6 ms·
The Receptionist Test (The Interview before the Interview)
- mvid 18y agodoes anyone use floppies anymore?
- eru 18y agoReceptionists do. ;)
- RavingGoat 18y agoI think the usage of floppy disks is a clear warning sign of a place you don't want to work.
- fallentimes 18y agoGreat idea. I read about this one firm that would occasionally spill drinks on candidates to gage their character. Also, I'm glad they didn't call this the "administrative assistant test".
- DaniFong 18y agoMy cofounder once was interviewing someone. An earthquake struck in the midst of it. The candidate froze, bolted out the door, drove off, and was never heard from again. My cofounder now says that he wish there were an earthquake for every interview...
- edw519 18y ago"High tech" version of Henry Ford's old test. He wouldn't hire anyone who put salt on his food before tasting it.
- hugh 18y agoOr wore a yarmaluke. Seriously though, Ford's test sounds silly. I'm sure he had some kind of justification for it, but I doubt it really did a good job of screening out who would and wouldn't be a good employee.
- gills 18y agoDogma vs. Data! Do you want to hire someone that does things 'because that's what they always do', or because they collected data and acted appropriately? I'm not saying salt is a good indicator - there are a million other ways you could test it - but I think that's the gist of it.
- jumper 18y agoThe "salt test" is a popular and older than I am story\method, but why the name drop of Henry Ford? So far as I can tell, the evidence tying it to him is non-existent, just like all the other people\groups you hear it tied to. Regardless, why not let the method stand on it's own, and give up on the name dropping? Bah, rumors...
- baltoo 18y agoFirst time I've heard of it. Where I come from it's the other way around. Salting before tasting just means you generally like more salt than most and the host couldn't have predicted that. Salting afterwards is a (faux pas) critique.
- cadalac 18y agoI think you could easily ask a few indirect IQ questions to see if the guy is suitable for the job.
- mileszs 18y agoSounds like theoretical versus practical. In fact, the point of the story was that many candidates could easily handle all interview questions, IQ-centric or otherwise. This is a practical exam, of sorts. It will prove someone is unworthy of the position (but will not necessarily prove someone _is_ worthy of the position). It's a weed-out class.
- mdasen 18y agoWhy does it seem like computer jobs require such a higher standard of competence than other jobs? I've been on interviews for both computer and non-computer jobs and most of the time, non-computer job interviews really don't give the employer much to go on. Computer jobs always have questions about algorithms, data structures, and shooting the breeze about some technologies. Is it that there are lots of people who lie and say they're computer people when they aren't (compared to the rates in other occupations)? Is it because you can't fake computers like you can fake other jobs? Is it because computer people are used to being mistreated and undervalued in a way that is unacceptable for other people? I'm really curious if anyone has thoughts on this.
- gills 18y agoIt's because, like the sea, the computer is a wholly unforgiving bitch.
- GrandMasterBirt 18y agoThat's why I love computers. As for the sea, people were just not made to be sea-faring. We just came up with really cool ways to get around this limitation... Stupid requirement of having to do things like breath air.
- lacker 18y agoPeople weren't made to be computer programmers either ;-) Imagine seeing a bit of bad syntax and suffering involuntary convulsions....
- GrandMasterBirt 18y agoThis methodology is so simple that it is brilliant. My favorite one was the file extension problem... of course ubuntu would solve everything. No file, no problem! I am surprised he didn't tell the receptionist to roll on the floor saying hail linux while he did a witchdoctor dance. Now only if my office had a receptionist so we can do this. As to why computer jobs require competence, it is because any engineering position (computer, or otherwise) requires competence. Would you live in a building without knowing that it won't collapse tomorrow because the construction company didn't know how to calculate the required strength of the steel beams needed to support the structure? A company won't go under because a secretary does not know how to make perfectly formatted word files from the get-go. Where as it will fail if a software company's key product is managed/coded by incompetence.
- justindz 18y agoI have a lifetime bid for a fraternity (I didn't join, probably won't) as a result of a legitimate receptionist test. I was hanging out waiting for a friend and some senior member started cursing at his laptop. He had apparently lost an essay and I was able to rescue the contents, safely transfer it to disk, help him back it up just in case and give him advice on avoiding the problem in the future. Won me some points.
- bestes 18y agoIt is a clever test, albeit a bit deceptive.
- Chocobean 18y agoAm I the only one who is offended (but slightly amused) by this test? I would never work for a place that would play games like this. Are they also going to send undercover employees to talk to you about the company over lunch break as your annual review? What's wrong with presenting the problem in a straightforward manner and see if the applicant can debug the steps, telling the interviewer what he's trying and why at each step? For starters you'd get way more out of his think flow. For "authenticity" you can add that this was a real problem that Cindy faced the other day and you may ask her questions. People tend to try what they know first (ie: pounding ctrl-p or ubuntu), and if it happened to be the issue, they were merely lucky and may not be competent at all either. How hard is it to ask them "What else haven't you tried? What would you have tried next if this didn't fix it? Why did you try those steps in that order?"
- Dilpil 18y agoPerhaps, but this does have the benefit of not making the interviewees feel pressured.
- hbien 18y agoI worked at my college unjamming printers for two years. The interview was pretty relaxed, they just made sure I could use Windows, Mac, and Linux (our school used all three).
- nazgulnarsil 18y agostories like this piss me off when I'm unemployed.
- yters 18y agoAnd I always thought The Office was an exaggeration: http://thedailywtf.com/Articles/Anything-You-Can-Do-Lyle-Can-Do-Better.aspx http://thedailywtf.com/Articles/Anything-You-Can-Do-Lyle-Can...
- jyothi 18y agoLooking at the comments seems like I am an exception. But I really appreciate these tests especially if u are hiring at start-ups. One got to be hands on and ready to fix anything and everything. The biggest test is that of go-getter and not be finicky about the kind of work you do.