3 ms·
His version of orc, elf, and dwarves are close enough to earlier versions it’s hard to say how much he changed vs these versions simply fitting a modern aesthet
by Retric 4y ago
His version of orc, elf, and dwarves are close enough to earlier versions it’s hard to say how much he changed vs these versions simply fitting a modern aesthetic.
Earlier dwarves vs Tolkien dwarves vs more modern examples don’t seem that different. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwarf_(folklore)#Norse_mythology_and_later_folklore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwarf_(folklore)#Norse_mytholo...
Elves are easier to argue but Santa workshop elves, Harry Potter elves, D&D elves, etc are all quite different.
- bombcar 4y agoOne thing Tolkien never had was pointy ear elves - that crept in somehow and now it’s everywhere.
- Retric 4y agoLarge and sometimes pointy elf ears where a thing before he was born, but I don’t know where pointy thing really took off. I suspect it was mostly a way to draw larger ears without it being as comical. 1870: https://freevintageillustrations.com/enter-an-elf-in-search-of-a-fairy/ https://freevintageillustrations.com/enter-an-elf-in-search-... He did say in a letter that Hobbits had pointy ears seemingly a nod to existing tradition, while elves had leaf shaped ears whatever that meant.
- bombcar 4y agoHe also said Gandalf’s eyebrows stuck out past his broad rimmed hat so sometimes his descriptions are a bit poetical.
- zabzonk 4y agoSpock