3 ms·
Whenever I see that rare consumer-protection or worker-protection law get passed in the US, I'm always amazed at how timid and gentle on corporations the law en
by ryandrake 4y ago
Whenever I see that rare consumer-protection or worker-protection law get passed in the US, I'm always amazed at how timid and gentle on corporations the law ends up being. I know I shouldn't be amazed but I still am. I read the bullet point list in the article and think "Wait, don't companies already have to do these sensible things?" When it comes to protecting the investor class, you get giant sledgehammers like SOX. When it comes to protecting the little people, they put on the kid gloves legislation and give the company a popsicle if they at least try to follow the law.
- ghayes 4y agoI think the sad fact, addressed in the article, is that the bill wasn’t going to pass without industry support. Oftentimes this means either a) limited recourse for failing to comply, and/or b) new barriers to entry to smaller organizations. While this bill is meek, it does seem to be purely a net gain, since the burden on businesses is low and it gives consumers an easier recourse in cases of fraud (since the collected information will now available directly or by a subpoena).
- Spooky23 4y agoSOC was in response from Enron which impacted a lot of regular people. Enron bought up utilities that were often “widow and orphan”, boring stocks that were held for a long time by retirees. I knew a few people whose parent or grandparents lost everything when their ancient electric company stock turned into Enron, then rode to zero. Minus a big story, people aren’t in favor of consumer law.
- aksss 4y agoTBF, Sox is also protecting the little guy and it has the effect (for better AND worse) of increasing the cost of doing business (properly/legally). When regulating small businesses it’s important to be mindful of the overhead inflicted such that significant barriers aren’t being raised to business creation. Similarly, Amazon doesn’t advocate for $15 minimum wage out of altruism, no matter what your thought on the issue - they can afford to pay it whereas more local businesses would struggle and go under. Anti-competitive regulatory advocacy is a thing, so light touches in the SMB arena represent caution as often or more than regulatory capture.