3 ms·
> When policy drives such a focus on this testing ... it can lead to a dehumanizing of the classroom and in a way limiting what students can learn because every
by rayiner 4y ago
> When policy drives such a focus on this testing ... it can lead to a dehumanizing of the classroom and in a way limiting what students can learn because everybody is focused on test prep rather than teaching students more holistically,” said Doron Zinger, director of the CalTeach teacher preparation program at UC Irvine.
Do folks like Zinger seriously believe that these kids are actually getting a good education, and the problem is just that the tests aren’t measuring the right things?
- WalterBright 4y ago> seriously believe Of course not. They're just never going to admit they're doing a bad job, and need a messenger to shoot.
- awaythrow321 4y agoThey're never going to admit they're not allowed to do a good job. Throwing the worst-behaving 5% out of the classroom and forcing some discipline on the remaining 95% would both get better results, and make the teachers enjoy their jobs more.
- erosenbe0 4y agoBad behavior is an issue but not the primary issue. The big issue is allowing deficits to stack year on year without comprehensive intervention involving discipline and diligence from all stakeholders.
- rayiner 4y agoBad behavior is a huge issue. The only reason we pay for private school is because our school is allowed to counsel out misbehaved students. Our studious, obedient daughter would never get equal attention from her teachers in a typical public school.
- erosenbe0 4y agoYes, the public systems are struggling to manage behavior and iphone addicted parents are not helping the situation. Kids with bad behavior deserve equal attention but should not be sucking all the air out of the classroom, which unfortunately is happening all too often. When that happens ideally there are interventions, discipline, social work, IEPs, medical therapy, and alternate placements. Obviously we cannot ignore such kids (largely boys) or they'll be on their way to prison or otherwise an economic drag on society. I worry especially about all the boys I see who are just not getting out with dad, grandpa, or brothers to get some solid lessons and hard knocks on the playground.
- topspin 4y ago> Do folks like Zinger seriously believe Folks like Zinger believe whatever the narrative prescribed by the institution in which they're very comfortably ensconced require them to believe. In this case we're dealing with someone that directs the education of teachers and awards UC Irvine credits, which automatically deliver higher teacher compensation as per their union contracts. You won't be surprised to learn that these courses are rather easy and short; typically just sitting through a few lectures. It's a racket, and you're listening to a racketeer.
- dmix 4y agoThe solution is clearly more holistic aka qualitative and subjective testing, requiring more administrators who can use their expertise to carefully evaluate their local group of students based on [current important skills of the day]. And those administrators can have individual administrative bodies for each state/county. Then the universities can take the brunt of the responsibility for figuring out which of those bodies are actually doing their job or not, in addition to the test scores they pump out. Which means, yes, more administrators.
- topspin 4y ago> Which means, yes, more administrators. If the solution were more administrators the US would lead the world in test scores, setting new records annually.
- dmix 4y agoEngland seems to be beating the US on one key relevant metric: https://www.statista.com/chart/11058/bachelor-tuition-fees-international-comparison/ https://www.statista.com/chart/11058/bachelor-tuition-fees-i...