2 ms·
They are not a replacement, but unfortunately search engines are turning into AI chatbots too. When I think of a search engine I want a "grep for the Internet"
by userbinator 4y ago
They are not a replacement, but unfortunately search engines are turning into AI chatbots too.
When I think of a search engine I want a "grep for the Internet", not an "AI".
Looking up part numbers for ICs and other electronic components is the most prominent application where search engines like Google have gotten far worse in recent years, and AI ain't going to work there either.
- enlyth 4y agoA grep for the internet is what most of us technical users want, but they are optimizing for the more common user who structures queries more like natural language (e.g. "How can I tie my shoelaces so they don't get untied easily") instead of what me or you would query ("secure shoelace knots") I'm surprised there hasn't been a separation of some sort of more technical search engine for developers and the classic Google experience where some neural network tries to make sense of your poorly written human language phrased question
- rtkwe 4y agoWe used to have just Internet grep but it was awful because sites just slammed tons of keywords into invisible text to get fake traffic. That's what spawned the original innovation at Google of PageRank and thus the SEO wars started. Going back to that wouldn't solve the issue with modern search.
- grugagag 4y agoIf we only had a downvote or don’t show me results from this source this problem would be solved. Google didn’t want to give us that feature because of … different incentives, no other reason comes to mind. I’ve witnessed google search become worse and worse and now it’s barely useful
- rtkwe 4y agoThat would cut down on some of the concentrated SEO spam centers but I think you'd still be fighting an endless battle with more distributed SEO spam sites that are more focused on one point.
- tag2103 4y agoI know they would not do this but you aren't the only one that thinks in those veins. I'm so tired of all of the pinterest spam I pretty much gave up on google for anything other than code searches which funny enough can be done better and more naturally through a GPT type AI.
- lamontcg 4y ago> A grep for the internet is what most of us technical users want not really. the problem is that is way too easy to game. i want that when you really get down to highly specific technical details, but not for the average everyday internet search where i'm not searching for something that thousands of people haven't searched for in the past week.
- Too 4y agoThey are optimizing for ads. Asking how to tie your shoelaces usually start with three sponsored links where you can buy shoelaces.
- PeterisP 4y agoGrep for the internet works if and only if the most appropriate page on the internet is actually good. There are many questions for which the ChatGPT answer is more useful than the canonical documentation page I already have open in another tab, which includes a huge amount of extra information that is irrelevant for me (and thus requires effort to parse) and the key bits are scattered all over it; the chatbot can do the extraction and summarization work for me.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoWe probably will end up with AI using search engines to tell us what we are looking for. The process of using your eyes to look at search results is something an AI can do for us. That's different from a pre-trained model that already knows what you are looking for and doesn't need to go out and look for it. That's what chat-gpt is today. All Google needs to do is upgrade the frontend to their search engine to be a conversational AI that knows how to query their search engine effectively. Of course easier said then done and Google's inability to implement big technical changes to their core products is becoming a problem. This should be in their comfort zone; but it isn't. It's not about what they can do but about what they are willing to do. And they seem hesitant to commit to doing anything, often withdrawing products before they've even had a chance to fail properly. The big hurdles here are going to be cost and controversy. Doing this stuff at scale is going to be expensive. That comes straight out of their profit margin. And inevitably there are going to be controversies with AI getting it wrong, being biased, offensive, etc. Also not great for profits. Google is the wrong company to be doing this. That's why OpenAI is going where Google would be well capable of going without actually going there. One of those two companies is going to get billions of revenue in paid accounts next year for AI services. The other one is going to be obsessing about their add revenue. I expect a few more startups might jump in this space once the money start flowing.