5 ms·
There is a simple solution, but nobody will like it. Give the teachers a base pay. Then, they get a percentage of a bonus amount. The percentage is calculated
by WalterBright 4y ago
There is a simple solution, but nobody will like it.
Give the teachers a base pay. Then, they get a percentage of a bonus amount. The percentage is calculated based on the percentage of the students in the teacher's class meeting grade level standard at the end of the year. The teachers will figure out how to teach them. Money, especially if the bonus could be 20-30000, is a big motivator, but those bonuses are still cheaper than the failed programs usually tried.
Q: what if a teacher gets assigned a poorly performing cadre of students?
A: assign the kids randomly to teachers. The ups and downs will average out.
Q: what if the teacher cheats on the year end tests?
A: have an independent authority do the testing
Q: what if the teacher teaches to the test rather than anything valuable?
A: change the test so that passing it reflects learning
- saagarjha 4y ago> change the test so that passing it reflects learning How?
- WalterBright 4y ago2 + 2 = _ Fill in the blank.
- saagarjha 4y agoI’m not sure I understand what you mean. Is this an example of a question you feel teaches understanding?
- WalterBright 4y agoI don't understand how one can do arithmetic with no understanding of it. It's an example of a question that tests understanding. How would you determine if a student understands arithmetic?
- saagarjha 4y agoYou memorize the answers? Like, I had an entire week of third grade where they wanted us to do a table of 100 basic arithmetic problems, and it was really a test of whether you remembered that 8+9=17 rather than some sort of actual understanding of what “eight”, “nine” and “the combination of eight and nine” meant. I think arithmetic in general is actually one of the most difficult things to test understanding of, because there’s not a whole lot of understanding involved. It’s kind of axiomatic for the rest of math to build on top of. I would attribute “understanding” more to being able to synthesize useful results from properties like addition and subtraction being inverses of each other, being able to form relationships like “two small numbers added together are always less than two big numbers added together”, etc. But I did actually start this thread by asking how you would test for this, because I believe doing so is quite difficult. I don’t think I’ve seen many a test that people haven’t tried to game without “understanding” the subject.
- orlp 4y agoFor the longest time we (and in many places probably still do) literally taught students multiplication tables. That is, hardcoded answers for a * b with a, b <= 10. As soon a double digit integers are involved - tough shit.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you don't memorize the tables, you're going to have a tough time multiplying N-digit numbers. Besides, work enough arithmetic problems and you'll inadvertently memorize them anyway.
- WalterBright 4y agoSo you've memorized what 23+69 is?
- Rufbdbskrufb473 4y agoIf you randomize the types of questions enough every year, the best preparation for passing would be to just teach the general subject.
- WalterBright 4y agoYup. I always thought that people who spent all this effort cheating would expend less effort if they just bothered to learn the stuff. And besides, you get a bonus from having a bit of pride that you did it honestly.
- diob 4y agoCheck out "The Tyranny of Metrics" book for why this won't work. Weird to say it's simple.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe current metric is gamed pretty thoroughly, wouldn't you say? Besides, businesses operate on metrics every day. It's the bottom line. It works. You just have to pick metrics that are the goal of the organization.
- dmix 4y agoI’m sure I already know the answers from experience after becoming obsessed with KPIs as the solution to startup problems to seeing how companies just game vanity metrics. But could you provide some examples of why it doesn’t work in a school environment? My best guess: It is possible to weed out non-productive KPIs, they are still extremely useful for breaking down reality distortion fields, but it takes an honest and thoughtful person with a good grasp of both the business and how the stats are collected - combined with management buy in. I have a feeling highly bureaucratic gov organizations won’t have either the talent, iterative approach, nor incentives to actually find the right metrics that matter.
- WalterBright 4y agoMath tests are hard to game.
- hattmall 4y agoIt's too variable. A teacher has a variety of classes with a variety of children that changes completely every year. The outliers are enough to impact the metrics significantly but leaving them out paints an unclear picture. As well you have additional high variability of an individual students performance at any given time. This variability is greatest in the non-outliers which matter the most.
- WalterBright 4y agoI answered that in the OP.
- hattmall 4y agoJust let teachers do whatever they want with periodic evaluations, if the teachers suck move them around. Do the same with students. The shuffle will get the good teachers with good students.
- cauthon 4y agoEven simpler, but less likely to be popular. Pay teachers competitive (six figure) salaries, put a cap on student:teacher ratio (20:1, or even less?), and get rid of tenure.
- erosenbe0 4y agoUhh,teachers in major cities make 100k with 10-15 years experience on 180 contract days per year, and also get pension. Student:teacher ratio is below 20 in all major cities.
- cauthon 4y agoNot sure how you’re defining major cities, but starting salaries in the top 5 CoL cities are definitely not near $100k Boston $60k https://btu.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Salary-Grids.pdf https://btu.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Salary-Grids.pdf Seattle $65k https://www.seattleschools.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Certificated-Non-Supervisory-2021-22.pdf https://www.seattleschools.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Ce... LA $55k https://achieve.lausd.net/cms/lib/CA01000043/Centricity/domain/280/salary%20tables/T_Table_Annual.pdf https://achieve.lausd.net/cms/lib/CA01000043/Centricity/doma... SF $60k https://uesf.org/members/2017-2020-contract/ https://uesf.org/members/2017-2020-contract/ NYC $60k https://cdn-blob-prd.azureedge.net/prd-pws/docs/default-source/default-document-library/salary-schedules/may-14-2021-salary-schedule-teachers.pdf?sfvrsn=5dc5670_5 https://cdn-blob-prd.azureedge.net/prd-pws/docs/default-sour... Looks like you can add $10-20k with a masters and a few grand per year of tenure. Key word in my comment was “competitive”, which these aren’t for trained/skilled workers with other options.
- erosenbe0 4y agoIn the most expensive locations I would agree that it is not very competitive, and the same goes for entry-level police and other needed services. (Though nimbys reap what they sow here.) The entire education system is inefficient and anachronistic. School should run all year, simply emphasizing more sports and nature in the summer. Then you don't need to fit the career and compensation structure of the personnel into seven contract hours a day working 180 days a year. You can pay a true salary, end regression and lower criminality in the summer, while also helping working parents be more productive. Don't get me started though! College is even dumber. 36 weeks of class per year for 18 year-olds? Wtf. Kids graduate high school and ought to be in class or an apprenticeship the next Monday. Most young adults go to non-selective universities to get simple credentials like nursing or education. It's not about fancy internships at Google or other nonsense like gap years. That's relatively decadent stuff most young adults can't indulge in.
- mikebenfield 4y agoThis is a remarkably bad idea. No, the differences between students will definitely not “average out” at this scale. And how do you expect to handle poorly performing schools as a whole? Do you not expect the quality of teachers there to just plummet?
- WalterBright 4y agoPaying people for results works very, very well in the private sector. Why wouldn't it work in the public sector? > the differences between students will definitely not “average out” at this scale Of course it will. Assigning kids at random will produce an average over time. > how do you expect to handle poorly performing schools as a whole? The teachers in that poorly performing school will have a powerful incentive to do better. > Do you not expect the quality of teachers there to just plummet? I expect if you dangle $20-30000 if they do better, they'll do better. Monetary incentives work. And in businesses that pay commissions, the people who are good at getting those commissions (i.e. they're good at their job) want to be there. They're not satisfied with just a salary. High commissions attract the best.
- awjlogan 4y agoThe problem with saying that teachers will have an incentive to make a bad school better is that they can not hope to compensate for massive socioeconomic differences. If you pay solely on absolute results, all the good teachers are going to go to schools with favourable intake profiles, which are likely to be strongly correlated with house prices. This would be a further driver of inequality. There would have to be a realistic scaling factor, looking at improvement, perhaps, rather than absolute results.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe current system is an abject failure. Time for some old ideas that work, like paying for results achieved.
- 4y ago
- yamtaddle 4y agoNobody likes it because it has a ton of problems. Jumping to "my solution's just too edgy, and that's why nobody will like it" before having a good grasp on the issue is perhaps premature.
- WalterBright 4y agoEverything has problems. But it will be far better than the current system. > edgy It's not about edginess. It's about the public teachers union that blocks any and all attempts at merit pay.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jhanschoo 4y ago> Q: what if a teacher gets assigned a poorly performing cadre of students? > A: assign the kids randomly to teachers. The ups and downs will average out. This punishes students who can't get streamed to classes that challenge them at a degree appropriate for their aptitude.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe current system punishes them much worse.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 4y agoIf you can write a test (or other combination of measurements, metrics etc) that actually measures whether someone is well educated, and tells us how much of that is down to the teacher and not the overall school, family, home life, culture, etc, and cannot be gamed etc, then you will have solved one of the worlds longest standing social issues. Then you will just need to convince people to vote to (more than) double what we pay teachers (and eat the resulting tax rises) to fund the resulting bonuses for at least some of them. Clearly grades are worthless here. But that doesn't mean there is a better system. Especially given what people are willing to pay and the complex other inputs...
- WalterBright 4y agoComplaining that tests don't measure anything is popular, but tests work.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI didn't say they don't measure anything. Just that they don't measure everything...
- idontwantthis 4y agoBetter idea: fully fund schools and stop blaming teachers.
- cafard 4y agoAbout 25 years ago, The Washington Post carried an item on Algebra I grades in the high schools of Montgomery County, Maryland. In the west of the county, one needed to score at or above 90% to get an A in Algebra. Mid-county the cutoff for an A was in the mid-70s. Assigning the kids randomly to teachers, across schools, is called "busing", which has never been popular among prosperous families--just the people likely to turn out at school board elections. (Not that I don't see the appeal of your proposal.)
- WalterBright 4y agoModern public schools cannot stand elitism like gifted programs. The Seattle school district eliminated all gifted programs because they were inequitable. My proposal caters to that desire for equity. Random assignments to teachers.
- lostmsu 4y agoThere are gifted programs on the east side. Also, what about Running Start?