5 ms·
The federal government would absolutely be okay with a federal ID. They even offer a few already. It is the states who are against mandating one.
by kube-system 4y ago
The federal government would absolutely be okay with a federal ID. They even offer a few already. It is the states who are against mandating one.
- habnds 4y agowhy are the states against it?
- rayiner 4y agoIt gives more power to the federal government.
- bbbbb5 4y agoWhy would they not be against subjecting their citizens to such a mass surveillance system?
- emptyfile 4y ago[dead]
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> why are the states against it? Cedes control, which is a political and minor economic issue.
- kube-system 4y agoThe status quo is that the states already have IDs that are exactly how they want them. There’s no practical benefit to them, and it’s a politically convenient argument for privacy rights and states rights.
- Spooky23 4y agoThe states are fine with it, as it would make their lives easier and yield more federal dollars. National ID was a core GOP platform issue post 911. It never happened because both extremes of the political spectrum are against it. Right wingers are into the mark of the beast stuff and see it as a tool of government tyranny. Left wing types see it as a way to disenfranchise voters and deny resources to marginalized people. Both are right and wrong. So the status quo prevails.
- kube-system 4y agoHow would a national ID make anything easier for the states?
- Spooky23 4y agoIt would get them out of the ID business, or yield federal dollars to be in that business. It would also streamline lots of use cases that require ID. Various federal programs administered by states require that you authenticate people in different ways. The states spend millions to do a shitty job (driven by Fed requirements) for unemployment, social services, Medicaid, etc.
- kube-system 4y agoFirst of all, they don't want to be out of the ID business. They like identifying their citizens to their own standards. Second of all, the most common state ID is a drivers license. A federal ID would not replace the state's need to license drivers.
- Spooky23 4y ago> First of all, they don't want to be out of the ID business. How do you know? State motor vehicle orgs are revenue generators. ID operations are expensive and operationally risky. A federal ID would put the states in the business of selling endorsements. A drivers license would be like a deer tag or fishing license - higher margin and lower overhead. It would also enable online services and local/county/state government could significantly reduce workforce and other expenses.
- kube-system 4y agoHow would a state assign endorsements to an ID they do not maintain or control? How would they use an ID database they don't have? The answer is that they'd have to rely on the federal government instead, and given the functional relationship between the states and the federal government, states just aren't going to voluntarily give up that power and trust them to do this for them. It is in the existential interest of the states to maintain as much power as they can, despite the associated cost.
- Tangurena2 4y agoBecause it feeds into the "mark of the beast" thing. State legislators want to appeal to the fundamentalist crowd so they occasionally have to make noises to satisfy them. Since enough people in my state believe such a thing about Social Security numbers, there is a form that the DMV (who I used to work for) has for people who are against SSNs due to religious reasons (SSN required for driving & occupational licenses by Uniform Interstate Family Support Act [0]). > It also forced all people, great and small, rich and poor, free and slave, to receive a mark on their right hands or on their foreheads, so that they could not buy or sell unless they had the mark, which is the name of the beast or the number of its name. [1] Sources: 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Interstate_Family_Support_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Interstate_Family_Supp... 1 - https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Revelation%2013%3A16-17&version=NIV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Revelation%2013....
- Manuel_D 4y agoWe already do have federal ID: our social security numbers. And if you're a man your selective service number, too. Both are technically not mandatory, but the steps to avoid them are incredibly byzantine and lock you out of lots of social services.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> We already do have federal ID: our social security numbers Social security numbers (or cards) are not ID, in any meaningful sense. > And if you're a man your selective service number, too. Also not an ID. > Both are technically not mandatory, but the steps to avoid them are incredibly byzantine and lock you out of lots of social services. “Immigrate to the US after age 25” isn’t that byzantine. And, actually, selective service registration is technically mandatory, during a narrow age band.
- Manuel_D 4y agoSocial security numbers are unique IDentifiers for almost all people (legally) living in the US. Their whole point is to uniquely identify each person in the country. Even if you immigrate to the US after 25 you'll be assigned an SSN after becoming a permanent resident. You can't board a flight with it because there's no photo, but it's still a near-universal way to ID each person residing in the US.
- kube-system 4y agoTheir point is to identify a unique taxpayer record or a unique social security recipient. They lack a photo, so their utility is limited in identifying a physical human being. They are, pedantically, "an ID". Just like a UUID is an ID. They're just not the type of ID we're talking about: an ID that authenticates the identity of a human who possesses it.
- Tangurena2 4y agoSSN are supposed to be unique. They are not. If you try to use them as a unique identifier in a database, your customers/end users will be sorry. In the payroll app that I'm currently working on, 111111111 is used as a temporary number. Which ends up not being temporary enough.