4 ms·
This Carla Rossi seems to have quite the academic position, being the editor in chief of a journal and the director of a research center (https://www.receptio.e
by jeroenhd 4y ago
This Carla Rossi seems to have quite the academic position, being the editor in chief of a journal and the director of a research center (https://www.receptio.eu/ https://www.receptio.eu/).
The blatant plagiarism Rossi has committed here not only casts doubt on her own previous publications, but also on the works by the organisation she's representing. The way her secretary defends the plagiarism she committed reads like someone who's been caught, couldn't think of an excuse, and started denying until they could come up with a better excuse ("blogs don't have scientific value") for Prof Carla Rossi's plagiarism. The sheer nerve to call a blog scientifically meaningless when the author has brazenly put her name on someone else's work!
It's possible that Rossi didn't know about the plagiarism as many publications in academia outsource a large amount of work to others (PhD students, for example) and stick the name of the researcher managing the project on the front. Perhaps the person answering the email was (or knew) the person who plagiarised this blog and is trying to prevent her boss from finding out.
Regardless, I wouldn't trust Prof Carla Rossi, nor her journal "Theory and Criticism of Literature and Arts", nor receptio.eu until this problem has been dealt with. As far as I can tell this blog is an excellent source of information, but if these publications have copied online sources verbatim before, who knows what other, lesser websites have also been copied and restated as scientific fact?
- javajosh 4y agoMy intuition agrees with all you've written. But one possibility remains, and that is that our intuitions are wrong and the OP is purposefully lying to attack a target. The odds of this needs to be reassessed particularly in light of content-generating AI tools. Constructing years worth of plausible blog posts and comments to support your story is rather easy, now. It would be simple to copy the work of a target, insert it into a generated, plausible-looking blog, and claim IP theft. The email assertions are easy to fabricate (interestingly, if the OP can prove the existence of those emails, that would be better proof than the blog!) It's a scary prospect because AI invalidates most of our heuristics about fraud and plagiarism, and therefore our intuitions can't be trusted. (e.g. we can no longer rely on the heuristic "geez, it could be a con but who would bother to put in so much damn work for such a small benefit?" argument.) (It's also interesting that this is basically a fundamental trade-off of higher productivity. I would wager $10k that within the next 2 years startup land will get caught with its hand in the AI sock puppet cookie jar more than once.)
- nicolas_t 4y agoWell in this specific case, internet archive validates that the content was there before the "work" by Carla Rossi. In general, even if AI can produce years worth of plausible blog posts, this doesn't live in a vacuum and sites like archive.org help to date if the content is recent or not.
- feet 4y ago>plagiarism as many publications in academia outsource a large amount of work to others (PhD students, for example) Do you have a source for this claim? PhD students get credit for the work that they perform, their names are on the papers so I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that they aren't getting credit or that this is somehow plagiarism
- jeroenhd 4y agoThey certainly do get credit, and working together is not even close to plagiarism. However, I've read plenty of papers where the "author" put front and center in news articles and the like was no more than the person managing and editorialising a group of PhD students which did the actual leg work. Everyone gets credited in some way but there is no way to know for sure that the author listed most prominently has personally read and verified all the sources. An overworked or overconfident PhD student could have plagiarised an article or log post, pretended it was their own work to hit the deadline and still get co-authorship on the publication, and convince the "author" that the magnificent work was all their own, "infecting" their coauthors without their knowledge. This is very easy if you have a good standing within your group and make no suggestion that you need to resort to plagiarism. Needing access to physical resources like rare books makes it even easier to hide your lies because validating such work takes a lot of effort. During several plagiarism cases that have hit the national news here researchers had coauthored papers with convincing liars, expanding upon earlier work or taking a made up data set and applying real, proper methodology to it. Often the coauthors had to find out through the papers that their publications were at risk of retraction when a liar had been found out. I don't believe researchers are on the habit of checking every single line of text their coauthor writes for matches online because not plagiarising is the norm.