3 ms·
It's a shame that this happened, but it's not unsurprising. If you put a probability of loss on every relic of antiquity, they multiply out to a substantial amo
by echelon 4y ago
It's a shame that this happened, but it's not unsurprising. If you put a probability of loss on every relic of antiquity, they multiply out to a substantial amount of destruction every year.
Ultimately it's a matter of cost. The cost to secure all of these pieces is extremely high. We won't be able to safeguard everything, but there are probably low hanging fruit in applying basic security measures to the items most at risk or of highest value.
- mvdwoord 4y agoEh.... "The vandals forced their way past barbed wire and dug under a steel gate to get into the Koonalda Caves"
- orangepurple 4y agoThe tragedy of heritage sites in Syria being blown up in the past few years by ISIS also comes to mind. Turkey plundered as much as possible before ISIS C4'd the sites.
- echelon 4y agoIncredibly tragic. It's a shame to see so much history being lost.
- perryizgr8 4y agoSee also the Buddhas of Bamiyan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhas_of_Bamiyan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhas_of_Bamiyan
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoAnother comment suggests that the Mirning people wanted to volunteer to protect it, but the local government was restricting their access. So while cost may play a part, there was also an issue of lack of concern from the government.
- angry_octet 4y agoThere are liability issues with volunteers which make it impractical for government to agree to that formally. They essentially have to be contracted or employed in some form. It has been a rent seeking strategy in many instances. A better strategy would be to properly fund the park ranger service, many of which are indigenous anyway, and commit to a specified level of surveillance and patrol. Rangers have powers to expel people from park areas and know how to liaise with police, but general cost cutting has reduced their effectiveness. Park rangers can also legitimately patrol cultural sites on private land without causing issues with farmers (cattle rustling is still a thing).
- wahern 4y agoWhen identification can be difficult or costly, you can always just impose harsher penalties to increase the ex ante cost: https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2022/11/10/prison-time-vandals-nevada-petroglyphs-white-river-narrows https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2022/11/10/prison-time-vanda... Historically this is why in the United States both nominal and actual penalties imposed in Federal criminal cases can be so swift and harsh: the Federal government doesn't want to be in the business of prosaic criminal law enforcement. (Ignoring the changes wrought by the War on Drugs.) But this doesn't work unless the population appreciates this. In the U.S. it's generally understood that Federal penalties tend be swifter and harsher even for mundane infractions; an American will definitely think longer about, for example, trespassing on Federal property than they will comparable private or state properties, even when there's less chance of being caught on the former than the latter. Or perhaps what this really points to is granting or expanding indigenous groups' territorial and legal sovereignty over various lands and sites, so they can make these decisions themselves.