9 ms·
The Architecture of the Lisa Personal Computer (1984) [pdf]
- KerrAvon 4y agoThe perception of Unix at that time is very interesting — this was way before X existed (X would also not have been suitable by this definition when it did become available, of course). The NeXT UFS variant in 1997 was also probably still unreliable by this definition. > However UNIX is a relatively large operating system with several features such as a multiuser timesharing capability, user accounting, and protection which would be wasted in a personal computer such as the Lisa. Since the Lisa would be used by people who were not computer experts, the system must be very robust. However, the UNIX file system is fragile and unreliable [10), [14]. If the power is interrupted or a system crash occurs the UNIX file system can easily be damaged. Unless a systems programmer is present to repair the damage, a user can easily lose all his data. In addition, UNIX does not provide the general inter-task communication facility that the Lisa requires. UNIX memory management does not offer sophisticated sharing of code and data between tasks. Finally, UNIX and alI other operating systems do not provide the support for graphics, multiple windows, the mouse, integration, etc., which are essential to the Lisa. Such capabilities cannot be built on top of an operating system but must be built in to work correctly and efficiently. An attempt to modify UNIX to overcome all of these deficiencies would have taken longer than designing a new operating system with all of the needed capabilities.
- Taniwha 4y agoSome context here - unix of the day was actually tiny, designed to fit in 64k and run on a pdp-11. File systems weren't that unrobust .... but fsck was new and probably not well trusted, prior to that file systems had to be fixed manually
- kragen 4y agothey were right about all of that, except that bsd did have general ipc they ended up implementing the multiuser timesharing capability (aka multitasking), but i remember the machine as ridiculously unstable anyway this probably made the gui unusably slow on the available hardware, though the at&t unix pc did sort of work on hardware that was only two or three times as fast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_UNIX_PC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_UNIX_PC not sure what you'd do with ipc without multitasking tho
- musicale 4y ago> An attempt to modify UNIX to overcome all of these deficiencies would have taken longer than designing a new operating system with all of the needed capabilities. This turned out to be essentially correct (see NeXTSTEP, Mac OS X, Linux...) Nevertheless, Unix was also available for the Lisa.
- Animats 4y agoIf only the Motorola 68000 line hadn't taken so long to come up with a usable MMU. Computing history could have been very different. 1979, M68000, CPU, instruction backout broken, so if you wanted to handle page faults, you needed to avoid all multi-step instructions. 1993, M68010 CPU, fixed backout bug. 1987, N68030 CPU with MMU, page faults work. Early machines required boards full of extra hardware to work around this problem. Which is why the Macintosh, unlike the Lisa, had a plain 68000 MMU and a DOS-like OS hidden by a very nice GUI.
- eschaton 4y agoYou missed 1983’s 68451 segment/limit MMU for the 68010, as well as 1985’s 68020 with 68851 PMMU. There also were MMU implenentations for 68K without instruction resumption—Lisa had one, and Apollo initially used two 68000s to support resumption. Finally, there really isn’t much reason to call the Macintosh operating system “DOS-like” or “hidden;” it wasn’t exposed to the user or developer at all except via APIs, and wasn’t some sort of text-based system that had a graphical interface layered on top of it.
- Animats 4y agoThat segmented MMU was pretty useless. And, yes, there was the 68020 machine with the separate MMU. You could run a variant of Unix, called A/UX, on it. It was really slow. I've coded for the original MacOS. Yes, it was DOS-like at the OS level. No threads. No processes. No CPU dispatcher. A collection of interrupt driven hacks to allow a little bit of asynchronous processing by registering callbacks. Like you'd do on an Arduino today.
- eschaton 4y agoYes, Apple had the Mac II with support for the 68851, but they weren’t the only ones to use it. Though Sun and HP and Apollo all skipped it and continued using extensions of the paging MMUs they’d developed for the 68010. And plenty of those 68020 systems, whether with custom or Motorola MMUs, were quite fast for their time. Any performance issue with A/UX wss on it and the Mac II hardware design itself. In 1981-4, the era when the original Mac OS was developed, very few systems had threads. And if “has a filesystem and is single-tasking” is your criteria for being “DOS-like” I’m pretty sure every operating system between the inventions of the filesystem and timesharing is also “DOS-like” by your definition. I’d call an operating system “DOS-like” if it used a filesystem with drive letters and short file names with extensions, a command line where argument interpretation is handled by the executed program, text files to script startup and configure device drivers, and the operating system API existed primarily to mediate filesystem and maybe printer and modem access. The original Macintosh operating system had no scripting system, used long volume names and filenames, made file type information inaccessible to the user, didn’t include any sort of command line at all, and made providing ways to interact with documents the main point of its API set—to the point where it had no provisions for anything but graphical applications.
- lapcat 4y agoThe Lisa was incredible, so ahead of its time. Too bad it was so expensive, because otherwise it groundbreaking.
- kragen 4y agoalso unstable as fuck
- pjmlp 4y agoWith a system written in a mix of Assembly and a Pascal dialect.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tppiotrowski 4y ago"Therefore, on the Lisa display there are 3 pixels in the horizontal dimension for every 2 pixels in the vertical. These different resolutions do compIicate, slightly, the design of the Lisa graphics soft- ware. For example, the software must remember that a graphical object 150 by 100 appears as a square, however 100 by 100 is a rectangle." Glad this convention died. Definitely a "clever" hack to save memory bandwidth resulting in a lot of pain for future generations.
- mepian 4y agoNon-square pixel graphics systems were quite common back then.
- masswerk 4y agoThe Mac really pioneered square pixels (at least for consumer machines). Reportedly, some wanted them for the Lisa, as well, but, as the Lisa was behind schedule and working perfectly with non-square pixels already, the Lisa was denied this luxury. (One may also argue that in an office environment the horizontal resolution may have been more important than square pixels, which would have come at the cost of a third of the horizontal resolution. As usual, no free lunch…)
- bitsavers 4y agoThe Corvus Concept beat it to market, had a higher resolution bitmapped screen with square pixels, was built on top of the same SVS Pascal compiler as Lisa, and vanished because it's software was primitive, barely using the capabilities of the screen and had softkeys like the HP Amigo and no mouse. http://bitsavers.org/pdf/corvus/Corvus_Concept/ http://bitsavers.org/pdf/corvus/Corvus_Concept/ It's essentially what Lisa would have been if the UI direction hadn't changed because of Apple's exposure to the PARC Alto (which also had a 606x808 screen with square pixels). Fun fact: Mike Cook, the person who designed the Corvus Concept hardware, ended up going to Apple and designed the board for the LaserWriter II.
- 4y ago
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoMany years ago now already it was announced that the Lisa OS would be made available by Apple to the Computer History Museum for publication. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/12/source-code-for-apples-historic-lisa-os-to-be-made-available-in-2018/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/12/source-code-for-appl... That still seems to not have happened. Would be nice to know what the hang up is and what is stopping this from happening.
- mmastrac 4y agoThis was interesting - they intentionally built the screen as an inverse: > As a result, the Lisa bitmap display can operate faster by representing a black pixel as a One and white as a Zero.
- Owen69 4y ago[dead]