3 ms·
This corroborates my experience. Reading Society of Mind in undergrad is one of the things that led me to doubt AI progress and to stray away from the field [1
by echelon 4y ago
This corroborates my experience.
Reading Society of Mind in undergrad is one of the things that led me to doubt AI progress and to stray away from the field [1]. It was handwavy, conceptual, and far removed from the research and progess at the time. If you held it up to Norvig's undergraduate level Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach, you could sense Minsky's book was as wishfully hypothetical as Kaku's pop-sci books on string theory.
[1] Recent progress has led me right back. There's no more exciting place to be right now than AI.
- briga 4y agoEven if it didn’t lead to empirical results I think most of the value of the book today is in the questions Minsky asked. How is intelligence organized in a distributed system like a neural net? ChatGPT may be able to do amazing things, but the mechanisms it uses are still very opaque. So even if the theory may not be “useful”, it is still worth pursuing IMO It’s also pretty well written and written by someone who clearly spent a lot of mental energy on the problem