10 ms·
From https://twitter.com/BriannaWu/status/1607719007892738050 https://twitter.com/BriannaWu/status/1607719007892738050, written while Tesla was at $123.15: W
by CharlesW 4y ago
From https://twitter.com/BriannaWu/status/1607719007892738050 https://twitter.com/BriannaWu/status/1607719007892738050, written while Tesla was at $123.15:
While the markets have been closed, two major stories about Tesla have broken.
A. Tesla is shutting down factories because demand is plummeting.
B. Musk praised a truly insane Russian propaganda tweet, predicting the fall of the west
She expects Tesla to fall below $100 by 1/1.
It seems notable that the price of used Telsas has fallen 15%+ since August as well, which is about double the trend for used car prices in general: https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/price-trends/Tesla-m112 https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/price-trends/Tesla-m112
- Waterluvian 4y agoI think B only matters as a signal of leadership instability. And I think it tells us nothing new about Mr. Musk that we didn't already know. So I think B is probably not really a factor. A is plenty enough to explain the market behaviour.
- Robotbeat 4y agoWait, you guys know that was a joke, right? Is it okay to not do due diligence on claims because we don’t like a guy? (Which isn’t to say it makes the market feel better, but come on…)
- the_snooze 4y agoIf he wants to joke, he should give up the CEO's office for a clown gig.
- jacquesm 4y agoAnd then he can use as much drugs as he wants without it introducing new and interesting avenues for geopolitical instability.
- Waterluvian 4y agoYeah but Ambien tweeting is so much more thrilling when you’re a billionaire CEO. We’ve all been there.
- jacquesm 4y agoYou forgot to add the 'mic drop' ;)
- sqlcommando 4y ago"Sleeping pills" is classic celebrity cover for harder stuff.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lanternfish 4y agoIt's pretty clearly an attempt at humor, but there's still room for troubling conclusions within that framing. For one, the fact that Musk is even being recommended that kind of content is concerning. Twitters algorithm is set up in such a way that to get exposure to that kind of content, you have to be intentionally engaging with pretty delirious circles of narratives. Additionally, of all the possible jokes to make on all the possible pieces to riff off of, he chose a pretty mediocre joke on an almostly tepidly incoherent take - his joke isn't necessarily endorsement, but it's still an intentional choice that doesn't really signal the kind of responsibility investors are probably looking for.
- Waterluvian 4y agoPopehat’s Law of Goats applies. https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Popehat%27s%20Law%20of%20Goats https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Popehat%27s%...
- zajio1am 4y agoWell, by Popehat's Law of Goats, Jonathan Swift is just cannibal apologist ...
- krapp 4y agoNo, because Jonathan Swift wasn't actually eating people in the service of satire. "Goat fuckers" actually fuck goats even when they do so "ironically." If you spread Russian propaganda for the lulz you're still spreading Russian propaganda.
- Robotbeat 4y agoAre people who quote-tweet Musk tweets to dunk on them spreading Musk propaganda? “Satire is bad because it spreads the thing being satired” is a fun take, but no one in the media seriously believes it enough to be consistent about it.
- krapp 4y agoExcept we're talking about Twitter, which is designed to do exactly that, and Elon Musk, who should know by now that any thread he replies to will go viral. In this case, "satire" is bad because is spreads the thing being satirized, yes.
- fundad 4y agoIt means as little as people joking about whether Tesla’s and Starlink antennas will get bricked if we don’t laugh at his jokes.
- jp_nc 4y agoThe “Epic thread” post could easily be used as Russian propaganda as an endorsement. I tend to think someone with as much power as Elon has some duty to be serious when engaging in potentially dangerous geopolitical issues.
- ztrcx 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cma 4y agoTesla went past the value of the entire auto industry before Biden entered office.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- electrondood 4y ago(a) isn't even remotely true. They paused production in Shanghai on a few lines to upgrade them to the new Model 3 and Y. Brianna Wu is a permabear who pretends to be a journalist and spreads disinfo without verifying.
- astrange 4y agoOne of the more embarrassing things about the popular tech podcaster ATP/relayfm people is, aside from their wives, Brianna Wu and Anita Sarkeesian seem to be the only women they're friends with. Back a few years ago when "there aren't any women in the tech industry" was the crisis of the day, it seemed like they wanted to upgrade from knowing no women so they went out and met a few not very trustworthy people who had nominated themselves spokeswomen of all women, never noticed this, and stopped trying after that.
- nverno 4y agoYea, the predictions of someone driven by passion (in this case, a passionate dislike of Musk it appears) probably aren't great in general. But, below $100 seems reasonable - the stock could still be considered 'overpriced' in the current market (at least by P/E).
- awacs 4y agoThere's really not much to drive sales for 2023 either. Was watching a summary of new EVs for the year and I'll give him credit on the "jet powered" roadster as very cool, but all the new exciting EVs for the average consumer are coming from GM, Ford, BMW, Toyota (with a very interesting Hydrogen powered offering which is technology I had no idea was even this developed) and a few other smaller startups. I think Ford really is going to get traction with the F150 Lightning. That's the smartest move you could make, i.e. electrify the #1 selling vehicle with something similar and practical. That's what people want, and if you convert that demo, you basically win over the rest.
- nverno 4y ago> I think Ford really is going to get traction with the F150 Lightning I agree, I think this will be huge. Tesla's moat really is narrowing. I'm still rooting for them, though, and I'd like to see some of the other startups get traction as well.
- potatochup 4y agoWhat factories are they closing down?
- CharlesW 4y agoI believe she's referring to Shanghai, which is apparently being shut down for a week.
- belltaco 4y agoThey extended a week long Covid shutdown at the Shanghai by 8 days because of higher rates of covid among workers in China. It got spun into "shutting down factories because of lack of demand" by someone that's neither qualified in finance, nor in the car industry. Because they have an axe to grind. It gets posted on HN and upvoted to the top because many HN folks hate Tesla and want to spread FUD about it. Meanwhile, in reality, Tesla has been announcing plans to build a new Mexico plant.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agowell, it'll be a cold day in hell before I ever buy a Tesla, but on the other hand I drive an '04 Corolla and like the fact that I never have to worry about my car doors opening or not. If anything, I'm mostly ambivalent about Musk. So not all of us :)
- olddustytrail 4y agoMusk was very clearly mocking the propaganda tweet, not praising it. I wouldn't put much confidence in the predictions of someone who didn't realise that.
- browningstreet 4y agoOnly because of his follow-up tweet -- his first tweet ("Epic thread") was fully ambiguous. He knows better (after all, he owns the platform) so he's also willingly trolling by not being clearer. That said, the media response to it -- pumping his first tweet without clarifying by virtue of the second tweet -- is emblematic of everything wrong with our current news/media/social-media culture.
- vardump 4y agoI'd say mockery was pretty apparent from the context in the first place. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1607494455720022018 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1607494455720022018 > Epic thread!! If you had no idea from who that tweet was from, wouldn't you regard it as mockery?
- leereeves 4y agoMusk "praised" that insane Russian tweet by saying: > Those are definitely the most absurd predictions I’ve ever heard, while also showing astonishing lack of awareness of the progress of artificial intelligence and sustainable energy. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1607565268150091778 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1607565268150091778
- hobo_mark 4y agoThat course-correction came five hours after the original tweet.
- fwip 4y agoSure, 4 hours after he replied "Epic thread!!" and somebody convinced him to do some damage control.
- scifibestfi 4y agoWhen he realized it was too easy for people to not get the joke and were using it to hurt Tesla.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's Musk that hurt Tesla, not 'people'.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat came after the stock took a plunge. I hope he got his money's worth out of that one.
- leereeves 4y agoThe NASDAQ exchange was closed yesterday. Edit: including the after-hours market, according to https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/tsla/after-hours https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/tsla/after-hou... > Data last updated Dec 23, 2022 08:00 PM ET. > This page will resume updating on Dec 27, 2022 04:00 PM ET. (Elon's second tweet was before the pre-market opened.)
- kylecordes 4y agoIt appeared to many observers that Musk was mocking the Russian propaganda, he then made the mockery explicit later. I don't understand the thesis that Musk is somehow pro-Russia. Generally his ventures are against Russia interests: SpaceX, launched in the aftermath of Russia being uninterested in selling a leftover rocket to Musk, now dominates the launch industry to the detriment of Russia, among other things halting the cash flow from NASA to Russia to carry astronauts to ISS. Tesla and former-SolarCity, reducing use of oil, while Russia is a major oil producer. Starlink provides communications capability to the country Russia is attacking. However, a likely macroeconomic slump in (electric and other) vehicle demand and Musk’s erratic way of running Twitter are real problems. I think these get the blame for stock issues, rather than the bizarre Russian thing.
- cma 4y ago4-5 hours later, possibly around the time his ambien was wearing off: https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/elon-musks-strange-strange-ambien-tweet/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/elon-musks-strange-s...
- astrange 4y agoElon doesn't exactly tweet like a rational logical being at the moment. It seemed to me he was praising the tweet because it mentioned him and said he was going to be president of the US (or something like that) so he thought it was cool. Then he just snuck back in and denounced it later when he remembered he has a security clearance. He's already taken calls with Putin and randomly decided to announce Ukraine should negotiate peace with Russia, then lost interest and dropped it. (Note, the way Elon "talks" in tweets would be sarcastic if it was someone younger, but remember he's middle aged and still calls things epic unironically.)
- cokeandpepsi 4y agoSomeone who's dependant on us goverment contracts defense/nasa really shouldn't be interacting with high ranking russian officals.. even if it's for the lulz espcially since the us has sanctions targeted at medvedev by name, it's no joke
- xwowsersx 4y agoIf B is referring to this tweet https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1607494455720022018 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1607494455720022018, I feel the need to point out that this was obviously trolling/sarcasm. People can criticize Musk all they want — hell, they can even argue the trolling/sarcasm is inappropriate — but pretending that Musk was "praising" that batshit thread is beyond silly.
- ffggffggj 4y agoMaybe this is a good lesson that when you’re the CEO of major companies and publicly speaking with a member of a government engaging a genocidal war of aggression, it’s just not smart to make any of these “le epic trolling” style jokes
- jacquesm 4y agoIt is when life isn't serious to you, the rest of the world are NPCs in your personal video game and no matter how bad you fuck up you're set for life.
- xwowsersx 4y agoIt feels to me that there's something of a Motte-and-Bailey going on in these discussions. It proceeds like this: Arguer: Musk is a pro-Russian asset who praised a Twitter thread in which a Russian government official predicted the fall of the West! Respondent: That was trolling/sarcasm which Musk made clear in a subsequent tweet, if it wasn't already obvious. Arguer: I just don't think CEOs of major companies should engage in trolling, especially about serious political topics!
- ffggffggj 4y agoI never claimed Musk is a Russian asset - the market is signalling how it feels about Musk. I’m just suggesting that the kind of edgy ambiguity that lands with teens doesn’t tend to land with portfolio managers, as we are seeing. Obviously anyone who reads his 4 hour later follow up tweet knows he meant for the original tweets to be read as sarcastic. But it doesn’t change that it signals immaturity and instability in the c suite. You can disagree, but this is just not a motte and bailey situation, since I never made the original grand claim. And, for what it’s worth, I don’t think Musk is an asset at the heart of a big conspiracy. I think the truth is so much more banal than that - he’s just an impulsive guy surrounded by sycophants.
- _the_inflator 4y agoTesla could go out of business or become a takeover candidate. Electric car subsidies are on the line in many cases in EU. And the coolness factor in contrast to other established brands was clearly damaged by Elno's escapades - and it's not getting any bette
- joewadcan 4y agoI'd bet against that. Tesla is flush with cash, zero debt, and growing revenue annually more that most Fortune 100 companies. They are very profitable without any subsidies and still have a 28% profit margin on the cars they sell
- masklinn 4y ago> or become a takeover candidate. Why tho? It’s not like they’re really good cars, the build quality is sub-par, as you note the brand has really suffered, the home-grown tech would be difficult to integrate, and the automation a liability. The supercharger network seems like the major asset someone might be interested in. And secondary would be a pretty strong software team as historic manufacturers have had a hard time taking that turn, but at the same time that would likely clash with the existing teams and practices so the benefit is not a sure thing.
- chinabot 4y agoThey are really good cars actually (FSD Bulls** excluded)
- masklinn 4y ago> They are really good cars actually (FSD Bulls* excluded) They're not tho, the materials, QA, and fit and finish is absolutely garbage, has been for years, and apparently it's getting worse (https://youtu.be/kIW4moIM0zM https://youtu.be/kIW4moIM0zM).
- chinabot 4y agoI've got a 2021 model 3 and dont have any of the issues you are talking about, I must obviously be the exception.
- joewadcan 4y ago"Shutting down factories" is the not the same as slowing production. Tesla is expanding their production since they are wildly profitable.
- Geee 4y agoIt's ridiculous to state that Elon praised Medvedev. Medvedev made some insane and absurd predictions for 2023 and Elon replied with "Epic thread!!". It was epic because how insane it was. Elon clarified it later with "Those are definitely the most absurd predictions I’ve ever heard, while also showing astonishing lack of awareness of the progress of artificial intelligence and sustainable energy."
- fabian2k 4y agoI think it is entirely reasonable to not give Musk the benefit of the doubt here. He has previously made some comments that were very friendly to Russia, and calling something "epic" is reasonable to interpret as a positive endorsement. It's entirely possible that Musk is just trolling here, but that is not an excuse and should not shield him from criticism for this comment.
- Geee 4y agoTo me it's very obvious, but if you aren't familiar with Elon I guess it's possible to misinterpret it.
- akmarinov 4y agoThe UK rejoins EU and it falls apart all in 2023 - that is epic. There’s negative chance it happens, I can’t take it as “Elon think this will happen”
- jacquesm 4y agoHis attempt at damage control 4 full hours later wasn't exactly credible.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Taywee 4y agoI'd take anything Wu says with a boulder of salt. She's an extraordinarily unreliable narrator.
- colpabar 4y agoWhy is someone who is only famous because of gamergate a reliable source for stock market predictions? Brianna Wu is an idiot.
- RobertRoberts 4y agoWhy I won't buy a Tesla (as of today) even though they are amazing. I rented a model Y, and the ride, fit, finish, comfort, speed, venting is super cool, charging, range, power/speed settings that affect drive experience, all _amazing_ ... but... (no particular order) - Door handles SUCK, open the wrong way and often require TWO hands. (I am not old/feeble) - Unlocking the door SUCKS. You have to tap the key card multiple times, or in an exact spot. - Locking the doors SUCK. You have to either find some obscure tiny lock icon on the touch screen... or just walk away an HOPE it locks. I actually couldn't tell if the car actually locked because it AUTO UNLOCKS when you get near it. - The touch screen SUCKS. While many simple controls were easy enough, and the large screen was nice for navigation, most of it was miserably tedious. Repeat actions should be easy, but it was a constant chore to find and re-find. - The physical controls on the steering wheel (you guessed it) SUCK. They are not labeled, and they are context sensitive so you are required to look at the screen to figure out what they are affecting. But sometimes, it's a tiny spot on the screen that it affects, and you can't see what it is doing. And since it changes what it affects, you can't rely on muscle memory. - Lane controls SUCK. It constantly wines and alerts you, and warns you, and steers back into your lane. I tried multiple times to shut it all off, and I could simply not turn somethings off. (I work in IT, I googled it, there was nothing obviously locked down the rental company) - Price (sucks) Why is lane control seemly required? (my opinion) Because all the car's controls are out of your safe driving line of sight. Without this I think most Teslas would be in persistent minor/major accidents. The bad so far outweighs the good... I hope they either allow disabling the babysitting features or make a simpler car without them. Add real physical buttons. Put a _real_ dashboard that you can see without getting distracted.
- kylecordes 4y agoI've had a Model 3 since 2018. You can see earlier in the thread that I am not a raging Musk fan, in particular of his public behaviour over the last few years. But a couple of these concerns are may be just because of the short experience renting? Door handles: for the first week or so they seemed awkward, but I've been opening with a single hand ever since. The design is very similar to various exotic sports cars - and not well suited to a midpriced daily driver. Tradeoffs for aero, I think. Unlocking and locking: bad experience on a rental with the card. As an owner, it locks and unlocks based on the phone-key automatically in daily use. I tried the key card a couple of times in the first month to understand how it worked - it's great as a backup key that fits in a wallet. Touchscreen: I've used the touch UI in various brands of recent cars, and find the Tesla experience by far the best. Though I agree another $50 worth of physical buttons for the most commonly used features would be nice. Steering wheel controls: after a few weeks you remember what they do and the physical minimalism is totally fine. Design optimized for owners, at the expense of renters. Lane controls: there are about a dozen switches that control this behavior. It can be incredibly annoying, or no problem at all. Sounds like the defaults nowadays (or what the rental place sets) are awful, since as configured it ensured you won't buy one. Price: they're selling all they can make at the price the market will bear. Would be nice if it was lower. Many industry watchers predict lower prices are all brands in 2023. Fortunately it's a big industry, there are now some great electric cars competing with very different dashboards. I like variety, I'll pick a different one when I am ready to trade in.
- LegitShady 4y agoBrianna wu is a nobody whose opinion of Tesla is equal to that of every other nobody. How is this person qualified to predict stock prices? Why does their extremely one sided take matter to anyone? They're not a good source of information even when they're right.
- oxfordmale 4y agoThe price-earning ratio for Volkswagen is 4.4 on the 22nd of Dec, Tesla still has a ratio of 38.05. That is partially based on the hype of a full self driving Tesla. That promise looks like it won't materialise anytime soon. Other car manufacturers are also catching up on the EV market. The Tesla share price will likely been going downhill for a while.
- kortilla 4y agoQuoting Brianna Wu for anything related to Tesla or Musk is like quoting Fox News for Biden insights.
- philippejara 4y agoa...brianna wu tweet? are we in 2015 again? How is she being quoted talking about stock prices