3 ms·
If Uber is taking 28% according to its very large dataset and Lyft is taking 48% according to a single driver in a single region for a small amount of time, the
by Waterluvian 4y ago
If Uber is taking 28% according to its very large dataset and Lyft is taking 48% according to a single driver in a single region for a small amount of time, then I suspect the most likely explanation is the data is deficient.
I suspect this because I can’t see how Lyft could ever be competitive in the market if it is taking a far larger chunk: either they’re drastically underpaying drivers or overcharging customers compared to Uber. Why would either group endure that?
- atdrummond 4y agoThis kind of presumes that Lyft and Uber have completely similar markets and user overlap. I know of many Midwest communities, for example, where Lyft is the only option.
- Waterluvian 4y agoDoesn’t that support the argument that a single driver in one region for 48 hours of driving cannot possibly be representative?
- atdrummond 4y agoI don’t disagree with that claim either.
- notahacker 4y agoDoesn't seem unreasonable to believe that 28% across all markets including ones where Uber is subsidising their rides to try to crush the competition or make up for driver shortages translates to something more like 48% take from a typical driver in many established markets where they don't have much competition (from apps or surviving taxi firms) or shortages of drivers of regular vehicles during daylight hours...
- dylan604 4y agoIs Uber still subsidizing the cost of the ride with VC money? In my area, Lyft if regularly more expensive than Uber. This is based on other people telling me the prices for Uber as I do not have an account. I was recently given a $100+ fare for a ride that is normally ~$20. I kept checking back through out the day, and the lowest I saw was ~$50. The person I was trying to visit showed me the same route with Uber was ~$30. All of this to say from a single perspective that it does appear that Lyft is charging more. It also suggests why I so infrequently use Lyft because I'm not paying $100 to go <20 miles. So maybe I'm not enduring it like you say. There are times where I definitely choose to not go somewhere based on price alone.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Uber still subsidizing the cost of the ride with VC money? By definition, no, they are a public company.
- edgyquant 4y agoUber definitely subsidizes each ride with investor money. They still lose dollars per ride
- schrodinger 4y agoPotential theory: riders get kicked off of Uber for poor reviews and are forced to accept Lyft's 2nd tier pay?
- Waterluvian 4y agoImagine the potential nastiness of both sharing or selling ban lists to each other. Surely that would attract the fury of regulators.
- UncleEntity 4y ago> Why would either group endure that? Because they destroyed the cab industry and hunger is a powerful motivator? You have one group of people who want to go somewhere and another group who own a vehicle and need money for whatever reason, match made in heaven—assuming you ignore the fact that most of the cost of the ride is basically coming out of the equity of the vehicle.