3 ms·
The kind of thing that often would come up in clinical trials I’m glad people are researching this and other peculiarities from all angles, I got a lot of dism
by yieldcrv 4y ago
The kind of thing that often would come up in clinical trials
I’m glad people are researching this and other peculiarities from all angles, I got a lot of dismissive comments in 2021 about an opportunistic pathogen being a culprit for some issues
but the dismissiveness was paradoxical “scientists didn't study that so they must have ruled it out, stop fearmongering”
people didn't like the idea that there could be a parallel infection going around
annoying
- lamontcg 4y ago> people didn't like the idea that there could be a parallel infection going around That sounds like fearmongering though. This is a combination of at least two (if not more) unlikely factors happening in the same person. One of the is prior exposure to a pathogen, one of them is having the right kind of gene, and this study can't rule out other additional factors. The pathogen is likely to be something which has been with the human race for thousands of years, not anything novel to the human race like SARS-CoV-2. There's no point in trying to change your behavior to avoid trying to contact this other pathogen. The pathogen may also be something incredibly common, but other accidental factors conspire to produce this exact antibody.
- maxboone 4y agoIt wouldn't though, as it didn't pop up in the exceptionally large phase 3 trials. Probably because the clotting risk of COVID is higher.
- tsimionescu 4y agoNote that the study didn't find any opportunistic infection. It found that the immune response in people who had the blood clot problem suggests that they have previously been infected with some pathogen that happens to resemble the adenovirus vector used by AZ: > That [the very quick progression of the blood clotting issue] suggested, Gordon said, their immune systems had already experienced this strange combination of adenovirus and PF4 – or something that looked a lot like it.
- kaba0 4y agoThe probability of having that particular gene AND having been exposed to a specific pathogen before is quite unlikely
- themitigating 4y ago"got a lot of dismissive comments in 2021 about an opportunistic pathogen being a culprit for some issues" Did you have any evidence or were you just throwing out hypotheticals?
- yieldcrv 4y agoI think its fine to talk about ideas that may have been overlooked In the past the same issue has occurred and it took years or nearly a decade to discover multi-variable components to ailments, let alone discover the new virus or bacteria “Hey has anyone considered how this looks exactly like this other issue, is anybody putting resources into that” “I don’t want to think about that so do you have any evidence!?” its paradoxical, the people that would acquire the evidence are doing something else, more reactionary
- neuronic 4y agoYou're right, and this was unfortunate. However, I think this is closely related to the nature of modern online discussions where this kind of oversensitivity to perceived "hostile" information is met with an unreasonably forceful response by either side. First of all the neutral facts: all the major Western vaccines were immensely helpful to soften the impact of COVID on our societies. Some turned out better than others, mRNA vaccines proved to be the major breakthrough that scientists expected. None of the vaccines are without issues (blood clots, myocarditis etc.) but they are significantly better than the consequences of millions of unprepared COVID infections without prior immunization (Long COVID/Post-Viral Syndrome, long-term hospital stays, death, overwhelmed healthcare systems...). Some folks and especially health institutions were calmly discussing and weighing benefits vs. costs and risk. But on the public side, online discussions once again moved into opposing "teams" which seemingly happens to a lot of political/culture war discussions: - Team A were staunch supporters of getting everyone everywhere immediately vaxxed with no room left for discussion at all, not even on the scientific level - Team B was spreading misinformation to spread unfounded fear and hate against the vaccines based on insane conspirational theories and easily dismissed bullshit information - Team C was the rather silent but very large majority that was rather supportive of the vaccines but just kind of apathetic, never really getting into heated discussions about it online or offline, just doing whatever needed to be done. While A and B represent the extremes, what's interesting to me about Team B is that it appeared as a minority in the population when actually looking at polls or protests [1]. But online they were way louder, amplified actually, to a degree that is really notable. And this is, in my view, often the case in online discussions. I think it's also safe to say the opponents (Team B) were not rarely fueled by foreign agents to further instigate the culture wars in both Europe and the US, thereby politically weakening and destabilizing the countries from within. At the same time I wouldn't be surprised if the very strong supporters were influenced just as much because in order to fuel a divide you may need to prop up both sides. [1] https://www.dovepress.com/a-global-map-of-covid-19-vaccine-acceptance-rates-per-country-an-updat-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-JMDH https://www.dovepress.com/a-global-map-of-covid-19-vaccine-a...