8 ms·
I'm sorry, but the idea that tech journalism doesn't know what to do with Mastodon because it's an open-source platform that doesn't fit into commercial startup
by crazygringo 4y ago
I'm sorry, but the idea that tech journalism doesn't know what to do with Mastodon because it's an open-source platform that doesn't fit into commercial startup narratives is... utter nonsense.
Tech journalism does just fine with open standards/software/platforms like e-mail, domain names, torrenting, Linux, crypto. None of these fall into commercial startup narratives, yet journalists cover these things just as well as everything else.
> The media seems to be regarding Mastodon as a bizarre curiosity, something that the general public couldn’t possibly grasp. Sure, the guys with a Linux server in their basement might geek out on it, but this thing isn’t for the masses.
I mean, that's pretty accurate. It's easy to sign up for Twitter, it follows all of your expectations of how apps work. Not only is it hard to sign up for Mastodon, but it's hard to even figure out how to figure it out. Mastodon isn't for the masses in its current state.
So as far as I can tell, the tech journalists are covering it quite appropriately.
- Dawnyhf2 4y agoTo my mind these websites are equally user hostile, twitter is extremely confusing to people who just signed up, too much influencer spam and it makes you login to find out that the stuff is just influencer spam. People who started Twitter earlier have a way better experience.
- robswc 4y agoI noticed this too. I made an account for a business and it was just odd. Maybe they’re targeting the younger generation? If not, that’s certainly what it felt like when signing up, lol.
- robswc 4y agoYep. It sounds silly but I learn more and more to just make things as frictionless as possible. Someone explained how to sign up and the first instance I found said it was shutting down soon and to migrate off. A few others I tried said they weren’t accepting new users and eventually I gave up. The funny thing is I swear I figured it out a few years back and don’t remember it being like that but maybe I just had more patience. Is there a reason you can’t just create your own identity, without an instance?
- nequo 4y ago> Is there a reason you can’t just create your own identity, without an instance? It looks like Mastodon has aimed for total decentralization like email, rather than the kind of decentralization that IRC does that still keeps identities centrally managed with nick servers (e.g., how irc.libera.chat works). Presumably, managing identity verification would be much cheaper than managing the content, so Mastodon or something like it should be able to scalably do it centrally, while still federating separate instances for the content.
- robswc 4y agoI feel like if they did that, the service would be 100x more viable… but would lose its claim to total decentralization. Idk, good luck to anyone that does a social media site cause that seems like a hard problem to solve.
- unshavedyak 4y agoI like Mastodon, i use it daily. BUT, i kinda feel it loses that claim already. I am disincentivized to run my own instance, aka "distribute". It pushes for centralization. On multiple fronts. Why? Well for starters the protocol as i'm aware of does not efficiently federate to smaller instances compared to bigger instances. I also fear that instances will eventually be plagued by spam / attacks from foreign small instances and will be pushed towards whitelisting federation rather than blacklisting. As the general philosophy of federation seems to match that of Email. Email.. tbh, feels like a failed technology. Yes i know, i love email and we all use it.. but it's incredibly centralized and insanely vulnerable to massive amounts of spam. The protocol almost pushes people to centralize to deal with problems that the Email protocol doesn't manage - spam. I fear Mastodon will eventually follow the same path. I use it, but i have to ignore the protocol and my desire to decentralize.. because otherwise i just get frustrated.
- robswc 4y agoThat makes sense. I was looking for an instance and they listed their server specs. They were very small servers. Would they be susceptible to simple DDOS?
- nicoco 4y ago>It's easy to sign up for Twitter, it follows all of your expectations of how apps work I always find it funny when I read things like that about twitter, because I honestly wanted to see what it was several times and I swear I could never figure it out. I know I am most likely an outlier, and yes, I have a Linux server sitting below my desk (my basement is way too damp).
- le-mark 4y agoYou are not alone. It’s always been inscrutable to me as well.
- nicoco 4y agoFWIW, I've been giving the fediverse a try for 2 weeks now and it's slightly less obscure without the crazy "algorithmic" timeline. Chronology is less confusing than machine recommendations. Who would've thought?
- NikolaNovak 4y ago"Mastodon isn't for the masses in its current state." Fwiw, Even for somewhat geeky guys with kids and family and busy lives, Mastodon isn't friction less enough. That being said, for a somewhat geeky guy, twitter is also hard to sign up - if you don't want to give them your phone number and other personal information, it's full of dark patterns. Less of an issue for non geeky folks though.
- Brendinooo 4y agoYeah this is a good point. There’s a lot of learned helplessness in my opinion. People who don’t want to switch away from Twitter and are used to its quirks (and yes, there are absolutely quirks) are far more incline to throw up their hands and say it’s too hard.
- chefandy 4y agoI think it's a bit disingenuous to say it's difficult to sign up rather than it being difficult to protect your privacy while signing up. That's a different thing and the distinction is important to any future attempt to get the general public to adopt FOSS social media. Twitter deliberately requires too much effort and knowledge to keep your info private. They do that because they know most people either can't or won't go through with it. The privacy-focused software world understands how problematic that is. Mastodon, because it was created as a tech-first solution without deliberately building user paths for non-technical users, requires to much effort and knowledge to sign up for and use at all. For some reason, pointing out that most people either can't or won't go through with it is sacrilege. It gets met with minimizing statements about how simple it all really is, and stories about tech-naive people they've explained it to, or dismiss it by saying that it doesn't have to be for non-technical people while ignoring the larger discussion about what the FOSS world thinks they can replace with it. The only people who misunderstand mastodon are the people who misunderstand regular users capacity for complexity in social media, or the complexity of actually using it like users want to use it... A centralized asynchronous way to easily contect with everyone else that uses it. If it doesn't do what end users want in the most straightforward way possible, it will never be what end users use.
- notpushkin 4y ago> Not only is it hard to sign up for Mastodon I genuinely don't understand this point at all. You pick an instance – any instance, provided it's open for new users. Then you fill out 4 fields and confirm your email. That's it, you're now a proud citizen of the Fediverse. Does it get any easier than this? (Not trying to be toxic here or anything, just actually curious.)
- aniforprez 4y agoYes. The part where you don't have to pick an instance > provided it's open for new users This in itself is a massive point of confusion for most users. I've had all my friends and family ask me about this very point and I didn't know what to say. Especially when Elon fired everyone, literally none of the instances on the Mastodon page were accepting anyone. It's much better now but this alone confuses people into thinking they're locked into their instance. Why would my father, a retired mechanical engineer, join an infosec instance? Or my friends join a French instance when none of us are remotely French?
- Matl 4y agoIs email hard because you need to pick up an 'instance'?
- Scarblac 4y agoWell you first got one from your Internet provider, and after that there were a few huge ones (Hotmail and Gmail). I don't think most people feel they "chose" their email at all.
- corv 4y agoThis is probably how the fediverse will turn out too
- wpietri 4y agoIt was! Now we are down to a very small number of default instances for most people. I'm one of the weirdos who doesn't use Gmail (Fastmail ftw), but Google's ad-subsidized email really decimated the competition.
- roge7331 4y agoThe fact that every mastodon enthusiast is publishing tutorials on how to use mastodon speaks for itself. As some in the bubble it may be easy to understand but for the default Twitter user it is not
- Kye 4y agoThis is nothing new. Every new technology has a billion how-to articles. Twitter had the same. It's the bread and butter of the "...For Dummies" and "Complete Idiot's Guides" series of books.
- wildpeaks 4y agoA recurring hurdle I heard is choice paralysis when picking which server to join (e.g. "which one is the Gmail of the Fediverse") ? It's just enough friction to make some users postpone signing up, thinking they'll get around to finish choosing a server later when they have more information, and never finishing.
- jancsika 4y ago> Mastodon isn't for the masses in its current state. It's super easy to sign up for Mastodon. I read a blog from the creator of Mozilla and it seemed pretty straightforward to me. Simply Google it and then click "Create Account." Now choose one of myriad instances without having any idea what it the topic of that instance means for your user experience. If you requested an invite and never received it, or they aren't taking new members, just choose one of the other instances and join there. After you get suspended-- without any explanation whatsoever how you violated the short, vague ToS-- just go ahead and sign up on some other instance and try again. You should be getting good at this now! When your posts start to pick up some traction, watch as your blog gets hammered by a zillion requests at once simply to display a website preview in the posts. Is the load too hot for your personal site? Don't worry-- that's the federation working it's magic![1] > Mastodon isn't for the masses in its current state. Summoning OG FOSS mailing list energy... Which part exactly? Did you file a bug about this? Read the fucking manual? OR That's actually a feature, not a bug. Edit: 1: Also, why aren't you just using Cloudfare? Poor website configurations are hardly Mastodon's problem. In fact this is a feature, not a bug: it will cause enough problems for small website users to force them to just use Cloudfare. So good news, small time users-- Mastodon is for you! You're welcome. Also, fix your websites, small time users.
- btbuildem 4y agoIf you have to read a blog about how to sign up for it, it's not "easy to sign up". Signing up for mastodon is a series of hurdles with some extra steps in between. Conceptually it's pretty far from what people are familiar with. It's a classic trap of tech nerds being way, way off base thinking that others would enjoy jumping through obscure hoops just like they do. Most people really don't. (This is coming from someone who grew up on dialup / bbs / sweaty underground diskette auctions)
- calgarymicro 4y agoThey're pretty clearly being sarcastic; they don't actually think it's "super easy to sign up for Mastodon."
- 4y ago
- fredgrott 4y agogiven the number of reporters and public figures that joined Mastodon in the past 30 days that seems to counter your narrative.
- wpietri 4y agoYeah. I mean I don't know what to do with Mastdon, and I have a few Linux servers in my closet. That's partly because I haven't used it, but more that Mastodon is still in the process of becoming whatever it's going to be now that Twitter is burning down. The story is still incoherent because the reality has not yet cohered.
- JadeNB 4y ago> It's easy to sign up for Twitter, it follows all of your expectations of how apps work. Although it's probably too late, and not the place, to fight this particular battle, this kind of resigned circularity frustrates me. The reason the apps from big companies all "follow your expectations of how apps work" is not that they have reached some Platonic ideal of according with user expectations; it is that they have the time, the money, and the muscle (in the sense of being able to force you to use their apps to use their big product, whether you want to or not) to shape your expectations of how apps work. Their apps work as we expect apps to work because their apps defined how we expect apps to work.
- rconti 4y agoI suppose signing up for Twitter is 1 step easier than Mastodon, because you just go to the one site. But it's actually incredibly hard to use and find value from; I suppose people have forgotten this because the small percentage of the Internet who liked Twitter figured it out 10 years ago and it seems "normal" now. The good news is, that'll make Mastodon fairly easy to use, too, since many conventions are similar, though Mastodon is easier in some ways. I am not a regular user of Mastodon but I already find it somewhat easier. I attempted to derive value from Twitter on and off for, whatever, 10 years, and I still found it incredibly hard to use. I'm not a stupid person; obviously if I had a real reason to get used to it, I would have. Journalists, for example, "had to" use it, because they found it an incredibly easy shortcut to getting opinions from a populace that they assumed reflected a broad cross section of the world, even though it wasn't. Confusing things: * The reply format. If you reply to a tweet, your reply will be below the one you're replying to, which readers have to scroll UP from the beginning to see, even though the browser gives you the impression you're already at the top of the page. And there's a back arrow. But the back arrow takes you home, not to the parent post. And if you quote a tweet in your reply, it ends up below your words, indented out. That's the only indenting ever, and it's the only time your reply is above something, rather than below it. * There are ads and suggested tweets everywhere, cluttering your feed. * You don't know who to follow, or why you should follow people. People you follow might change their name every 5 minutes, so you can't remember who anyone is or was. You're told to follow important people, so during a volcanic explosion in Iceland, you follow an Icelandic volconologist, but the only content you see is stuff they quote-tweet or reply-tweet to with no context that's apparently an inside joke in some other community they're in. * Am I seeing the whole feed? In chronological order, or? * Why the character limitation? And the awfulness of threads and how where/when to reply in one that came as a result of this. * Can't follow a hashtag, utterly inexplicably. About the only use case I found for it, wasn't available. * Limitations on number of characters * Utter toxicity of most of the userbase. * Inability to form smaller communities. Everything is public, just people shouting into the void for attention. And then, of course, the usual cultural things you have to learn from cues over time which I never got comfortable with because I didn't spend enough time there. Where the hashtags go; inline, at the end, at the beginning? The intricacies of when you @ people, when you DM people, etc. The discomfort with finding a voice in a public shouting match.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]