3 ms·
You submitted two links, both to an industry group headed up by Guus Berkhout: [quote] Berkhout founded the Netherlands-based organization Climate Intellige
by defrost 4y ago
You submitted two links, both to an industry group headed up by Guus Berkhout:
[quote]
Berkhout founded the Netherlands-based organization Climate Intelligence Foundation (CLINTEL).
Mid 2019 plans of CLINTEL and Berkhout were leaked showing that they were organizing a campaign against political commitments to net zero carbon emissions being made into law. The campaign features a number of academics and industry figures with ties to climate change sceptics groups, as well as members from oil and gas companies.
Berkhout claimed the ideal of the organization was to provide an alternative to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
In late September 2019 the group produced an open letter which presented a European Climate Declaration, stating that there was no climate emergency and repeating a number of claims that were inconsistent with the scientific evidence on climate.
A fact check performed by climate scientists for Climate Feedback gave the letter an overall scientific credibility of "very low", and tagged it as "Biased, Cherry-picking, Inaccurate, Misleading".
The analysis also added that, out of the roughly 500 signatories, only 10 self-identified as climate scientists.
The document was later rebranded as the World Climate Declaration.
[/quote]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guus_Berkhout https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guus_Berkhout
Climate Science (as laid out by the IPCC) is akin to Foucoult's Pendulum; the earth rotates, and human activity is altering the atmosphere in a measurable manner that traps more heat energy than is normally retained.
You may have a contrarian opinion about measurable facts .. but there are bars and cafes for those.
- mactavish88 4y agoSo this is exactly the perspective I’m looking for from HN. If my post (which clearly wasn’t for or against the linked material) was not immediately flagged and killed then it would’ve been possible to actually solicit this kind of perspective. But if my post is immediately killed then I never get to see this kind of insight. Hence my question about whether there’s a better model than simply flagging content, as HN currently works.
- theCrowing 4y ago[flagged]
- whythre 4y agoI am trying not to read this with hostile intent, but seriously, why discuss or ask anything if the OP could just be told to do the mental legwork themselves? Sometimes outside perspective is helpful.
- theCrowing 4y agoI perceive the lack of basic research or education on a subject as a sign of hostile intent especially when an individual creates a thread and expresses their views vehemently without proper knowledge or understanding. It's not even a topic (HN moderation) that is hard to research, he just didn't. It's also a repeating pattern he did the same with his initial submission and afterwards with this thread. 1-2 hours after he submitted the thread, he pivoted to his UX argument which makes even less sense because that's fundamentally his problem he needs to understand the site he is on, and he didn't even know about the "showdead" switch in the profile view. Which means in close to 4 years he didn't read the FAQ. How can you advocate for change if you don't even understand the system that is in place and without doing even the most basic research yourself?
- mactavish88 4y agoWho said you had to do the work? If this was a topic that was somehow discussed previously, should there not be some kind of mechanism to indicate this in the flagging process? (Ideally automated)
- theCrowing 4y agoClintel was even in the news cycle a few years ago and you submit it without even googling it before? You impute that I have a particular stance on climate change, but I honestly believe you have because no person without an agenda would play naive like you. I myself just hate misinformation and people that share and play victim when nobody engages with it.