3 ms·
Automation can make many flights safer, but this assumes two critical things: 1. The automation is designed and implemented in a reliable, known, safe way. 2.
by Dalewyn 4y ago
Automation can make many flights safer, but this assumes two critical things:
1. The automation is designed and implemented in a reliable, known, safe way.
2. The pilot are competent at flying the aircraft completely manually if necessary.
If either of those two assumptions are violated, the flight is not safe.
Automation cannot replace incompetent pilots, no matter how good. Pilots can't overcome bad automation if it is not designed and implemented properly (eg: MCAS), no matter how competent.
- vkou 4y agoYou're missing a necessary assumption #3 - 'The pilot needs to be competent at correctly identifying and safely flying the aircraft in any mixture of automation and manual control.' This accident was caused by a violation of #3. I've no doubt that the pilots in question were completely capable of performing these maneuvers manually - they failed at identifying which particular mixture of automation and manual control they were in, and in taking the correct steps during them.