4 ms·
People who think we've made serious qualitative advances in debugging would do well to reread H.H. Goldstine's and J. von Neumann's thoughts on the topic from 1
by 082349872349872 4y ago
People who think we've made serious qualitative advances in debugging would do well to reread H.H. Goldstine's and J. von Neumann's thoughts on the topic from 1947.
What we have done well is to quantitatively scale so that we're applying the classical debugging techniques to Big Balls of Mud, and not just a few lines of assembly.
(the record among my colleagues was writing, then fixing, 3 bugs in a single line of assembly)
- ben_w 4y ago> reread H.H. Goldstine's and J. von Neumann's thoughts on the topic from 1947. Do you have a link? Searching only gave me irrelevant results.
- 082349872349872 4y agoIIRC it was https://www.sothebys.com/en/auctions/ecatalogue/2018/the-library-of-erwin-tomash-l18409/lot.937.html https://www.sothebys.com/en/auctions/ecatalogue/2018/the-lib... (or at least in that series) and finding a samizdat'ed scan took a good deal of work (and maybe even some поиск'ing). Best I can do at the moment is to recommend searching from http://www.cs.tau.ac.il/~nachumd/term/EarlyProof.pdf http://www.cs.tau.ac.il/~nachumd/term/EarlyProof.pdf which was one of the papers I passed on the way... (IIRC Goldstine and von Neumann has diagrams resembling Figure 2; I don't recall if Figure A had been anticipated or not — remember all these people had been attending the same conferences, so it's very likely) Basically, back in the rosy-fingered dawn of electronic computation, they already had in mind "know what your state should look like at all points, so you can binary chop to find what control flow first made it go wonky". (a question I have not investigated: how well developed were debugging techniques in the card computing era? I've read horror stories of Los Alamos computations being corrected on-the-fly, with "new code" cards on a different coloured stock being run at the same time through machines that were still busy processing "old code" cards on normal coloured stock. And in terms of "know what your state should look like", card machines did have facilities to abort jobs if the input card deck should fail simple sanity check logic, implying that's been a thing since, probably, Hollerith ca. 1890.) [Edit: I'll have to dig it out of my library, but an old book my spouse got me on Naval computation, from back when "computer" was a job title, not an object, talks about how to organise jobs that would take a week or two to run. I'm sure they had plenty of double-checking going on to make sure a slipup on Wednesday wouldn't result in complete garbage by the following Monday.]
- ben_w 4y agoThanks, interesting link and also interesting commentary on your part.
- ngneer 4y agohttps://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/194051 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/194051