4 ms·
I see a lot of people mentioning bitwarden around here; is their actually a technical reason to believe they are better than Lastpass or any of their competitio
by bee_rider 4y ago
I see a lot of people mentioning bitwarden around here; is their actually a technical reason to believe they are better than Lastpass or any of their competition (have they like open sourced all their stuff?).
There’s very little room for failure and learning in the online password safe field, so I generally assume these companies are in one of two states:
* has unknown bugs waiting to be revealed
* out of business
- eternityforest 4y agoBitWarden is open source with some freemium features. It's what I use at the moment. I believe it has third party network audits. As far as I know it's fully E2E encrypted, and has never had a data breach. The only thing I don't like is the lack of SMS based 2FA, although I appreciate their commitment to maximum security by not allowing it .
- hoistbypetard 4y ago> is their actually a technical reason to believe they are better than Lastpass or any of their competition (have they like open sourced all their stuff?). You can see their server and client code here: https://github.com/bitwarden https://github.com/bitwarden I choose to use their clients unmodified, along with an instance of the server formerly known as "bitwarden_rs" running in my basement as the sync backend. https://github.com/dani-garcia/vaultwarden https://github.com/dani-garcia/vaultwarden I still pay them annually for their "freemium" features even though I prefer not to let them host my data.
- fruit2020 4y agoDo you expose your server to the internet or is it ok to sync devices only when you’re at home? Is every device a replica, if you lose your server can you redeploy it from the data on your device?
- diarrhea 4y agoNot the parent, but I have been hosting a Vaultwarden instance on the public internet for about two years now. After learning about certificate transparency logs, I moved the app from a raw subdomain behind a secret URL path. Think “hello.domain.com/correcthorsebatterystaple”. Is it security by obscurity? You bet. Does it work? Yes. I regularly evaluate the JSON logs emitted by Caddy in a pandas script and so far, no foreign party has even hit that endpoint. It’s like an extra username of sorts you’d have to know. I’ve always been unsure of where to draw the line when it comes to obscurity. People online are viciously against it, but isn’t a password also just obscurity, if you squint your eyes real good? It’s all secrets users would need to know. All that being said, I’m thinking of hosting it at-home-only as well. Would be a huge win in security and barely any loss in convenience.
- ratorx 4y agoI’d say the things hitting your endpoint are going to be entirely automated scanners that are looking for unauthenticated resources or low hanging common passwords. If you have even a moderately strong password, it’s just noise. I’d be wary about drawing any significant conclusions from logs, because the sophistication of attackers you’ve excluded are quite low. I’d say defense-in-depth is more about nesting strong cryptographic primitives, than simply adding layers. What you’re trading off for is complexity and convenience vs security. In the URL case, a password is more secure (and treated as such) and lots of care is usually taken to make sure the hashing scheme is timing resistant etc. I don’t know if Caddy makes equivalent guarantees, but I’d be very surprised if path matching was not just a string match/regex/trie. In terms of time to crack, just prepending these characters to the password would give you more protection, because that then has to go through a resource intensive hashing process. An example of defense-in-depth would be to host at home only. Here, it’s because you’re nesting actual isolation (which is a good security primitive by itself), with a strong password. This gives you protection even if your threat model is “caddy is borked and is letting anyone do anything”. Now in reality, you can do just about anything and it’ll work (because in the grand scheme, you’re probably not a high value enough target for any high cost attacks). If you secretly happen to be, then you can afford an actual security audit, rather than relying on random info from HN :)
- hoistbypetard 4y agoI currently have my server at home connected via wireguard to a VPS. On that VPS, I run Caddy and have it reverse proxy back to my server over wireguard. If I were building it out today I might just use tailscale and be done with it. I'm not sure about whether every device is a replica of the server. I believe that's the case (given how they behave when the server is offline) but that doesn't figure into my recovery plan.
- pch00 4y ago> You can see their server and client code here: https://github.com/bitwarden https://github.com/bitwarden But in the case of the mobile apps, downloaded from their respective platform's app store, how can you guarantee the code you see on github is the exact same code you're running on your device? Admittedly this supply-chain-verification is an issue for all mobile app store apps but seems particularly important with something like a password manager.
- ionspin 4y agoIn a perfect scenario you would be able to use a reproducible build [0], for Android you can actually get Bitwarden from F-Droid [1] which uses those reproducible builds. For Google play store, there was also that developers needed to sign their apps before releasing to stores, so you knew that it came from developer, but Google removed that when they introduced app bundles. There is still a way to verify if the build is the same as developer provided, but automatic protections that were there are now gone [2] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproducible_builds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproducible_builds [1] https://mobileapp.bitwarden.com/fdroid/ https://mobileapp.bitwarden.com/fdroid/ [2] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/07/google-play-dumps-apks-for-the-more-google-controlled-android-app-bundle/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/07/google-play-dumps-ap...
- mook 4y agoLooking at that, it doesn't seem like you can actually get Bitwarden from F-Droid? That looks like instructions to set up a third-party repository (hosted by Bitwarden)? The page didn't mention anything about reproducible builds. (Doesn't mean they aren't using it though, but that would be internal.)
- ionspin 4y agoYou are completely right, this is hosted by Bitwarden so in the end you would be better of building from source yourself.
- hoistbypetard 4y ago