4 ms·
Looks more like a brand problem. Especially Chevy. Different battery technology?
by Animats 4y ago
Looks more like a brand problem. Especially Chevy. Different battery technology?
- linsomniac 4y agoI think it's largely a battery management system problem, may also be pack quality. I've always felt like part of Tesla's lead in EVs has allowed them to develop some "special sauce" in the form of battery management. Other manufacturers that have just started may be playing significant catch-up to Tesla's lead.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoGM (Chevy) actually excellently engineered packs for cold weather. But what you might be seeing here is in fact the result of their attention to battery longevity. The packs in the Volt & Bolt have a lot of systems set up to maintain temperatures optimal for battery lifespan (in both cold and hot weather); one of the things that distinguishes them from the lackadaisical engineering in e.g. a Nissan Leaf. Lessened range may have more to do with the system spending energy to keep the battery at optimal temperature. Contrary to what others are saying here, Tesla had no "head start" or lead. The Volt came out the same year as the Model S (2011/2012) and the battery pack in there (LGChem + GM) is extremely well engineered. (In general GM is far more cautious about many aspects of battery life than others. One of the reasons the Bolt has weaker/slower fast charging. They also have tended to focus on a lower segment of the market than others, too. Comparing a luxury vehicle Tesla against a Chevy Bolt is not exactly apples to apples)
- neon_electro 4y agoAnd because of this cautious design, shouldn't used car consumers be able to better trust used Volts and Bolt E(U)Vs to have withstood their mileage and calendar years with hopefully less degradation?
- evanelias 4y agoIf I understand correctly, it's the lack of a heat pump.
- tpoindex 4y agoSeems that the underlying study that included the Bolt was from Feb. 2019 (the AAA study cited), so their battery recall/fix and newer software may have helped. Another couple of red flag in the AXIOS article was: "AAA found the loss in driving range could be as high as 41% with the heater on full blast." Hmmm, even with the recent Siberean cold air mass blast here in Colorado, I don't need the heater on full in my ICE cars with outside temps of -5F. Also, the recurrent.com study show some of the vehicles ratings based on verified range versus estimated range - why? Perhaps it's accurate, but mixed methodologies in the same study.