4 ms·
> I've also seen instances of individuals defending free speech because they hold unpopular (or sometimes even hurtful) opinions Well, popular opinion needs no
by lelanthran 4y ago
> I've also seen instances of individuals defending free speech because they hold unpopular (or sometimes even hurtful) opinions
Well, popular opinion needs no protections.
- hyperjeff 4y agoThere is often a wide gap between a popular opinion, perhaps softly or unspoken, and what is widely accepted and popular expression. Often popular opinions have few protections, and it leads to double-speak and coded or indirect language. Assuming that what is freely expressed is a reflection of popular opinion can lead to important misunderstandings.
- hgsgm 4y agoSure they do, if the people in power have minority opinions.
- ohbtvz 4y agoTell that to Iranians...
- Kranar 4y agoIgnoring the abhorrent treatment of women in Iran, using the current protest as a measure of popularity would be as faulty as using the Occupy Wall Street protests as a measure of popularity, or in Canada, the Convoy Protests. Unfortunately, as far as most of what I can find on the subject, most Iranians (who live in Iran) are either indifferent or opposed to the people currently protesting in Iran and Iran has a majority population that is highly religious and loyal to the current government. It's mostly in the big cities, like Tehran or Shiraz where the protests enjoy support and the population is more liberal, but outside of the big cities in more rural areas people are much more religious and supportive of the regime. I am certainly welcome to be corrected on this though.
- 8note 4y agoI don't think it's unlikely that there's more people in the big cities in Iran than there are outside, and that the people inside those cities should get laws that they agree with, well, even if the people outside the cities disagree with them
- bozhark 4y agoHard to analyze true intent when people are being killed for expressing them selves
- agalunar 4y agoTrue! I was just pointing out that this is different from defending free speech; it's simply wanting people to listen to you. (And so it may be deceptive to claim your goal is free speech when, in reality, you will only fight for free speech while your opinion is the unpopular one.)
- 8note 4y agoMind you, those opinions are held by the powerful, who's opinions also need no protection. The unpowerful, unpopular ideas don't even get calls for protection
- mlindner 4y agoIf the powerful have no protections then they won’t be the powerful for long and then the shoe will be on the other foot and a new powerful elite will be created (ostensibly what is happening right now as a certain group of elite have largely taken control of both the media system and the school system).
- whatshisface 4y agoFree speech as a concept means that the unpowerful, unpopular ideas are protected by the same laws that protect powerful unpopular ideas. If you want to protect only the latter, you need to convince your culture that they want free political speech with exceptions. The whole point of lumping all speech together for the purposes of making it free is that the powerful can't make exceptions. Once you've said one kind of speech is coming from "the powerful," you've said that they are the ones deciding which ideas get to be exceptions! Surely we know better than to give the powerful more power as a means of protecting the powerless from them. Is it not contradictory to imagine that "the powerful" will not write these laws and decide how they are interpreted and enforced, when their ability to do those things is the definition of the set we, in this thought experiment, identify them as? In fact, the point you are making about unequal protection under imbalances of power is perhaps even an argument for maintaining an absolutist stance against reasonable exceptions - because that's an effective tactic for protecting something in a flawed political world that can turn those exceptions into things you didn't imagine when voicing support for them.