3 ms·
This seems similar to Renaissance Technologies, especially regarding the regression part. Funny how so many people are skeptical, as if they they want to be c
by paulpauper 4y ago
This seems similar to Renaissance Technologies, especially regarding the regression part.
Funny how so many people are skeptical, as if they they want to be convinced that it's not possible. The fact Renaissance Technologies has been so successful for so long shows it can be done. Easy? no, but possible, yes.
- evo 4y agoEven the Medallion Fund only averages 20-40% gains a year and they've stacked the deck with every possible advantage of resources and the most brilliant folks they can find. If the risk management on this is geared to the point where it's seeing 300% account volatility in a month, even in a positive direction, it's easier assign higher likelihood to "this algo is levered far higher than it ought to be and while you've dodged landmines this month, you won't in the long run," vs. "your 'minimum viable stat arb' and competent implementation outperforms the best-of-the-best outlier." I think skepticism is warranted as most people at this point end up blowing up, but hey, I guess there's some slim possibility that it's the latter?
- gruez 4y ago>Even the Medallion Fund only averages 20-40% gains a year and they've stacked the deck with every possible advantage of resources and the most brilliant folks they can find. The Medallion Fund is also larger than a single quant's trading portfolio. This is important because a given trading strategy loses its effectiveness (in percentage terms) when scaled up. A strategy that yields 100% return on a 10k investment is unlikely to return 100% on a $10M investment, for instance.
- pid-1 4y agoRenaissance is a complete outlier. Most hedge funds - including firms that sell themselves as quants - just lose tons of money. I've been in this industry for a while and folks making high returns solo either: 1) Got lucky for a very short amount of time, then their strategy stopped working. On avg those folks net lose money trying to make "the thing" work again. 2) Were running a super risky levareged strategy and went bust eventually
- antonvs 4y ago> Most hedge funds... What about prop funds, which are trading for their own account? Seems like those wouldn’t keep it up very long if they were losing tons of money.
- MikeDelta 4y agoWe often forget that there are quite a few prop shops out there with just a few people, making a living for many years. Not sure where to find a link to the statistics, but you hear it when talking to the community.
- sidlls 4y agoRT is going to be a fantastic case study when their scheme unravels. The likelihood of the outcomes RT has enjoyed occurring without committing some kind of fraud or employing other illegal practices is basically (not exactly) zero. At this point it's more a question of whether their skill in hiding the shenanigans can continue to outpace discovery of them at a level of visibility that forces action by the authorities.
- cavisne 4y agoAgreed. I did originally buy into the explanation that they collected/digitized stock data that is no longer available. But really it’s more likely to be some sort of fraud.
- joshuamorton 4y agoIt has partway, they've paid something like 7 billion in tax penalties for medallion, which wipes out a lot of the gains from the past few years.
- alberth 4y agoPeople once thought Bernie Madoffs fund were unbelievable.
- mhh__ 4y agoRentech also mainly (only?) manage their own employees/partners money, so it'd be an interesting scam.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]