5 ms·
When US bans something to protect itself, that’s OK, but when another country does it, it’s a suppression of free speech and freedoms and whatnot. Doesn’t this
by bayindirh 4y ago
When US bans something to protect itself, that’s OK, but when another country does it, it’s a suppression of free speech and freedoms and whatnot.
Doesn’t this sound a bit off?
- idontpost 4y ago[dead]
- adamsmith143 4y agoIntent matters. The reason why China bans foreign social media is much different than the reason we would want to ban TikTok.
- medellin 4y agoLittle different when the CCP is ok the board of the company and controls its decisions. Look at what happened to Didi when they did one thing without consent from them. I don’t think you are comparing the same things.
- bioemerl 4y agoDoes anyone consider the EU passing all sorts of data privacy laws and putting regulations on American companies as censorship? No, just regular protectionism and it doesn't get too much flack. The problem with China is that they are actually suppressing free speech and freedoms and whatnot. Do you disagree that this is the case?
- imperfect_blue 4y agoTit-for-tat makes perfect sense from a game theory point of view, even ignoring the egregious abuse of data for nefarious purposes by the CCP.
- acchow 4y agoIf China decided to ban a US company for using its app to locate Chinese citizens, I'd say that is totally fair.
- kranke155 4y agoChina has banned all western social media I think?
- kranke155 4y agoWe’re not in the world of what ifs and ethical debates. We are in a world where our strategic enemy has a foothold on our digital lives and will likely use it against us. This is evidence. We should treat our enemies as enemies. China doesn’t consider itself to be in a friendly competition for dominance. Neither should we.
- 8note 4y agoWe're in a world where Facebook has already used it's power to influence who wins western elections. The enemy was here before TikTok has existed, china is catching up quickly to the western tools for dominance
- throwaway742 4y agoWhy is China our enemy?
- rightbyte 4y agoRemind me. Why should the rest of the world put up with Google and Facebook? Free trade for me but not for thee? This hypocrisy is maddening. Companies need to comply with PI laws. Then there is no need to find excuses to keep approved spyware companies operating depending on where the stockholders live.
- _djo_ 4y ago> Why should the rest of the world put up with Google and Facebook? Free trade for me but not for thee? This hypocrisy is maddening. It doesn't have to, and other countries have imposed restrictions and even outright bans on US tech firms. The EU being the prime example.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoGood things are good, evil things are evil. This detached observer way of looking at the world is mind boggling. There is nothing contradictory about arguing for the good and arguing against the evil. I think this mindset stems from a fundamental uncertainty in our values, and conclude that our values are just as good as any others. It’s simply not true. No. TikTok is run by a state hostile to the ideals of freedom and our western way of life. That alone is enough of an argument for banning it: because of values are good, and we don’t want their values. If they are not willing to go above and beyond to demonstrate they will do the same, then ban it. They are not entitled to our attention, our children's attention, or any of our other resources.
- mardifoufs 4y agoYour comment only makes sense since you are an american. The entire premise of your argument completely false a part when you have actually experienced what the "goodness" of america, say in the middle east, means.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoNo, it makes sense because my values are good and I happen to be American. This is exactly my point. You’re saying “because the US has done bad things in the past, it has no moral standing to do good in the future”. A lot of bad happened in the Middle East, some parts caused by the US, so that means we can’t ban the evils of China in our country and minimize their harms abroad? Try this: focus on increasing the good in the world. Don’t be hamstrung by “well the US has done bad things before”. “We can’t do good anymore because we’ve done bad before” is not a valid argument. And no, none of this makes China equally good. It’s not your job to weigh all the countries of the world on some balance to decide who’s been the most good. That’s that detached observer mindset again, and it does nothing but occupy your mind and sap your agency while bad things continue. Your job is to increase the good in the world. If you don’t care to do so, then get out of the way
- lmm 4y agoThe idea that US is good and China is evil is absurd. Other Americans do far more to destroy "ideals of freedom and our western way of life" than China does - hell, I'm pretty sure that with the current US polarisation, both sides would say they have more in common with China than with their US opponents - and they'd be right. Take any concept of "freedom" or "way of life" that you care for, and half the US is currently against it. TikTok is a bogeyman that has done nothing to Americans that Americans weren't already doing to themselves.
- LarryMullins 4y agoUS soldiers used rifles. Nazi soldiers also used rifles. Oh the hypocrisy! Give me a break.