5 ms·
Was reading the policy document when this “innocuous” paragraph struck me. Am I misunderstanding something? > Regarding freedom of teaching, faculty do not hav
by vlovich123 4y ago
Was reading the policy document when this “innocuous” paragraph struck me. Am I misunderstanding something?
> Regarding freedom of teaching, faculty do not have total discretion over their course content. For example, a class titled “Beginning Chinese” cannot be taught as an advanced calculus class. And department heads would be within their rights to consider faculty members’ expertise in the process of making or adjusting teaching assignments. Working within our standard administrative structures such as curriculum planning committees, faculty generally should be able to teach the scholarly content they wish. Academic freedom does not give faculty members the unfettered right to advocate political beliefs in their classrooms that are irrelevant to the course content. Such political expression should be grounded in the faculty member’s expertise, relevant to the subject matter, and consistent with both sound pedagogical principles and the achievement of learning objectives.
The exercise of academic freedom with respect to research, publication, and teaching takes place in a context of scholarly rigor. Evaluating the strength of arguments and the quality of ideas is intrinsic to research and education processes. Aside from cases where evidence of invidious discrimination exists, faculty members cannot claim that the denial of tenure based on a professional assessment of the faculty member’s scholarship constitutes censorship. Nor can a student receiving a less than desired grade in a class claim that wrong answers are a form of protected speech. Though faculty and researchers have a good deal of freedom, that freedom is exercised in an academic context in which disciplinary competence and professional judgment are crucial to knowledge production and education.19
Freedom of intramural expression means that faculty members should be able to speak their minds about their own institution and its policies. MIT strongly values this freedom
Isn’t this saying “stay in your lane and only express political views if it’s relevant to your academic discipline”. An engineering professor might have a thing or two to say about copyright but since their academic profession isn’t law, they’re not allowed to opine on it? A biology professor might not agree with climate policy of the current administration and that means they can’t speak their opinion because they’re not a climatologist nor a political scientist? Isn’t academic freedom supposed to be the opportunity to mix in thoughts from outside the field so that blind spots can be examined? Stratifying and isolating freedom of speech in this manner would seem to encourage intellectual isolation. Not something I’d want to see from an institution that’s supposed to be educating the next generation of great thinkers who aren’t bound by conventional thinking. Of course, I probably just misunderstood what this is saying. I didn’t go to MIT and I never did do well in English class.
- PakG1 4y agoWonder what they would think of Noam Chomsky being a linguist and cognitive scientist.
- defrost 4y agoGiven he is an Institute Professor Emeritus at MIT I have a sneaking suspicion that they're fully aware of that, and his work in history, media studies, etc. I also suspect that when he taught he taught linguistics and grammar in classes to do with such things and left media analysis to other classes or the commons. As per the outline above; stick to the course outline in course classes.
- john_the_writer 4y agoI would expect he would have an interesting idea on the link between language acquisition and the brain. It is rather easy to understand how the way we interact would be linked to the structure of our brain.
- bruce511 4y agoNote the use of the words "in the classroom". Free speech is about time and place. They are saying that speech can be free, but going into a political rant in the middle of a class on calculus is not appropriate. Free speech is about saying what you like, but in a context where others are free to leave. I can't leave my class without prejudicing my grade, but I didn't sign up for your diatribes on human diet.
- komali2 4y ago> Free speech is about saying what you like, but in a context where others are free to leave An excellent example of the comment I was trying to wrangle in my head, inspired by our shared OP: this whole idea of "free speech" or "not free speech," and this university's attempt to codify it, seems remarkably oversimplified still. First, where did you get this extra context that our OP and I both seem to be missing, that "free speech is about time and place," or that political rants are only ok when people are "free to leave?" I'm not finding anything like that clicking through the links. Is this just your personal value about what you believe "Free speech" to be? Does MIT agree? Has MIT codified something like this? I'd like to read it, if so, because I'm very interested in this conversation and idea. I'm very interested, because I disagree with you that there is a context (in this university scenario) where "others are free to leave." Easy: extracurricular activities, common ways to get bonus points or saddle up with the professor. Your philosophy teacher likes to go to the local libertarian debate club, a place where a common topic is whether gay people should be "allowed" to get married. The professor encourages students to come, either to "challenge" themselves, or, write a paper on what they observe, or straight up as a bonus points opportunity, whatever. If you think the explicit bonus points is unrealistic or a practice that should end, instead consider the "soft bonus" by attending based on the professor's recommendation alone. In any case, gay students really aren't interested in hearing their very existence being debated, and prejudice their grade by not going. Nobody else faces this difficulty. Better: a gay student comes, and argues whether white people should be allowed to marry if gay people can't, because there's functionally no difference ethically there, and prejudice their white teacher against them. Can you pick up what I'm puttin down here? My argument is essentially that your point ignores both explicit and implicit power dynamics that underlie this debate. The same dynamics that make "cracker" a far less harmful word than the n-word, or, make a romantic relationship between two adults problematic if one adult happens to be the other's active professor. I feel like this context is often simply ignored, and I believe that that's because the people that get to decide what these statements coming out of these working groups look like, are people that are mouthpieces for the existent hierarchies that are protecting themselves from change and criticism, the blowback that many are calling "cancel culture" and others are simply calling "consequences for actions."