4 ms·
It's sad we need encryption mostly for protection from not criminals, but our own government for even trivial data. What freaks me out most these days is how e
by ck2 15y ago
It's sad we need encryption mostly for protection from not criminals, but our own government for even trivial data.
What freaks me out most these days is how easily people fall into the belief that "oh well traveling is not a right so you have to give up rights when you fly or drive anywhere".
No, if you are a citizen of the United States and unless you are actually crossing a border, you should have the unqualified protection against unreasonable searches, especially without warrants.
I also don't accept the "well it's worse in other countries, be happy you are not there" argument. This country is not even 250 years old. The laws we made are pretty fundamental and not old at all. It's not some kind of game where they should be allowed to dance around the edges to break them.
- flipbrad 15y agoTo be honest, I don't see why national borders are so strongly part of the equation. I suppose that depends on your worldview. I live within the Schengen Area, and to me it seem patently obvious that most 'bad things' in the world are hardly affected by national borders. They're typically supra-national (climate change, credit crunch, cracking, etc) or intra-national (most crime, etc. I don't mean to argue for more checks / security measures, overall, but why do you want them to be focused at the border?
- icebraining 15y agoDrug trafficking and illegal immigration?
- Willwhatley 15y agoHuman trafficking is the new drugs. Apparently it's enormously more profitable to import sex workers and keep them in a kind of narcotic/whatever assisted slavery, because of the reuse of the person vs. the consuming nature of the drug.
- flipbrad 15y agoWe're getting way off topic but I'd be interested to see a source for that claim. I imagine that the costs associated with a prostitute (food, shelter) would be significantly higher than those associated with a stock of inert crystalline powder, pills, or resin. Even if nominally borne by the prostitute, those greater costs still reduce the profitability of the overall enterprise.
- noblethrasher 15y agoI read a scholarly article on the subject that I unfortunately can't find at the moment but I recall that plausible deniability was one of the big advantages of that enterprise.
- pmr_ 15y agoWithout getting into an argument that is very far off the topic: Especially those two things are only made into problems. The first is easily solved by partial legalization and the second is just protectionism.
- flipbrad 15y agodrug trafficking, illegal immigration don't serve as counterpoints; you're putting the cart before the horse The drugs trade is the flow of narcotics from source to sink. Stopping them at a national border is one approach; stopping them elsewhere in transit (as it leaves the source, on the open sea, at the destination by local police, etc) is another. And then you have one more: tackling the existence of a source and a sink. In other words, you look at supply (i.e. creation/generation of stock) and demand. I believe that this is perhaps the best approach, and it is definitely one to which borders are irrelevant. So I don't really accept that as a counterpoint to what I was saying. In some ways, the fact you thought it was illustrates my point: our focus on borders is simplistic and maybe distracting us from finding more effective approaches that might be inspired by a thorough analysis of the system dynamics. People trafficking is to some extent the same thing: source, sink, and a flow over many miles from one to the other (maybe across a border, maybe not). As for illegal immigration, you have a flow that exists because of inequality (i.e. it's a flow down a gradient) - a difference in living standards, job opportunities, safety, etc. This inequality makes the recipient country a sink and the donor country a source. But of course, once again we shouldn't be talking about countries. Some regions are more attractive than others, and people have always moved between them, generally to the gain of one region and the detriment of another. Population flows can be cross-border, or not, despite the similarity in causes. Once again; should borders really be the focal point at which destabilising migrations are addressed by modern, globalised societies?
- icebraining 15y agoYou got me wrong: I'm saying why they are - I'm not saying they should be.
- Willwhatley 15y agoMy understanding is World War I. Apparently passports and visas were an innovation inspired by the militarism and nationalism that swept Europe at the beginning of the twentieth century. However governments rarely divest themselves of power once acquired, and so although many, many more folk are internationalist these years, there exists this relict of national control. /stills rant about how in the United States, the Social Security was promised never to be used as a universal identifier.
- jodrellblank 15y agoApparently passports and visas were an innovation inspired by the militarism and nationalism that swept Europe at the beginning of the twentieth century. Passports were referenced plenty in Around The World in 80 Days, written in 1873. ( http://aroundtheworld.phileas-fogg.net/80days.html http://aroundtheworld.phileas-fogg.net/80days.html ) Although if you mean the systematic use of passports, rather than their invention, yes - Wikipedia Says: *During World War I, European governments introduced border passport requirements for security reasons (to keep out spies) and to control the emigration of citizens with useful skills, retaining potential manpower. These controls remained in place after the war, and became standard procedure, though not without controversy. British tourists of the 1920s complained, especially about attached photographs and physical descriptions, which they considered led to a "nasty dehumanisation" - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passport http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passport
- brc 15y agoI often still marvel when reading the biographies of enlightenment-era people, who often travelled and worked extensively in all sorts of cities and countries. There are often tales of going to Rome for a year or two, then returning to Scotland, then off to Germany for a while, or wherever. While the modern-EU person can do this without any trouble, anyone from outside the EU (or the US), this is just a pipedream without serious legal money to throw at the visa manufacturing industry. Nationalism is still heavily with us, and even more so than in earlier times.
- jrockway 15y agoNo, if you are a citizen of the United States and unless you are actually crossing a border, you should have the unqualified protection against unreasonable searches, especially without warrants. I agree. Practically speaking, the government can only search what you're physically carrying over the border. That means if you boot from something like a live CD and store all your data in the cloud, you're safe from search. To search a US-based cloud provider, the government needs warrants and for those they need probable cause, which means you are relatively protected against unreasonable searches. I encrypt my laptop because I don't want to rely on the cloud, but this is hardly the path of least resistance. If you want to be secure in your papers, don't have any papers.
- 16s 15y agoI'm not sure the cloud is as difficult to access as you may think. Many cloud services have built-in law enforcement interfaces (LEI) to make searching the data self-service and easier for law enforcement as well as the cloud providers. Source: http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-10446503-38.html http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-10446503-38.html
- morsch 15y agoThe answer is, of course, to store your data online and encrypt it.
- buro9 15y agoWhich is what we thought was happening with Dropbox and why people were up in arms about discovering that it wasn't the case. There remains the space for a cloud sync service that encrypts client side and provides good enough clients for every major platform. Spider Oak comes close, but it's just too damn ugly an interface and isn't the "Install and forget" option that Dropbox is.
- spacemanaki 15y agoWho thought that was happening with Dropbox? Did they ever make the claim that they would encrypt people's data?
- cafebabe 15y agoFirst hacker rule when crossing a border: Wipe your disks or do not bring disks at all. This also applies to companies who do have strong competitors who work with the authorities (e.g. if you travel to china / US).
- Create 15y agoThis was always the case, Phil Zimmermann was very open about it, even back in 1991. Sun fellows know the same. There were even case stories from Romania around the nineties, a country which is not even 250 years old. http://www.philzimmermann.com/EN/news/PGP_10thAnniversary.html http://www.philzimmermann.com/EN/news/PGP_10thAnniversary.ht...
- rdl 15y agoI am much more concerned about criminals or foreign governments seizing my data (from a lost or stolen machine) than I am about the US Government. If USG wanted the data for legal reasons, it would be pretty easy to detain and get a court order. If the USG illegally wanted data from me, it would be easy to just black bag and monitor the endpoints. Disk encryption means not having to apologize profusely to everyone when/if your laptop is stolen. That's the real low hanging fruit. Of course, the only sensitive data I have is authentication credentials (easily revoked), commercially sensitive stuff, and personal privacy (which has much higher value to me in keeping secret than to anyone else in publishing), so I feel pretty safe.
- brc 15y agoThe latest example I know of happening is the seizing of the laptops of a blogger who runs a climate-science related website. His blog was one of the handful that the 'climategate' links were posted on. So the outcome was that a warrant was given to search his house, 6 armed officers entered, took two laptops and left (to my knowledge, they still haven't been returned). He wasn't charged with a crime or wasn't a suspect in a crime, he merely had a link posted in a wordpress-hosted blog that he runs by the person that distributed the zip file containing the emails. It's pretty bad that you can lose hardware and have it inspected by unknown persons for unknown reasons simply because you had an anonymous poster put something on your blog. This story, to me, really brought it home that the biggest threat to computer privacy probably isn't theft but rather falling foul of a political position. http://tallbloke.wordpress.com/2011/12/14/tallbloke-towers-raided-many-computers-taken/ http://tallbloke.wordpress.com/2011/12/14/tallbloke-towers-r...