3 ms·
>it more importantly embodies the way that the Internet worked before capitalism showed up. Does it really? I miss the internet of the late 90s and early 2000s
by Dalewyn 4y ago
>it more importantly embodies the way that the Internet worked before capitalism showed up.
Does it really? I miss the internet of the late 90s and early 2000s, but Mastadon feels like precisely none of that.
- ergonaught 4y agoFor me, "Mastodon" more closely resembles the BBS-with-Fidonet experience, which I suppose might be similar to UUCP/Usenet to a degree "before capitalism".
- Brian_K_White 4y agoThank you. I never had a Twitter account and so never migrated from Twitter to Mastodon, and hadn't checked it out otherwise either. But this comment is the first thing I've heard that makes me think I might love it. I loved the message subs on bbs networks. The fact that an ordinary user/commenter conveyed that useful essential impression that all those journalists never did in the years since it's been newsworthy, would seem to fit right in with the article's point. This article itself also finally presented some useful "what is the point? why might I want this?" points too about no algorithm manipulation. Mostly all I've seen are vague stuff that it's not Twitter and that it's federated kind of like email. But that really doesn't say anything useful. If it's like email, we already have email. How is email an alternative to Twitter and Facebook? They really have failed to write effectively about it.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIt feels kludgy and slow and unreliable to get what you want. That’s kind of like my 90s web experience.
- rsynnott 4y agoOn ‘slow’, this is very instance dependent; perhaps try another. My original one was pretty painful, but my current one is fast, certainly faster than Twitter of late.
- Waterluvian 4y agoYou’re right. But that’s a non-start for the majority of potential users. Recommending it to family and friends feels like I’m recommending Ubuntu. I really want it to succeed but the current landscape isn’t going to cut it.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoto be fair most of my family and friends without tech jobs didn’t really get twitter either
- kalleboo 4y agoA lot of people have forgotten just how long it took for Twitter to get the mainstream appeal it has, and for a long time just how confusing all @, # and RT stuff was, and how hard it was for people to find good people to follow etc. Twitter has been working hard on that for many years with all the onboard and the algorithmic stuff.
- birdyrooster 4y agoThe internet but with only privileged people, is it still the internet?
- wkat4242 4y agoIt's the "let's do this together" attitude. Whatever than the "how can we get rich quick" one that powers most of the internet now
- mepian 4y agoBy the late 90s capitalism was already there, even Microsoft was already dominating.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoThe dot com bubble was the very definition of capitalism. It's the MBAs (that HN hates) that turn "the internet" into a product that makes money- or that they can convince investors will make money some day.
- jtode 4y agoIt does really, and that's why it doesn't work as well in this current environment. Mastadon is a DIY app/platform, which constitutes one of any number of implementations of ActivityPub, which is the underlying protocol, and can speak to any of the other implementations without limitation, save those imposed by the protocol and self-imposed by the two implementations currently speaking to each other. There are multiple types of SMTP/POP/IMAP servers out there, but they all implement the same protocols, which means that my email client can reach your email client no matter what our clients, or the servers we connect to, look like. This is how the internet works; platforms will always be a limited subset of this fundamental reality. It's also how ActivityPub works, you can wrap whatever user interface you want around it, Mastadon or otherwise, but the protocol, not the platform, defines what is and is not an ActivityPub packet. Platforms, FB, Twitter, Tiktok, Insta, none of these work this way, they are closed platforms that you enter through secure gates and must play according to their rules, and they will always decide who gets amplification and who does not based on what makes them money, and good luck taking anything back out to the open internet with you, even if it's 100% your work. If you put it there, don't expect to get it back easily, and forget about control. It is a fundamentally hostile user relationship that cannot be improved without removing the profit motive. There have been other recent posts on HN about User Hostile software design. It's a thing and it's a bad thing. Mastadon is... tofu dogs. Mastadon is an attempt to feed healthy, protocol-based internet food to people who have been subsisting on bad, algorithmically-manipulated corporate internet food (the aforementioned user-hostile platforms) in a way that feels familiar to them while they get used to the idea of not consuming the internet equivalent of Twinkies and Pork Rinds and Liquor for the rest of their lives. It doesn't taste as good as Twitter, sure. Maybe that's not the most important thing.
- LarryMullins 4y ago> Mastadon is... tofu dogs. Mastadon is an attempt to feed healthy, protocol-based internet food to people who have been subsisting on bad, algorithmically-manipulated corporate internet food (the aforementioned user-hostile platforms) in a way that feels familiar to them while they get used to the idea of not consuming the internet equivalent of Twinkies and Pork Rinds and Liquor for the rest of their lives. Mastadon is hand-rolling cigarettes instead of buying them at the gas station. Brewing gin in your bathtub, instead of going to a liquor store.