2 ms·
Potential risk... MIT already seemed to have much more narrow-experience libertarians than other schools I've been around. If the bulk of the prestigious scho
by neilv 4y ago
Potential risk...
MIT already seemed to have much more narrow-experience libertarians than other schools I've been around.
If the bulk of the prestigious schools are perceived as "woke", are the angriest opposition to that going to disproportionately go to the prestigious schools perceived as "non-woke"?
Even if a school is more re-embracing a traditional university marketplace of ideas and collegial dialogue, while also learning to be much better than in the past wrt treating people fairly and being open to everyone... will there ironically be disproportionate applications (and admission) of students who're especially resistant to those aspirations?
Analogues that might be familiar from recent years: anonymous forums attracting the worst behavior, and "free speech" claimed as a battle cry by those who don't seem to have the lofty ideals behind that.
(To be clear, I think some of what I called "the angriest opposition" should be in a university marketplace of ideas. And that, ideally, their thinking evolves during a college journey, at the same time that their input helps evolve everyone else's thinking. The risk I'm concerned about is whether there will be so much "the angriest opposition" that it breaks the marketplace.)
- turzmo 4y agoI don’t think so. Unlike online forums, people attend MIT for considerations far more important to them than politics. MIT students are also typically less politically minded than other top schools
- neilv 4y agoBoth your points seem true to me. But the hypothetical effect I'm wondering about isn't as much due t the typical students, as to the disproportionate number of "angriest opposition" individuals who did select because "non-woke" was a big factor in their decision. So, imagine typical students being non-political, but still a lot of students who are political, and specifically on the side of really stamping-out anything they perceive as woke (or not according to market principles, or oppressing generational-wealth white males, or whatever). And maybe not enough people around who are able and willing to engage them with counterpoints. To the extent that political action does happen, that sounds to me like it could push MIT culture in a bad direction.