4 ms·
> So what? We all know in principle that this reasoning can be written down formally in ZFC with enough effort But how can you know this? You're starting from
by zozbot234 4y ago
> So what? We all know in principle that this reasoning can be written down formally in ZFC with enough effort
But how can you know this? You're starting from reasoning in natural language that, by your own admission, sometimes engages in "sloppy" abuses of notation, such as treating isomorphism as if it could be equated with identity. Whenever mathematicians argue that "this can be written down formally in ZFC" they're essentially using a sloppy, informal, ad-hoc version of type theory and higher-level logic in the process; they're merely in denial about this point.
- spekcular 4y agoI understand your last sentence to agree with the statement that everything could be formalized in ZFC given sufficient effort. (I do not really care by what means we know this can be done.) If so, then I'm not sure why you disagree with what I wrote previously.
- zozbot234 4y ago> everything could be formalized in ZFC given sufficient effort Since I'm not sure what could be comprised under "everything", I don't think I can agree with that statement. The whole point of "practical" formalization efforts is to add some rigor to such assertions. And you've acknowledged that type theoretical foundations can be useful to practitioners, so what's it exactly that you disagree about?
- spekcular 4y agoThe disagreement is about whether there are reasons aside from facilitating formalization to care about HoTT. (Because if not, it seems like we should all be jumping on the Lean bandwagon instead.)