3 ms·
Just as a counterpoint: I've been really enjoying goodnotes on the ipad lately. GoodNotes is a notetaking app which is not an infinitely zoomable canvas. And I
by josephg 4y ago
Just as a counterpoint: I've been really enjoying goodnotes on the ipad lately. GoodNotes is a notetaking app which is not an infinitely zoomable canvas. And I love it. (I'm not affiliated in any way, I'm just a huge fan).
Goodnotes documents are essentially paper notepads that you can write in. New pages are added to the document as you need them (usually by swiping right from the last page).
I've tried a couple infinitely zoomable canvases but I tend to make a bit of a dog's breakfast when I use them:
- Everything ends up in a seemingly random place in the document, and at different zoom levels. I personally find I tend to gradually zoom out while I write in infinite canvas apps. After awhile it gets increasingly difficult to find things I've written earlier because old things get small.
- There's no natural sense of "before" or "after" on an infinite canvas. This is kind of the point, but it makes me work harder to keep items arranged in space or tell a story after you've taken a bunch of notes. If you don't, then you've got to go hunting for things.
Goodnotes doesn't have this problem. I can sit down and just start writing, or flip to a new page and write there. Because pages have a natural order, my notes end up in a nice chronological ordering. Each page is individually coherent, and its easy to reorder & delete pages later if I want to throw away some of my rough note pages. And each page is screen sized. There's no ambiguity about how big each pen is, or what the right zoom level is for something I've written. Each page fits on the screen. The next page is a swipe away.
Infinite canvases are better for connecting disperate ideas - like mind mapping. But the notes I've taken in goodnotes feel easier to read later, or screen share and present. I find I tend to go back and read them more often.
- jwr 4y agoGoodnotes is a great app, I've been using it for years. But it has two big usability issues: 1. Your documents are not organized spatially. They are dumped in a way that is convenient for application developers to implement. This means that every time you launch an app with an idea in your head, you spend time and mental effort on finding the document that you want to open. By the time you get there, the idea is often gone. 2. Its "paper" isn't screen-sized. Seems silly? Perhaps — but on my iPad Pro about 10% of screen space is wasted on "margins" just because their "paper" isn't the right size. If you don't implement an infinite canvas, that's fine, but then provide a way to quickly take notes on "pages" without zooming, panning, or otherwise fiddling, and provide a way to use all of the screen. I feel like we underestimate the power of simple and the power of spatial organization.
- josephg 4y agoYep. I also tried to use it recently to draw some diagrams for a blog post and discovered (to my horror) that there's no nice way to export the diagrams for publishing. I'd like either SVGs or, failing that, PNGs with transparency. The only options are as a series of JPEGs (with a white background) or a PDF. What a hassle.
- Tagbert 4y agoAre the PDF exports vector or bitmaps? Update: Just did a quick test and it appears that the PDF export is a vector output. You can open and edit it in Affinity Designer and likely other graphic programs and then export from then to SVG or something else.