock I think, there is little hole that looks like made by something spiky. I have fallen while cruising on skateboard
- MerelyMortal 4y agoI drop my phone a lot, but having a glass screen protector, I believe, adds the extra reinforcement needed to disapate the shock and prevents my screen from cracking.
- icelancer 4y agoStart billing Apple for the fake calls.
- bmitc 4y agoOr prosecuting.
- missedthecue 4y agoAll apple has to do is ignore the invoices...
- zimpenfish 4y ago> An easy way to get them to pay attention They did. "We did have a conversation with Apple about the crash detection this fall and they told us they were aware of the issue and were working on a fix they were hoping to have out in the first quarter of 2023" As did some other people. "His dispatch supervisor has contacted Apple and received a response that the company is aware of the conflict between skiers and the crash detection technology and are working on a fix, Schroetlin said."
- genocidicbunny 4y agoGood, now that they're aware, surely they wouldn't mind paying the town for the resources their feature wasted?
- manholio 4y agoIt's a fundamentally stupid idea, the sensors in the watch are woefully insufficient to detect such an event with any reasonable amount of precision. Bumping your watch into a tree would generate massive G forces, hitting your head while your arms are flailing would barely register. At minimum, it would require biosensors that detect the owner is still wearing the watch yet his life signs are significantly perturbed from the norm: irregular heart beat and oxygen saturation, hypothermia, AI-informed sound interpretation for things like gasping for air etc.
- colechristensen 4y agoYou don’t know what you’re talking about. It is not as dumb as just looking for spikes in acceleration, but specific patterns and integrating acceleration to get position and velocity history in order to match situations that look like car crashes. Obviously the real world is demonstrating some bugs with bad matches that didn’t get found in testing, but this isn’t surprising or some big failure. Unfortunate it is bothering emergency workers, but is it actually impacting emergency services?
- bmitc 4y agoIt doesn’t appear Apple knows what they’re talking about or doing.
- nickthegreek 4y agoMine only goes off when I fall.. so I do think they know what they are doing. My mother is 72 and lives alone, I plan to get her an apple watch specifically to detect falls as I have been very impressed with its ability to detect them.
- manholio 4y ago> specific patterns and integrating acceleration to get position and velocity history in order to match situations that look like car crashes And that's a fundamentally stupid idea. > is it actually impacting emergency services? Yes, but that's an externality, so don't worry about it.
- i2amsam 4y agoIt happened to me last week when I tossed my coat forgetting the phone was in the pocket. I was very confused when I came back 30s later and dispatch was on the speakerphone asking what the emergency was
- danmur 4y agoI don't really understand how false positives can be eliminated. Maybe it's still better overall.
- bmitc 4y ago> I don't really understand how false positives can be eliminated. They can't, which basically means it's a poor feature and shouldn't have been implemented.
- avidphantasm 4y agoSeems like naïveté and myopia are endemic to tech companies, large and small. Smart people who are confident yet clueless.
- tzs 4y agoSince a false positive generally causes much less harm than missing a true positive making no false positives a requirement is generally a terrible idea.
- watwut 4y agoThis really depends on how many of false calls happen. There is a point at which these start being detrimental.
- bmitc 4y agoAs I mentioned in another post, Apple shouldn’t be farming out the determination to emergency services. They can provide an intermediary to determine the severity. The situation is such that a phone or watch does not have enough information to properly evaluate a situation as an emergency or not.
- Scarblac 4y agoFine people who call 911 frivolously? Including by using a device that does this. Let people know that they must buy a second phone for use with skiing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]