3 ms·
>Where are all those “it’s a private company they can do what they like” folks now? I haven’t seen that posted recently. Those people were responding to argume
by krapp 4y ago
>Where are all those “it’s a private company they can do what they like” folks now? I haven’t seen that posted recently.
Those people were responding to arguments that social media platforms banning people, moderating content or even presenting content under an algorithmic feed were violations of the First Amendment, Section 230 and freedom of speech, by pointing out that all of these actions are allowed by the aforementioned principles and laws. That argument hasn't been posted recently because the threads in which the free-speech absolutist arguments to which it replies haven't been posted recently. It isn't germane to the situation wrt Musk and Twitter because, for whatever reason, the free speech absolutists no longer have a problem with censorship by private enterprise when Elon Musk is doing it, and so they no longer post angry, long-winded screeds against it.
And notwithstanding that Twitter banning journalists (even for just 12 hours) is a much more serious deal in terms of freedom of speech implications than banning some shitposting Nazis, no one complaining about that is actually claiming that Elon doesn't have the right to do what he's doing, nor are they calling for the government to make it illegal, as the free speech absolutist crowd has - they're just calling him a hypocrite and an asshole. Because he is.
This really isn't the dunk you and the countless others who keep bringing it up is, it just demonstrates that the free speech absolutist crowd were never arguing in good faith to begin with, because none of them ever bothered to actually listen to or engage with the arguments being made.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoSo, when Twitter banned the NY Post at the recommendation of the FBI, that wasn’t an issue? I don’t see how suspending a few journalists for 12 hours and being directly able to point to their existing TOS is the same thing.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThese bans weren’t under “their existing TOS”. The policy was rewritten after banning @elonjet to justify it retroactively. The bans weren’t 12 hours. They were eventually announced as week-long ones; Musk backed down after backlash and his public poll resulted in a “unban now” vote.
- clucas 4y agoPlenty of white nationalists were banned from Twitter due to TOS violations. I seem to recall the free speech "absolutists" still being upset about those bans. Why is TOS violation suddenly a good reason to ban?