5 ms·
TikTok admits to spying on U.S. users as effort to ban the app heats up
- ksniwmidjd 4y agoWe recently learned that Twitter was receiving money from the FBI that enabled the US government to censor users and suppress certain hashtags, etc. But TikTok is seemingly the only one the media is trying to push to get banned. Seems strange. Wish we had an honest media.
- dpkirchner 4y agoThe way that Twitter/FBI relationship has been portrayed by certain people has been dangerously misleading -- don't fall for it. Twitter was compensated for assisting with investigations (e.g. collecting information), which is entirely normal, and has nothing to do with censorship. Don't be a sucker, the people pushing this conspiracy theory are depending on us to not investigate the matter for ourselves and to instead get angry.
- polartx 4y agoIts no conspiracy that the FBI acted to try and delegitimize the Hunter Biden laptop story by warning tech companies (Twitter, Facebook, etc) about a ‘Russian disinformation campaign’. This, of course, was entirely false and no one knew that better than the FBI, as it was the laptop repair shop owner who (legally) possessed the laptop who had directly contacted the FBI first.
- lazyeye 4y agoAnd the FBI 100% knew the laptop was genuine. They publicly lied to support an election outcome. Not only is this not remotely a conspiracy theory, its something that needs to be taken incredibly seriously.
- jscipione 4y ago[flagged]
- browserman 4y agonah its a big fat nothing-burger cooked up by a giant rich baby and a couple of right-wing polemecists
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The FBI has destroyed the Constitution and ended the legitimate authority of the US Government with their blatant and flagrant censorship and election interference. No, it hasn’t, and that's just the latest in a series of desperate attempts by a political faction to justify their efforts to destroy the Constitution, in support of their man-baby leader's extended hissy fit over the American people deciding not to retain him as leader.
- hulitu 4y ago> Twitter was compensated for assisting with investigations (e.g. collecting information), which is entirely normal, and has nothing to do with censorship. Collecting information about random people _is not_ entirely normal. Now, if you live in a totalitarian state, it might be.
- uberman 4y agoReally? Are you suggesting that you would be surprised to find that companies are collecting information about you?
- bsder 4y agoWe can need to ban TikTok due to Chinese influence AND can need to fix the fact that the FBI was doing shitty things with Twitter at the same time. You are not arguing in good faith by framing that as either/or. The difference between the two problems is quite stark. The ONLY effective hammer that the US has against TikTok is a ban. Against Twitter, there are a range of options that various municipalities, states, etc. can bring to bear.
- Ancalagon 4y agoNice, add some fuel to this fire, let it burn.
- rnd0 4y agoWell, color me shocked. I think this is something that's widely known (edit or heavily suspected), but the people who use TikTok as a rule don't care.
- polartx 4y agoReminds me of when congressman Josh Hawley needled the COO of TikTok for 10 straight minutes trying to get a direct answer as to whether any TikTok employees with access to US user data were affiliated with the Chinese communist party. That was 3 months ago. https://youtu.be/meWM8d4Uz7Q https://youtu.be/meWM8d4Uz7Q
- powerapple 4y agoIf you are talking about Chinese Communist Party, you are basically talking about everyone in China. It is like 1/10 Chinese people.
- asianbro234 4y ago[flagged]
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhat parts of the article make it propaganda? It struck me as balanced since it minimized the harm in this case yet raised the alarm about inconsistencies between what company said was happening and what this instance proves does happen.
- Ancalagon 4y agoI fail to see how this is propaganda…
- josephcsible 4y agoFrom the guidelines: > Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, bots, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data.
- thefounder 4y agoTiktok has been used by the Chinese gov just like the U.S gov has been using its own internet companies(i.e apple, microsoft, google, meta etc). We already know from Snowden. I really dont understand why people act surprised. If any national or supranational gov(i.e E.U) cares about privacy and security of its citizens it should ban data transfer and data access outside its jurisdiction(i.e require totally separate entity located in each country/jurisdiction). This would be better for taxes and local jobs too.
- powerapple 4y agoI assume there are spies working in all different companies, governments don't even need to officially tap into those companies. What the private companies can do is to strength their security, and make sure it cannot happen easily.
- foreverCarlos 4y agoEvery time something like this is posted, the thread is littered with a dozen comments about how this should surprise no one, "water is wet", etc. News does not mean that journalists or the readers are shocked or even surprised. It's a new (or updated) piece of information. So yes, it's OK to have a discussion about it without the snarky comments. How would your proposed solution solve the problem you outline in the first sentence? If the US bans data transfer outside of its jurisdiction then Apple, Microsoft, etc will stop cooperating with secret government data collection programs?
- cromka 4y agoNot to mention that such limitations accelerate the fragmentation of the Internet
- thefounder 4y agoYou end-up with fragmentation of corporations not fragmentation of the internet. If Google sets a self governed license based entity in Europe with staff from Europe(executives including the CEO etc) then you have two separate entities playing by different rules(EU based or U.S based) linked just through a licensing deal. Think of it like Microsoft sells On-premise Azure instalations to governments. The EU and US entities would share no internal data b/c they would be two different companies that use the same software for different clients.