3 ms·
> This is why I get frustrated with people who say we should influence businesses with our wallet, by choosing not to shop at stores who behave badly. The reas
by godelski 4y ago
> This is why I get frustrated with people who say we should influence businesses with our wallet, by choosing not to shop at stores who behave badly.
The reason I get upset with this is because the world is so complicated that it is really difficult to determine if something is ethical or not. Or rather, which options are the most ethical (the world is so complex that nothing is completely ethical, so I think we should make an analogy to harm reduction. There will almost always be harm and if we seek zero harm through purity testing, we give advantage to those that do the most harm). While I agree that we should vote with our wallets to put pressure on the market, it is clearly not enough. It never will be enough because we can't peer behind the curtain and no one really knows how to make a pencil[0]. If no one knows how to make a pencil, then it follows that no one knows if pencil making is ethical to begin with, let alone pencil usage. I think what we must do instead is be willing to have these complex and nuanced conversations without religious vigor and instead make sure our passion to advocate for or against a system is proportionate to the time we are willing to put in to learning about the complexities of said system.
[0] https://fee.org/resources/i-pencil/ https://fee.org/resources/i-pencil/