3 ms·
ZF(C) was not a failure as a proof-of-concept, and before formalizations could be verified by machinery that was all that a formalization could be useful for!
by zozbot234 4y ago
ZF(C) was not a failure as a proof-of-concept, and before formalizations could be verified by machinery that was all that a formalization could be useful for! This was just as true of Russell and Whitehead's Principia, of course. Category theory was not originally intended as a foundation, either.
- zmgsabst 4y agoI agree that ZFC was an important and useful step in mathematics — but it fell short of its aims in both ways: - you can’t provide a solid basis for all math (though, ZFC is useful to prove that) - you can’t use it to produce papers of increased assurance, eg to remove the issues that had arisen with contrary calculus proofs Category theory was intended to solve a shortcoming of ZFC: the lack of tools to reason about “large” similarity and classes — such as algebra and geometry being the same topic. Category theory formalized those notions.