4 ms·
> So, transporting hydrogen at scale is a problem because even chilled to near absolute zero it's still way less energy dense by volume than liquid LNG. What a
by defrost 4y ago
> So, transporting hydrogen at scale is a problem because even chilled to near absolute zero it's still way less energy dense by volume than liquid LNG.
What about transporting Ammonia .. that's three H and and an N .. different beast.
- c54 4y agoBetter still is synthesizing methane from the hydrogen and transporting that. Three H and a C
- defrost 4y ago'Better' is always subjective - methane spills from a 1 km long shipping vessel is a lot of potent greenhouse gas back in the air, with an end point issue of using the methane without the C binding and creating CO2 - versus the ammonia with just Nitrogen as waste (or going into ag soils). Mind you ammonia is an irritating gas and no fun spilled in water at sea .. so, yeah. The main take home point is that the argument against hydrogen because it's a tiny slippery hard to teansport molecule is a complete furphy - there are other options.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoOf course those inefficiencies multiply. You generate hydrogen at 30/40% efficiency. You generate methane from that at a similar efficiency. Then you compress it ... which takes energy. You ship it around. Which takes energy. Then you burn it at 40% efficiency. Numbers rounded up here. Real world efficiencies are worse. Multiply all of that and you end up with efficiencies of a few percent. Nice that it can be done at great cost but there are a lot of things that are probably more efficient and cheaper.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoIt works, but you loose some more energy. Better still is to make fertilizer with that and ship that out. Shipping ammonia half way around the world with the intention of using it as a fuel doesn't make sense from an efficiency point of view. You loose so much energy creating the hydrogen, transforming it into ammonia, shipping it around, and then turning it back into mechanical or electrical energy, which again is not super efficient. By the time that is done, you are looking at maybe 10% efficient (possibly way less). So, it's a very costly way to move stuff around using ammonia as a fuel. Nice that it works but unlikely to be a preferred solution aside from some niche use cases. And while ammonia is better then hydrogen in terms of volumetric density. It's still about half of what lng gives. So, you need two ammonia ships for every lng ship to deliver the same amount of energy. That same property also is an issue with bio kerosene vs. ammonia in planes.