2 ms·
FWIW, my personal experince... I have interviewed over 2500 programmer applicants, all having passed a "resume screening". I terminated 50% of the interviews
by edw519 18y ago
FWIW, my personal experince...
I have interviewed over 2500 programmer applicants, all having passed a "resume screening". I terminated 50% of the interviews before reaching the coding test because I knew by then that it would be a waste of time. Of the other 50%, 90% couldn't pass the simple coding test. I ended up hiring or referring less than 100.
Anyone else have similar experience with these percentages?
- pmjordan 18y agoMy sample size is much smaller, (I quit a few months after I started getting involved with hiring at my last job) but they sound about right. It's pretty amazing how easy it is to get a degree in compsci or game development and have no programming competence whatsoever. What amazed me too was the astounding quantity of terrible CVs, even among people who supposedly have a substantial amount of experience. I used to laugh at articles telling you to spell check your application and give other, seemingly extremely basic advice, but I swear about 80-90% of applications have glaring spelling, grammar and semantic mistakes and no discernible logical structure. Come on, how hard is it to assemble a chronological list of things you've done?
- bigthboy 18y agoSometimes those mistakes don't come from competency of the program writer but rather the translator... "All your base are belong to us!"
- pmjordan 18y agoOh, don't worry - I wasn't complaining about immigrants. I'm talking about people who (according to their CV, and by the sound of their name) had spent all their life in the UK.
- gaius 18y agoOne thing you need to watch out for is recruiters "reformatting" people's CVs, possibly without their knowledge, into their "house style". One candidate I interviewed happened to bring an original copy of his CV with him, it was quite radically different to what I had in my hands.
- staunch 18y agoI never call people in for interviews without a phone screening. It's a waste of their time and mine.
- biohacker42 18y agoCould it be good programmers are worse resume writers? Perhaps if you had a different way of pre-screening candidates, something besides resumes. Perhaps even if the pre-screening itself took much more time then scanning a resume - overall it might end up saving time?
- Wesha 18y ago> Could it be good programmers are worse resume writers? Judging by myself: FSCKING YES!!! The only thing I hate more than resume writing is Java, This freaking "resume screening" selects best resume writers, not best programmers.
- fendale 18y agoOh come on - writing a resume is not that hard! Its two pages max, and while I agree its the most tedious undesirable task in the world, 3 or 4 hours spent on it will sort it once and for all. Then all you have to do is update it every 3 - 6 months for 30 minutes and it will always be ready to use. Its basically just a bunch of buzz words on the skills you have, and a paragraph about your last few positions/roles.
- dcminter 18y agoI rather like Joel Spolsky's observation that when one is hiring one is not selecting from the population of programmers, but rather from the population of programmers without jobs. A very different prospect.
- aneesh 18y agoNot necessarily. Often the best candidates are the ones you have to tempt out of their current position.