3 ms·
Counterpoint to the original article, based on your comments: Children do exist, because civilization exists. You could also say "civilization doesn't exist, we
by jerf 15y ago
Counterpoint to the original article, based on your comments: Children do exist, because civilization exists. You could also say "civilization doesn't exist, we invented it", but that falsely implies that things we invent don't exist, which regardless of what definitions you use for any of the critical words in that sentence, it's way too bizarre an idea to slip into the discussion unexamined.
I would say that as civilization has deviated farther and farther from the "default" of human civilizations, we come out of the womb increasingly less adjusted to it and therefore we have created a distinct phase of "maladjusted human" in our discourse to reflect it. And it is a real phase, which we must really be educated out of, or the result is a slide back to the default human state, which you may also know from the word "barbarism".
As I rather like "civilization", however artificial it may be, I'm OK with the "invented" child phase, and actually not terribly impressed with the original essay as it is written. Extol the virtues of having an open mind, sure, but children don't just have open minds, they are frankly stupidly open minds, and a variety of other difficulties like a near complete inability to rationally account for future consequences, even ones clearly mere seconds away (at the younger end). I don't believe the author can accurately describe his behavior as "childlike", because if he really was acting like a child, he would not be able to claim it was successful. I know 25-yo man children. Heck, I know a mid-40s man child. We're counting down the months until he gets arrested for some form of tax evasion, on the grounds of not really feeling like doing them. This is not a successful lifestyle. There's a lot more to "childlike" than having an open mind and a certain blind, stupid perseverance (that, might I add, only really works out if the adults in the life have created the proper environment).