3 ms·
It sucks for things that can be monetised. Searching info on products for example. Just because SEO spammers are too good. text generators will make this proble
by Gigachad 4y ago
It sucks for things that can be monetised. Searching info on products for example. Just because SEO spammers are too good. text generators will make this problem so much worse because the spam will look exactly like the hand made content.
- charcircuit 4y agoquery: "apple watch" 1st result: https://www.apple.com/watch/ https://www.apple.com/watch/ Google worked perfectly for me when I wanted to buy a product.
- Gigachad 4y agoFor the most trivial queries. Try something like “best frypan” and it becomes a lot harder to find real content that isn’t sponsored junk. Adding “reddit” to the query is the best option so far.
- klabb3 4y ago> Adding “reddit” to the query is the best option so far. Case in point. The fact that this works really well for this type of content means that Google has failed. Now whether they failed deliberately or not is a different question. In either case, search needs to be demonopolized. The truth is we don’t even know what search would be like without the Google hegemony. Even if all language models do is force Google to innovate and improve it’s worth every penny.
- charcircuit 4y agoGoogle doesn't know the fact of what frying pan is objectively the best and websites containing such an answer are going to be biased. That's an impossible query to answer with more personalization which may not even be possible.
- Gigachad 4y agoGood results exist, and they are mostly on reddit. The commercial blogspam drowns out the quality though.
- AussieWog93 4y agoThe point is that if you search "best frypan reddit", you'll get real recommendations from real people who have actually used the product. Maybe you won't find the objectively best frypan on Earth, but you'll find a very good one along some information about why that particular product is good. If you simply search "best frypan", you'll get lists of affiliate links to overpriced Chinese crap, written by someone who has never even looked at any of the products in person and frankly doesn't even care if they're any good. Google shouldn't be expected to know everything, but it should know that someone searching for "best frypan" is looking for real recommendations and not literal spam pumped out by a content mill. Searching for services like appliance repair or removalists are even worse, to the point where I'll now just ask on private Facebook groups for recommendations.
- alvah 4y agoquery: “best smart watch” Pages and pages of SEO spam, generally ranked by how big & established the site pushing said spam is, rather than any unique insights contained within.
- charcircuit 4y agoThat query is generic so you get generic results. What is best is is poorly defined.
- Gigachad 4y agoBack in the day you’d buy a magazine which would contain reviews of all the current years products and it would be somewhat decent. Now it’s all auto generated mass spammed garbage and affiliate links. I guess the market responded with brand loyalty. If you have an iPhone, you just buy the Apple Watch, you don’t look further. If you have a pixel phone, you just buy whatever google sells.
- alvah 4y agoSurely one of the purposes of a search engine is to assist the journey from generic to specific. I don’t see how filling page 1 for generic queries with non-specific DR90+ behemoths helps.
- charcircuit 4y agoIt's hard to do. If you were a search engine and someone searched "dog" what websites would you return? You can't really tell what the user wants.
- alvah 4y agoOf course it’s hard. My point is that the current version of the algorithm gives undue weight to factors other than what the user wants.