4 ms·
28 Minutes to boot? That's roughly what will be the norm in another decade ;) It's insane how much faster CPUs have become and how slow an average machine boot
by jacquesm 4y ago
28 Minutes to boot? That's roughly what will be the norm in another decade ;)
It's insane how much faster CPUs have become and how slow an average machine boots to full functionality. The days of 'instant on, instant off' are long behind us.
The amount of persistence behind these projects never fails to amaze me, see also the guy that made a miniature version of the Cray-1:
https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/191877-how-to-build-your-own-110-scale-cray-1-supercomputer https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/191877-how-to-build-your...
- hackmiester 4y agoWhat computer are you using that boots so slowly? I can’t say I have had that issue in over a decade.
- jacquesm 4y agoI have exactly one windows box in this house and I avoid turning it on but it is a requirement to operate a particular piece of hardware. It takes several minutes before it has completely booted, it runs Windows 7 on what is a perfectly fine machine for that OS. Highly frustrating. That's why you get articles like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21831931 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21831931 And many others besides. Windows can be such a cycle hog. Probably if I installed 64G of RAM and an SSD I could cut it down to something more decent, but I don't use that machine often enough to offset the expense (and never mind driver/installation media hassles, it isn't broken so don't fix it!). Other machines take on average about a minute or so but they are running Linux, running Windows on them would easily double that. My daily driver is a T540p (mostly to conserve power) and it works well enough. Not exactly a speed daemon in use but maxed out on RAM (16G), a 2.5 GHz i7 and a fast SSD it doesn't perform nearly as well as my 20 year old self would have expected it to. OS and browser will happily eat all of that, and I can't use swap because of the audio drop-outs that would cause. If there was a way to shoehorn in more memory I would take it.
- dontlaugh 4y agoYou need an SSD. My Windows 10 machine boots in 10 seconds at most.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> It takes several minutes before it has completely booted, it runs Windows 7 on what is a perfectly fine machine for that OS. > Probably if I installed 64G of RAM and an SSD... You're complaining about boot times, but using an OS that has been deprecated for years and using a mechanical HDD? SSDs have been the norm for a long, long time. Complaining about boot times of deprecated operating systems on outdated hardware that virtually nobody uses in new builds is very misleading. I hope you can see the irony of complaining about modern boot times by benchmarking things against a completely outdated system.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat machine shipped with Windows 7 and a mechanical HDD. It has 4G of RAM which should be plenty for the purpose. As for 'new builds', yes, SSDs are faster. But the speed gain from an SSD is negated to some degree by the amount of bloat present in a typical OS and if not for that you shouldn't be able to tell the difference between 'sleep' and 'cold boot', in fact 'cold boot' should be faster (but it really isn't). As for the complaint: take it with a grain of humor. It was mostly a contrast between booting say my 1980's BBC Micro (you couldn't move your hand from the powerswitch faster than that the prompt appeared) to the times that we have come to accept. SSDs have cut that time to something more acceptable but I fully expect that advantage to be eroded again over the years because that's what happens with software: it always becomes larger and slower, never smaller and faster. On identical hardware a newer release of any OS is invariably slower than whatever came before.
- goosedragons 4y agoOne of the features of Windows 8 was decreased boot times. I don't think its the only OS to do that either. SSDs make a massive difference even for Windows 7 too.
- mikewarot 4y agoMy windows machines can take anywhere from 5 seconds to 5+ minutes to boot, depending on if it's Wednesday or not.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> It's insane how much faster CPUs have become and how slow an average machine boots to full functionality. The days of 'instant on, instant off' are long behind us. Both my Mac and custom built PC boot very quickly. Faster than my PCs in the past. I'm not even doing anything special, just grabbing a generic motherboard, NVMe drive, and installing Windows. Powering off is a rare event, though. Sleep functionality has been rock solid in both OS X and Windows 10 for me in recent times.
- jacquesm 4y ago> Both my Mac and custom built PC boot very quickly. It would be interesting to quantify this across many machines / OSs. Say from cold boot to starting a browser and loading a benchmark webpage (to ensure the network is up and running).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Night_Thastus 4y agoEver since SSDs, all my PCs have booted nearly instantly. Even faster with NVME SSDs. I'm not sure what would cause your concern.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI don’t boot anymore. Haven’t for years. I just lift the lid and there it is. But I do remember when it felt like 28 mins. I think “booting” might become a concept that goes the way of “download.” That is, it will eventually be unknowable to those who didn’t grow up with it. Computers are just on, and files are just accessed.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's an interesting viewpoint, yes, you are probably right. But 'download' is still a thing even if streaming services are more and more common. And with the frequency of OS updates booting is also still a thing unless you never patch your systems.
- heelix 4y agoFunny enough - reboots are becoming a thing with Windows 10/11. I really dislike the way my Windows box now patches and reboots when it feels like it. Without fail, I'll have wherever I had my workflow paused for the night... just wrecked. It was so close to right with Windows 7.
- notafraudster 4y agoI don't mind reboots, since I sleep at least once a day. The main issue is the inability to restore state. MacOS has reopened everything I had open before a reboot for years now and I'm not sure why Windows still struggles with this.
- Delk 4y agoAre you running some kind of an OS that doesn't need reboots for any of its updates? Are you using some kind of live patching? I (somewhat) rarely do a full reboot either, and Linux on my laptop may go for a couple of months without a reboot, but I don't really trust that updates to the desktop environment or even lower-level libraries or things like systemd would be in effect without restarting most or all of the system. (Not to mention the kernel, of course, but kernel vulnerabilities that are easily exploitable remotely would probably create a ruckus.) I guess you could also just trust that there aren't remotely exploitable vulnerabilities in those components, but I honestly don't have the energy to keep track. By that point rebooting occasionally just becomes simpler.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BirAdam 4y agoI think you might have rose tinted glasses. I threw a solid state drive in my turbo XT and load times even for MS-DOS 3 aren’t good. Loading up Windows 3 is terrible. WordStar can boot okay if you’re not using any TSRs to enhance functionality. You want to load Civilization? There’s a wait. If we move on to Win98 or 2K on say a Pentium3, with a solid state disk everything becomes somewhat snappy. The SSD is the main gain. Take it away and everything is abysmal. I love ancient hardware, but if you go back to relive using those machines… it just ain’t what we remember. Our expectations have changed.
- MobiusHorizons 4y agoThe 8bit cartridge based computers really are instant on. I think that may be what the op is referring to. I don’t think any system with a hard drive or sdram can even get to a boot loader in the same amount of time regardless of the latency of the boot medium. It really was a different era.
- BirAdam 4y agoThey also only loaded BASIC instantly. Want to load from tape or floppy and you’re back to waiting. Same thing if you run your BASIC program. Instant on in that case was restricted to the ROM BASIC and cartridges.
- msla 4y agoMy current Linux laptop (System76 darter pro 8, Ubuntu jammy, 12th Gen Intel(R) Core(TM) i5-1240P, UEFI firmware) boots to a login screen pretty snappily, less than a minute, and from there it's up to me how quickly I type my password. I get a usable system very shortly thereafter because Window Maker is pretty lean. Getting a system back from a suspend-to-disk is pretty instantaneous.
- anthk 4y agoAtom n270, 1GB of RAM Alpine Linux with Slim (wmaker login theme) and cwm with xsetroot matching a purple theme from current wmaker. It flies. I have a UXTerm based setup with TMUX, lynx, bitlbee, nsxiv, mocp, MPV, ffmpeg, sox, frotz, slashem, mednafen... No lag except for goverment pages with JS, where I have to briefly launch luakit, but I have a global hosts file adblocking everything.
- ConceptJunkie 4y agoMachines these days boot and become usable faster than anything I remember, and I've been using computers for 40 years. Yeah, maybe an IBM PC booting DOS 1 or 2 booted faster, but I don't recall, and didn't use either version very long.
- prmoustache 4y agoMy girlfriend's windows 10 on spinning disks take much less than that for the desktop to appear, but I don't think her desktop is really usable until way beyond 25 minutes. My professional laptop on windows 10 boot in a few seconds but then it takes a minute or 2 for Microsoft Teams to show up and that is with SSDs. In comparison same laptop on linux take a little more time to boot to desktop but I can quickly get a browser window with teams / outlook and open other apps so while it appears slower to boot it is usable roughly at the same time. There are a lot of shitty technics to make windows appear loading faster than it really does. What matters is not the time for the login screen or desktop to appear but the time until you can be productive on it.
- yread 4y ago> teams of course if you want to run such advanced software you have to wait for it
- JPLeRouzic 4y agoI guess you are joking, but that's could be really something that was thought by someone in marketing. Such as the switch from making ads about technical features of software (~1980') to ads displaying boxes (~1990).
- satysin 4y agoI picked up a mini pc for my son a few weeks ago. €439 for a Ryzen 5600H, 32GB DDR4 RAM and a 500GB NVMe SSD. It comes with Windows 11 Pro and boots in ~10 seconds. Fedora runs great on it as well, booting in around 15 seconds, with the exception of suspend making the system unstable but that isn't uncommon with Linux sadly. For the price and form factor these mini pc are great. I just hope it lasts more than a few months :D