4 ms·
His biographer says that Allen & Unwin (his publishers) asked for "a new Hobbit book". The earliest drafts are about a second adventure for Bilbo -- he had run
by jfengel 4y ago
His biographer says that Allen & Unwin (his publishers) asked for "a new Hobbit book". The earliest drafts are about a second adventure for Bilbo -- he had run out of money and needed a new treasure fetch-quest.
You can read the early drafts in book 6 of the History of Middle-earth, and watch as "the tale grew in the telling". They start with Bilbo, then the protagonist changes name and identity as the concept fills out. He made it as far as Bree in a very Hobbit-esque style before scrapping it all and rewriting it in the more adult LotR style.
(He later tried to re-write The Hobbit in that LotR style, but it was dreadfully boring and he gave up after a few chapters.)
- wolverine876 4y ago> His biographer says that Allen & Unwin (his publishers) asked for "a new Hobbit book". I wonder what the publisher's thoughts were about Tolkien's response: 'How about a six book, three volume epic, not suitable for much of the same audience (children), in essentially a new genre, with almost all new characters?'
- Someone1234 4y agoMuch like movies today, if the sequel comes out long enough after the original, and you want to target the SAME people, you go from children/YA to adult. For example there was a 17-year gap between The Hobbit and LOTR's first two books.
- wolverine876 4y agoGreat point. Interestingly, JK Rowling didn't do that.
- jfengel 4y agoShe did try. She just didn't handle it very well.