3 ms·
I think there's a point the author almost makes here that's pretty important. > When there’s one rich guy in town and everybody else is starving, it doesn’t se
by godelski 4y ago
I think there's a point the author almost makes here that's pretty important.
> When there’s one rich guy in town and everybody else is starving, it doesn’t seem that crazy to go smash his windows and steal his food. But when there’s 50 rich guys in town, somehow the state of affairs seems fairer.
A major problem we've had in the last century is population explosion. Since the 50's but the world population and US population (and many country's populations) have nearly tripled. All the metrics being discussed here are percentile based. But if we see a higher percentile based level of inequality (e.g. compared to the 20's in the early part of the post) we would have a higher number of disproportionately rich people.
There's simply the possibility that with such a large population size that monopolies are more difficult than ever BUT the problems that monopolies exhibit (they aren't always bad, but they are bad because they leverage they are able to abuse) are also just as bad with oligopolies. It really comes down to a decentralization problem. They say money begets money, but that's true for almost every resource. Even Adam Smith was against these massive conglomerates. We've had a long history of monopoly busting (albeit often too late) but the problem at hand now is that it isn't so obvious anymore. There's no clear monopolies but we see collusion and all the effects as if monopolies existed. Do we really need to squabble when someone says "x is a monopoly" and there are other players in the field? People are just saying "x has a disproportionate amount of control over y industry and are abusing that power." I think we all need to think seriously about this because if we don't allow for a substantial amount of nuance in these conversations and don't work together (even if we disagree in part) then the problems we face will accelerate. A big reason this will accelerate is the Yard-Sale Model
https://pudding.cool/2022/12/yard-sale/ https://pudding.cool/2022/12/yard-sale/