4 ms·
This philosophy works well in truly competitive markets. However, fast-moving water can be artificially generated by throwing a ton of VC / IPO money at a marke
by vlovich123 4y ago
This philosophy works well in truly competitive markets. However, fast-moving water can be artificially generated by throwing a ton of VC / IPO money at a market.
> Three months later, we pivoted into video games on FB, grew quickly to $10M’s of revenue that we didn’t have before, and Saar was proven right
How big are FB video games today? Zynga was purchased for $12.7B when Take-Two's market cap was ~$20B without really impacting Take-Two's market cap meaning that Take-Two purchased a company for $12.7B that the market valued at ~$0 (generously if we assume the following peak of $28B was the acquisition, then the market valued it at ~4B).
My point is that "find the fast moving water" is a greedy search algorithm that is heavily distorted by private capital flows / band-wagon effect. That's why once a market sees 1 serious VC entering it meaningfully you see a massive cash flow as all VCs follow. That doesn't mean that it's actually creating value vs entrepreneurs rushing in to build companies to extract as much value as possible from the "dumb money" flowing in. This also sucks away oxygen from things that might be more durable ideas that are harder businesses to build.
It's useful advice for finding personal wealth in VC markets. I do wish there was some kind of economic model that manages to meaningfully inhibit pure market capital churn while encouraging construction of durable businesses. Probably not possible in the VC space I suspect.
Probably in this analogy, as other mentioned, we should be looking for fast moving deeper water / water that's likely to maintain a forward direction for a long time vs surface water churn.
- vkou 4y ago> How big are FB video games today? Zynga was purchased for $12.7B when Take-Two's market cap was ~$20B without really impacting Take-Two's market cap meaning that Take-Two purchased a company for $12.7B that the market valued at ~$0 (generously if we assume the following peak of $28B was the acquisition, then the market valued it at ~4B). I'm not sure that's correct. If a company worth $10B pays $1B in cash to purchase a gold bar that's worth $1B, it's market cap should not change. That doesn't mean that the gold bar is worthless! Likewise, if a company worth $10B pays $1B in cash to purchase a company that's worth $1B... It's market cap should not change, either! The only situation in which the market cap should change is if the purchase unlocks some kind of new synergy between the two companies, that wasn't present when they were separate entities (Or if the shareholders think that the management of the buying company has gone insane.) But that still has zero bearing on the 'market value' of the acquired company.
- vlovich123 4y agoMarket cap incorporates valuation of future cash flows. So buying $1B worth of gold should result in a decrease of market cap because the market will typically discount the future value of doing that (ie you should be able to find better growth opportunities). Same goes for mergers - a merger is supposed to get you synergies that grow you more than you’d be able to accomplish by yourself.
- vkou 4y ago> So buying $1B worth of gold should result in a decrease of market cap because the market will typically discount the future value of doing that (ie you should be able to find better growth opportunities). They bought the $1B worth of gold using $1B worth of cash. It's true that gold doesn't have future cash flows, but neither does a pile of cash. > Same goes for mergers - a merger is supposed to get you synergies that grow you more than you’d be able to accomplish by yourself. A merger not resulting in a stock bump means that the market doesn't think it's a smart merger. My point was that it doesn't mean that the market thinks that whatever you bought was worthless. If a company spent $1B on a worthless thing (By making a big pile of money, and setting it on fire), you'd expect its market cap to drop.