11 ms·
Hydrochloric acid is more complicated than you think
- gigathrowaway 4y ago[dead]
- aabajian 4y agoI remember a bit of this in undergrad gen chem. If pH stands for -log([H+]), how can pure water (H2O) have a pH of 7? In theory, there shouldn't be any hydrogen ions in pure water. Turns out there are two simplifications being made: i. H+ in aqueous solution is synonymous with hydronium ion (H3O+). ii. Water is in an equilibrium autoionization reaction with itself and the hydronium and hydroxide ions: 2H2O <=> H3O+ + OH- A pH of 7 means the negative log of the hydronium ion concentration is 7. Or about 10^-7 hydronium ions per liter. This reflects that the reaction above greatly favors water in the H2O state. We tend to make such simplifications (H+ for H3O+) in order to make teaching easier, but at some point it impedes a deeper understanding of what's really going on.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI think my mind was first blown when our physics teacher asked us if H2O conducts electricity. And naturally we all said yeah[1]. We were naturally wrong, but pure water is amazing in its own right. edit: decided to add an edit just in case someone tries to test this claim [1]https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/conductivity-electrical-conductance-and-water https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/sci...
- basementcat 4y agoWater ice is a semiconductor and can be doped, like silicon, to make transistors. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=o61wtb7dSRA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=o61wtb7dSRA
- XMPPwocky 4y agoThis video seems to confuse semiconductors with "materials with a negative thermal coefficient of resistivity". Saying "this gets more conductive as you heat it up" does not a semiconductor make, as far as I understand.
- brendank310 4y agoWhy not? It's not practical for traditional uses of semiconductors, but it has a mechanism to control conductivity.
- melony 4y agoPut it in a bell jar and pump the air out. Violà, vacuum tube.
- ilyt 4y agoBecause then you'd need to call resistors "semiconductors" coz they also change resistance with temperature and that's not useful to anyone.
- adrian_b 4y agoIn any normal resistor, which is made from a conductive material, the resistance increases with the temperature, because the "friction" between the electricity carriers and the atomic lattice increases. Only in resistors made of semiconductors, i.e. in NTC thermistors, the resistance decreases with the temperature. The difference between a conductor and a semiconductor is that in the former the concentration of the carriers is constant, while in the latter the concentration of the carriers can be changed by various means, e.g. by temperature, by light, by impurities, by corpuscular radiation, by electrical fields, by contact with other materials, and by other means. In most intrinsic semiconductors, the carrier concentration increases with the temperature, therefore the resistance decreases with the temperature. This is a valid method to determine that a material is a semiconductor, even if false negatives are possible, when a material is a semiconductor though its resistance increases with the temperature.
- dvh 4y agoFun fact: The exact meaning of the letter p in "pH" is disputed, as Sørensen did not explain why he used it. Sørensen describes a way of measuring pH using potential differences, and it represents the negative power of 10 in the concentration of hydrogen ions. The letter p could stand for the French puissance, German Potenz, or Danish potens, meaning "power", or it could mean "potential". All the words for these start with the letter p in French, German, and Danish—all languages Sørensen published in: Carlsberg Laboratory was French-speaking, German was the dominant language of scientific publishing, and Sørensen was Danish. He also used the letter q in much the same way elsewhere in the paper. He might also have labelled the test solution "p" and the reference solution "q" arbitrarily; these letters are often paired. Some literature sources state that the "pH" stands for the Latin term pondus hydrogenii (quantity of hydrogen) or potentia hydrogenii (power of hydrogen), although this is not supported by Sørensen's writings. Currently in chemistry, the p stands for "decimal logarithm of"
- alwayslikethis 4y ago"negative decimal logarithm"
- vore 4y agoPerhaps we've ended up full circle on this again as the current leading theory is H₂O actually forms the cation H⁺·(H₂O)₂·(H₂O)₄, where the H⁺ forms a hydrogen bond to two H₂Os which form two more hydrogen bonds to two H₂Os each: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2946644/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2946644/
- aabajian 4y agoHa, I wonder if that structure provides any more insights into pH.
- nyanpasu64 4y agoThe water memory folks will be up in arms over this discovery!
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoInterestingly this was all in the curriculum for my high school chemistry class.
- hilbert42 4y agoYes, it was. And it'd be nice if they left it alone (so I didn't have to relearn stuff a new every decade or so). ;-) Chemistry's a quixotic master.
- dthul 4y agoNice bit of insight! For anyone confused like me: I believe it should read "about 10^-7 mols of hydronium ions per liter", which is about 6*10^16 ions per liter.
- acchow 4y agoA key concept in biochemistry/chemistry is that almost all reactions are in some equilibrium between products and reactants, even H2O itself
- toddm 4y agoPh.D. in chemistry here. The stoichiometry which factors into the definition of pH is H_{2}O <=> H^{+} + OH^{-} which actually includes the activity of proton - that's H^{+} multiplied by a coefficient that reflects the ionic strength of the solution and in non-zero outside of really pure 18 mega-ohm RO water - but that's beyond the scope of this. I will note that your balanced equation is in fact valid, as it includes bulk aqueous water. (1) H^{+}(aq) is not synonymous with H_{3}O^{+}; the former is aqueous solvated proton, the latter is hydronium ion; (2) Moving on to the so-called "autoionization" reaction, what you mean to say is that water is self-ionizable or, more appropriately, amphoteric, i.e., is can act as an acid (in this sense, a proton donor) or a base (the hydroxide ion); (3) The pH of 7 is an ideal and is dependent on temperature, ionic strength, and a few other things (including pressure) that do actually move us off the pH point of 7 for a so-called "neutral" solution; and finally (4) The units are moles per liter; and hydronium vs. proton does make a difference, as proton is one hydrogen and hydronium is 3 hydrogens.
- rcthompson 4y agoI don't think the GP is saying that H+ and H3O+ are literally synonymous, but rather that "H+" in the context of an aqueous solution is actually shorthand for a hydronium ion and not a solvated proton (with an H2O implied on the other side of the equation for balance). My recollection from high school and undergrad chemistry is that an unassociated proton is very highly energetically unfavorable in solution relative to a hydronium ion, so any "H+" in solution would exist almost exclusively as the latter. Is that accurate, or is it just a simplification they make for the sake of not overcomplicating things in intro chem classes?
- fuzzfactor 4y agoI've always known protons to do things like no other particle. I agree that H+ in solution is going to make temporary friends with whatever it finds in abundance until it comes in contact with something it can react less irreversibly with. To build from fundamentals, what do we know? Naked protons really are aggressive. Yikes. H+. Water is just protonated OH-, it's neutral. pH 7 by definition. The more the H+ outnumbers the OH-, the more aggressive the proton action. If you water down HCl enough the solution strength will eventually fall into the narrow band known as "measurable pH", from pH 1 (quite acidic) to pH 7 (neutral). pH numbers higher than 7 (all the way up to 14) are alkaline, not within reach for HCl in plain water. It's good to have NIST-traceable pH measurements from precision electrochemical readings using pH-sensitive glass electrodes with temperature compensation. This is a type of glass that has a slight change in electrical properties according to the type and strength of ions it is exposed to, highly sensitive to aqueous H+ in particular. The range of readings is highly amplified by the instrument which is then calibrated logarithmically to the pH scale using known solutions. The known pH solutions correspond to the reference H+ concentrations according to the fundamental pH equations, without dependence on electrochemical measurement themselves. Not quite so good using the proper pH-sensitive dyes which have been discovered useful or invented over the ages. These are strong enough pigments at visible wavelengths such that they can still be detected by eye (or spectrometer) at very low concentrations, while also possessing the property of noticeably changing color wavelength in response to degree of protonation of the dye molecules. These have been around since before electrochemistry. In non-aqueous solutions, neither the electrodes nor the dyes behave exactly like they do with aqueous work, and I don't think the protons do either. The electrodes can be extremely useful non-aqueously, but it's not actually pH we're measuring any more. Plus different solvents are naturally going to have different water contents, sometimes whether intended or not. And there are other things besides dyes which have visible indications of aggressiveness, like polyurethane and metals of many types. Some may take longer to notice than others, but eventually you conclude, yup, this stuff has been attacked by acid. You will find the same number of molecules of HCl per liter of water will not be nearly as aggressive as the same number of molecules per liter in some non-aqueous solvents. At other times it will be the water itself that is required for acid behavior to be fully as expected. The best non-aqueous mixtures for any one purpose are probably not the ones commercially available. So you should be capable of coming up with your own. Don't try this at home.
- glasss 4y agoI've never thought anything related to chemistry was simple, so if it really is more complex then I'm glad I'm in IT.
- fatnoah 4y ago> I've never thought anything related to chemistry was simple I was an EE/CS major and getting A's in the two chemistry courses I took in college is one of my proudest achievements because I had to work so hard for them. Nothing about chemistry was intuitive or simple for me.
- TillE 4y agoThe first couple years of undergrad chemistry aren't too bad, it's stuff like advanced physical chemistry which finally beat my tiny brain into submission. CS is much easier to grasp, the worst it really gets in undergrad is moderately difficult math.
- 323 4y agoOne thing I always wonder is what exactly does HCl dissolve in the stomach, and how does it not destroy the nutritional value of the food?
- kimmik 4y agoLow pH is needed for pepsin to work. Also to kill some pathogens. Doesn’t affect nutritional components of ingestion eg amino acids, vitamins and lipids.
- agumonkey 4y agomakes me wonder what makes pathogen survive our stomach acid bath
- altgeek 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicobacter_pylori https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicobacter_pylori
- adrian_b 4y agoThe animals which are scavengers have more acidic stomachs than those which eat live prey, and the latter have more acidic stomachs than those which are herbivores. This is consistent with the supposition that low pH is needed to kill some pathogens. An interesting fact is that humans have a stomach pH in the scavenger range. This is consistent with the supposition that, before becoming the most successful hunters of this planet, for a long time humans had been mainly scavengers, who scared the other scavengers and predators by throwing sticks and stones, and then consumed completely the leftovers by breaking the long bones and the skulls with stones.
- bell-cot 4y ago> ...and how does it not destroy the nutritional value of the food? Acids destroying whatever they touch is mostly a "kiddie" version of reality. 99.9% of acids found outside of chemistry labs and industrial settings are no more dangerous or destructive (as acids) than soda pop, lime juice, or human vomit (all of which are acids). The reason is that some far stronger and/or more dangerous acids occasionally show up in household settings. Example: "battery acid", splashed on the skin, can cause horrific & life-long damage in seconds. Teaching kids to stay far away from anything labeled "Acid" is kinda like teaching 'em not to play with fire.
- adrian_b 4y agoFree text of the research paper: https://chemrxiv.org/engage/chemrxiv/article-details/63536344aca19808acdffc65 https://chemrxiv.org/engage/chemrxiv/article-details/6353634...
- gus_massa 4y agoI recommend to take a look at the research paper because it has a few drawing that show how the Cl- and H+ [1] are connected with the molecules of the solvent. I like Lowe's post very much, but this really need a few graphics. [1] Note that the H+ is never alone. It's too difficult to remove that electron from the Hydrogen, so H+ is a shorthand for something more complicated.
- rolph 4y agotypically H+ in aq. is H3O+ [hydronium] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydronium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydronium oxygen has greater electronegativity than hydrogen thus oxygen takes a greater share of the electronic orbital, becoming a net positive region
- aj7 4y agoMany people have never seen stainless steel rust. I have. At a slightly leaky Swagelok compression fitting on the HCl-containing gas mixture bottle for a XeCl excimer laser. The leaking HCl combines with the room humidity to make an acid that will rust stainless. And it’s brown oxide rust, induced by the stripping of protective oxides by the HCl.
- tmpburning 4y ago> Many people have never seen stainless steel rust. that is surprising if true..
- ace2358 4y agoRemember, it’s stain LESS not stain FEEE. It merely stains less than regular steel. Not that it is unable to stain at all. Haha I remember when I first realised that.
- colechristensen 4y agoLiterally, the suffix -less means a complete absence of the thing. It is not a synonym for fewer. “Stainless except for odd situations you wouldn’t normally find messing with the oxide protective layer” isn’t a very good marketing name. Even though it is a lie, stainless does mean the absolute.
- midoridensha 4y agoIt may have meant the absolute, because the term was likely invented by a marketer, but in reality "stainless" steel has never been rustproof. It really depends on the alloy, plus the manufacturing quality. Lower grades with less chromium rust pretty easily, just not nearly as much as regular carbon steel. Another fun fact about "stainless steel": it's usually said to be non-magnetic: you can't stick a magnet to it. But again this isn't completely true: the lower grades are indeed magnetic, but the higher chromium-content ones are not. Why bother with a low-chromium-content SS? Probably either cost, or performance reasons. The high-chromium alloys are more brittle.
- 4y ago
- rolph 4y agoactual title == Acid Personalities https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/acid-personalities https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/acid-personalities