4 ms·
> Look how quickly Shorts copied TikTok. And how's that going? I don't have any interest in either of them, but as an outsider it certainly seems like a tonne
by OJFord 4y ago
> Look how quickly Shorts copied TikTok.
And how's that going?
I don't have any interest in either of them, but as an outsider it certainly seems like a tonne of people like TikTok and nobody cares about Shorts, wishes they were normal YouTube videos.
And why do you assume 'AI chat' has to be a subscriber model, but 'search' works with ads?
It could easily have a 'recommended sponsor' as an example for certain queries. Or really trivially - just intersperse responses with ads... Exactly like search? And the data collection that's possible is superior too, surely?
- PartiallyTyped 4y ago> and nobody cares about Shorts Not creators though. Shorts give more revenue to the creators than TikTok equivalent. Personally, I prefer shorts, simply because I don't have to download yet another app. Don't get me wrong. I am not searching for them, but if something interesting shows up, I will watch it.
- OJFord 4y agoBut the thread's about Google, so if nobody cares except the creators because they get laid more by Google, that's even worse (for Google prospect). I also watch them for anyone I follow anyway, but the short & portrait format is annoying.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoI was making the claim that creators being more interested in shorts due to the higher return would actually be good for Google. I do agree on the criticism of the format, plus the fact that I can't seem to scroll and the repetition are annoying to say the least.
- tpl 4y agoRight now YouTube is pushing Shorts pretty heavily. Everything I have heard from creators is that Shorts can drive a ton of subscriptions into your channel. How many of those viewers watch the long form stuff is a bit more a mystery though.